
Dalit | Tech & Teaching | Educate. Organise. Act. | #StartDalitBusinesses #HireDalits | I follow only my conscience | #JaiBhim
India
Joined March 2019
- Tweets2.3K
- Following0
- Followers351
- Likes808
Radha retweeted
Just like how he mocked the death of 44 Dalits in Keezhvenmani.
And how he created a OBC anti Dalit haven in Tamilandu.
Or how he said that Babasaheb Ambedkar sold himself to the Brahmins and created a Brahminical constitution.
Or how he accused Babasaheb’s wife of poisoning him .
And how every year he burnt the constitution.
Or how he used his caste name “Naicker” until he died while the state called him Periyar.
Self respect? Really?
Thanthai Periyar taught us one key lesson: never accept injustice simply because it is old, powerful, or called tradition.
Question. Reason. Resist inequality. Stand for self-respect and human dignity.
Greetings on his birthday
#Periyar #ThanthaiPeriyar #SelfRespect #SocialJustice
Radha retweeted
Sachin Tendulkar has finally spoken on the student protests, and I had to read his note twice: once as a fan and once as an editor. The fan was disappointed, but the editor realised that this was a textbook specimen of the kind of writing that George Orwell warned about in his essay “Politics and the English Language”.
The essay was written in 1946, but it might well have been written yesterday about this very statement. Orwell’s point was that when people want to hide something, they stop using plain words and reach instead for the passive voice, for fog, for phrases that sound like they mean something while meaning nothing at all.
Consider the line, where students are disappointed that “their hard work hasn’t been rewarded”. Rewarded by whom, and denied by whom? There was a paper leak, which means somebody leaked it, some institution failed to prevent it, and an official presides over that institution. Yet none of them appears in the statement, and neither does the leak itself. A crime with identifiable custodians has been turned into something that simply happened to lakhs of children through nobody's fault.
Then comes the list of those who must set things right: parents, teachers, friends, relatives, schools and administrators. If you read that list again slowly, you will notice it covers everyone in India except the people the students are actually protesting against, which is to say the NTA, the education ministry and the government. When everyone is responsible, nobody is, and that is not an accident of drafting. It was engineered to deflect blame.
There is also a quiet sentence buried in the middle. “A society which prioritises outcomes over effort will seek shortcuts over meritocracy” is a line about those who take shortcuts, meaning the cheat. So a note on protests around paper leaks ends up gently lecturing the leaked-upon about honesty. His father’s lovely lesson—that failure is okay but cheating is not—is again aimed squarely at individuals, while the scandal and protests right now are about institutions that failed them.
The rest of the statement is what Orwell called ready-made strips of words, glued together. Full of dreams and energy, fuel to our success, safeguard their aspirations. Nobody can disagree with any of it, which is precisely the point, for this is prose engineered so that no one in power will find a single sentence to object to.
What an actual position would have looked like is a single sentence in the active voice: The government must find and punish those who leaked the paper, and fix the system that allowed it. He wrote 160+ words to avoid writing that one.
Here’s Orwell’s full essay for those interested:
bioinfo.uib.es/~joemiro/RecE…
Radha retweeted
A poem by K. Kasturi Rangan, founder of Kanaiyazhi, and a long time correspondent of the New York Times in Delhi.
கடவுளும் கவர்மெண்டும் ஒன்று
அதைத் தூற்றாதே; பழி சேரும்
உனக்கு. அதற்கு
ஆயிரம் கண்கள்: காதுகள்.
ஆனால் குறையென்றால்
பார்க்காது கேட்காது
கை நீளும்; பதினாயிரம்
கேட்கும், பிடுங்கும்.
தவமிருந்தால்
கொடுக்கும்.
கவர்மெண்ட் பெரும் கடவுள்
அதைப் பழிக்காதே
பழித்தால்
வருவது
இன்னும்
அதிகம்
கவர்ன்மெட்தான்.
[Couldn't find a translation, so here's a rough one]
God and government are the same.
Do not speak ill of it; you will face
the consequence. For, it has
a thousand eyes and ears.
Still, when it comes to your complaints,
It will neither see nor hear.
It will stretech its hands; and demand
a lot; grab.
If you perform penance,
It will give.
Government is indeed
a supreme God.
Do not revile it.
If you revile it,
you will get
more
government.
Radha retweeted
Is the Goondas Act Being Used Against SCs and Minorities?
===
The decision by the Government of Tamil Nadu to revoke the application of the Goondas Act against @SavukkuOfficial Savukku Shankar is a welcome step. In a similar vein, the Government of Tamil Nadu should review the cases of all individuals currently detained under the preventive detention legislation known as the Goondas Act. This is because the 2023 report on prisons, published by the Government of India, reveals that Tamil Nadu accounts for the highest number of arrests made under preventive detention laws (the Goondas Act) across the entire country.
Out of the 3,916 preventive detention detainees across India's 28 states, a staggering 1,354 individuals are held in preventive custody in Tamil Nadu alone. Tamil Nadu ranks first in the utilization of the Goondas Act—accounting for 34.6% of the total number of such detainees nationwide. Notably, the Government of Tamil Nadu holds more individuals in preventive custody than even Jammu and Kashmir, a region facing significant threats of terrorism.
Among the prisoners held in preventive custody, 10% are Muslims (136 individuals), 10% are Christians (133 individuals), and 571 individuals (42.1%) belong to the Scheduled Castes. This is a situation unparalleled in any other state across the country.
I respectfully request the Honorable Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu @CMOTamilnadu / @TVKVijayHQ to conduct an inquiry into whether the preventive detention legislation—known as the Goondas Act—has been deliberately utilized against religious minorities and Scheduled Castes, and to take appropriate action based on the findings. Furthermore, I urge that steps be taken to ensure that this law is not subjected to any further misuse in the future.
— Ravikumar M.P.
Radha retweeted
Appeal
The reports currently being circulated, claiming that the VCK is seeking various positions and making demands, are entirely contrary to the truth. We request the media not to lend credence to such reports. We further urge the media not to become complicit in attempts to malign the VCK.
- Dr D.Ravikumar
General Secretary , VCK
Radha retweeted
I think this is a very good explanation of complexity in medicine. (Or anthro-complexity, as Dave Snowden would put it).
My two-bit.
To understand why medicine is so complex, let's make a crude simplifying assumption that there are only 100 biomarkers that are important (in reality there are vastly more). Let's also crudely assume each market is allowed only two values. That gives us 2^100 possibilities, which is about 10^30. That is vastly more than humans that ever lived. And this is with the extremely over-simplified model. We face a practical infinity of possibilities.
In reality, no two patients are ever really alike. No statistical model can give you very high confidence on how to treat. That is why AI can never treat patients, because human doctors exercise something called "clinical judgment".
That judgment is what enables a doctor to tell us "this is not a serious issue, get good sleep" vs "this definitely needs deeper investigation". That judgment is hard. Often they cannot even explain why they arrived at this but great doctors have that intuition. The entire Big Medicine is about systematically dismantling clinical judgment and convert doctors to mere "protocol pushers". Great doctors resist this.
Now on top of the measurable biomarkers, there is the unmeasurable factor called "mental state". Every good doctor knows a positive mental state in a patient leads to far better clinical outcomes. That is why good doctors practise compassionate medicine, not just numbers based medicine. I know an outstanding skin doctor in Chennai who prescribed me medicine for my very-itchy Eczema that I had endured for months, and he also told me "try to avoid stress and it may go away, and you may not even need the medicines I prescribed". I consciously reduced my stress level and the problem went away without medicine. That is a truly great doctor.
What does it have to do with autism-vaccine connection? As my crude numerical analysis showed, we have the problem of N=1 way too often in medicine and that is even more true for autism where each kid is truly unique, and that is why statistics are mostly useless and clinical judgment is mostly all we have. We cannot have broad sweeping mandates, definitely not broad vaccine mandates. Each doctor has to exercise their judgment with their patient. And they have to listen to the patient concerns first.
What Big Medicine is about is to try to reduce medicine to be a pure statistical science and it is not. Conditions like autism do not fit that paradigm at all.
That is the battle here. At its core it is not just an autism battle, it is a philosophy of medicine battle.
I pledge to keep fighting this fight because I nearly wanted to commit suicide at one one point in my life. Just this morning, a depressed parent approached me for advice and that started my X thread today.
I urge intelligent doctors to debate this philosophy of medicine issue. I will not respond to the arrogant "stay in your lane" types.
Radha retweeted
PSA: Don't trust doctors who don't read the "evidence" they cite.
Replying to @pranesh
Sigh. It turns out some doctors make claims about nutritional causality on the basis of low quality, heavily biased non-RCT evidence, and can't bear being called out on it.
doi.org/10.1001/jama.2018.11…
doi.org/10.1093/advances/nmy…
doi.org/10.1007/s10654-019-0…
teapawt.org/theliverdr/status/1803…
Radha retweeted
😂
Today is Periyar's birth anniversary.
#Periyar imagined, not a Dravidian counter-image of India, but a kind of anti-nation, a society ordered by rationality and transparency instead of lineage and myth.
🧵[1/11] Read Ashik Kahina’s April 2021 essay on why the father of the Dravidian movement's legacy is vital and relevant to the entire country today:
caravanmagazine.in/books/rea…
Radha retweeted
This fetishization of "consent" reminds me: No one took my consent to give birth to me; No one asked me if I wanted to be born. But why should they?
Why should existing language speakers have some sort of control over whether their language is used by others?
Radha retweeted
Here's a reasonably good summary of the limitation of the study.
teapawt.org/ARanganathan72/status/…
Radha retweeted
Replying to @pratyasharath
The key message of Roosevelt's quote is not that criticism is banal and pointless.
The key message is critics often don't have skin in the game. A doer - "whose face is marred by dust and sweat and blood" - has.
It doesn't apply to all doers, and not to all critics.
Skin!
Radha retweeted
Replying to @Article14live @iyerkavi
Sure. The protests will continue till these thugs are not punished for weaponising tractors and terrorising people.
Imagine if someone had done this in London instead of Delhi…
Radha retweeted
Replying to @radharep @PSainath_org
Maybe unlike you and your friends, some journalists think Dalit lives matter too
teapawt.org/radharep/status/146174…
Radha retweeted
Replying to @PSainath_org
Maybe, because they saw people running for life with tractors chasing them.
#Violence
teapawt.org/radharep/status/146163…
Radha retweeted
Replying to @rumlolarum
Another person using a Dalit story to push their agenda. 🤦🏽♀️
As a Dalit who teaches Dalit kids science maths and IT, I can tell you the ‘exit’ gives us choice.
People who are flooded with choices can never understand those of don’t have that luxury.
teapawt.org/rumlolarum/status/1428…
Radha retweeted
The @Sequoia_India Spark program does precisely this. There's never been a better time to start a company. With early $$ + A class mentorship + access to the right networks = let's change those numbers above.
APPLY NOW
teapawt.org/Sequoia_India/status/1…
Different perspectives & experiences help drive innovation. That’s why gender diversity is so important. We also recognise we need to do more to spark a change in our ecosystem.
Today, we’re proud to announce we’re expanding Sequoia Spark to do just that.
sequoiacap.com/india/build/s…
Radha retweeted
Thanks, Radha. You can start on this page that curates our India insights: mckinsey.com/featured-insigh…
And might want to sign up for our (free) alert/newsletter on India (and many other topics/regions) here, so you won't future India @McKinsey content: mckinsey.com/user-registrati…
Radha retweeted
Replying to @radharep
lot of (at least US) j-schools have been offering data journalism courses for a while now, and many newsrooms that are foresighted and can afford it have trained editors and teams. And folks like @KnightCenterUT offer online courses like these regularly knightcenter.utexas.edu/knig…























