
Hawkeyes! Retired School Admin @locknowapp Helping to improve safety. #education #school #church #business https://teapawt.org/t.co/wat4t5a0gt
Joined August 2011
- Tweets8K
- Following1.7K
- Followers338
- Likes25.1K
Doughertyr retweeted
Nobody can seriously believe the CFP Selection Committee should have this much discrepancy from AP voters.
Data shows the CFP committee is boosting the SEC more than ever, and it isn't close
✍️ cbssports.com/college-footba…
Doughertyr retweeted
Data shows the CFP committee is boosting the SEC more than ever, and it isn't close
✍️ cbssports.com/college-footba…
The Great Awakening
ESPN has effectively told Iowa “you have two losses but you’re not a big enough brand or in the SEC so your season is over”
Alabama is 8-2 with 0 top 15 wins and 1 win against a SEC opponent with a positive record but they are ranked 3rd.
I can’t imagine the committee even enjoys this. Rather than complain, what is the solution?
Why not have the the coaches, the conferences, the commissioners get together and decide on metrics that they value. Make it democratic and vote on it. Then back test it in recent years with heavy criticism and debate.
When you feel good about the system, make it open source for everyone to see. This way we can all potential for bias. If we don’t like it? We’d only have ourselves to blame, and maybe a majority vote can bring us back to the drawing board to tweak the metrics for the next year. A truly open and democratic process feels like the proper solution here.
There’s just to many incentives right now that conflict with the rankings. There’s tens of millions of $$$ on the line. There’s marketing on the line getting to call UGA v Ole Miss a “top 10 matchup” but Notre dame (#11 at the time) vs Miami (#1) can’t say the same.
Seems small in the moment, but it isn’t. It shapes our perspective in the near and long term.
There will never be a point where people don’t complain and get angry with the rankings, but at least if we had an open source, democratic, data based ranking system we’d be in a better place.
Doughertyr retweeted
Ignoring the rankings and any individual opinion on them:
ESPN owns the rights to the College Football Playoff, a hugely profitable, prestige sports property. It is a crown jewel for the network
ESPN has also an exclusive broadcasting partnership w/one of the two most lucrative, powerful conference affiliations in the sport, the revenues from which allow the network to run its operations. Another crown jewel
ESPN's CFP is seeded by a Committee that does all of its work in the dark, much of it, at a minimum, debatable. That Committee steadfastly declines to make its process public, even announcing here that it is so complex as to be not "feasible" to explain to the public
As if by magic, ESPN's conference partner is treated as so extraordinary that none of the standards applied to other leagues apply to them. It manifests as though there's college football, and ESPN's college football partner, an elevated iteration of the sport entitled to all kinds of considerations—including being lavished with praise in complete non-sequitur fashion during game broadcasts of other conferences
That is a ludicrous, almost cartoonish conflict of interest. Even if everything is on the up and up, why is this being allowed to happen? The optics alone are abysmal
Break up the CFP, bring in competition, develop open-source, replicable metrics. Do everything in the sunshine
Doughertyr retweeted
We use deeply flawed metrics in college football. The obvious conflict of interest we're willing to accept in this rankings process is incredible. There's a huge problem with how we perceive big-brand teams. We expect them to be good, so when they show even a shred of potential, we overrate them.
Doughertyr retweeted
"Nobody on the College Football Playoff Selection Committee respects Iowa..
Putting a bunch of 6-4 SEC teams in the Top 25 props up everybody in that conference..
Iowa has the best scoring defense in the nation and they're playing pretty good ball" ~ @tyschmit
#PMSLive
Doughertyr retweeted
At the end of the day, they want the biggest brands in and will do the mental gymnastics to justify it. If Iowa and Oregon swapped résumés, there’s no chance this plays out the same way. They’d discount Iowa’s win over OSU without Sayin and hammer them for the Illinois loss. 🤷🏻♂️
Doughertyr retweeted
Appreciate the comment but also agree we lost to Purdue… and yes we did beat Oregon by two scores and a one score loss to UCLA but we don’t belong in top 25… like the other 6-4 teams that have a loss that doesn’t fit the narrative. Insanely entertaining to be honest. Great time to be in #CFBPlayoff talks 🤡🏈🤡
Doughertyr retweeted
Replying to @EffzehKollumbus @slmandel
We don’t debate this in the NFL. If you lose a game, you are punished because you drop in the standings. Plain and simple. Doesn’t matter if you played everyone in the AFC South or not. But in CFB, wins and losses are trumped by offensive output first, then brand, then arguing how to fabricate elevating those brands when they lose too many games.
Doughertyr retweeted
I'm not sure any team is getting hosed as hard as the Iowa #Hawkeyes are in the CFP rankings. Absolute disaster from this committee.
Winning or losing games doesn't matter if your brand isn't what the networks want, huh?
Doughertyr retweeted
We need to eliminate the committee and this invitational tournament that masquerades as a playoff. It’s so obviously rigged they should be embarrassed
Doughertyr retweeted
This might be a good time to remind everyone that 9 of the 13 CFP committee members have @SEC ties.
@CFBPlayoff wants no part of equal representation. There’s an agenda to be had.
Doughertyr retweeted
For people that wonder how KF can maintain a high level of success for such a long period of time with fewer financial resources than other programs, this explains it beautifully. Hard to put a price tag on the culture KF has built. We are lucky to have him as our HC!
Iowa OL Kade Pieper said he will not make an NFL decision until after the season, saying he wants to be where his feet are, but added this about @CoachBarnett_OL and the Hawkeye program:
“I love coach Barnett, coach Ferentz, I love this program. I wouldn't want to leave for anything else because this place is like home to me. ... They took a chance on me, and I've just loved it here ever since I've been here. The group, our room is just so special in every single way.”
hawkcentral.com/videos/sport…
Doughertyr retweeted
Not good. littlevillagemag.com/univers…































