
Associate Professor Transplant and Cellular Therapy Program @Huntsmancancer @UofUHealth #bmtsm #leusm #tcellrx #healthtech Tweets ≠ endorsements/medical advice
Salt Lake City, UT
Joined April 2007
- Tweets2.7K
- Following570
- Followers1K
- Likes9.4K
And even with early and best alloHCT practices, challenging to obtain long-term survival in my opinion compared to age-matched peers with non-SDS myeloid disorders.
In an international cohort of 865 patients, Shwachman–Diamond syndrome was associated with a high risk of myeloid cancer and poor survival. Early hematopoietic stem-cell transplantation for high-risk features had a potential benefit. Full study results: nej.md/4AtaUUg
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Not a word from the “nation’s doctor” on the several overlapping food recalls, generational infectious disease outbreaks, millions newly uninsured, or of course, basic clarity on vaccination as school begins anew.
Dismal abdication of basic responsibility for a role that could be so consequential.
Drowning can happen quickly, but taking simple steps around the water can help keep everyone safer as we enjoy the final weeks of summer.
Hear from Dr. Haridopolos, Director of National Health Communications for the Office of the Surgeon General and Principal Deputy Assistant Secretary for Health, as she shares important information about drowning prevention and water safety.
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Last year at this time, Health and Human Services Secretary Kennedy terminated 22 mRNA research contracts worth $500 million. Same cost as Trump’s gifted Qatari plane.
Today, Merck and Moderna announced that an experimental breakthrough vaccine treatment — developed through mRNA research previously funded by NIH — has shown signs of preventing cancer from returning or spreading in a study of high-risk melanoma patients.
Thank god the NIH funded this before Kennedy and the Trump administration showed up to degrade America’s health and leadership.
Which Republican senator has the courage to tell Secretary Kennedy that his decisions are making Americans sicker and letting China take the lead on research, science, and technology?
I’ll save you the time and give you the answer: none of them.
nbcnews.com/health/health-ne…
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Let me make a few important qualifications:
1. First and foremost, the COIs: One of the authors is the CEO of Curai Health, which unsurprisingly is a AI physician startup. Another author is the investor in Curai Health.
2. "Published" is actually an overestimation of the qualitative threshold of this "review": This is, in fact and contrary to the paper's claim, NOT a "review" or "of all published articles on AI in medicine since Jan 1 2024." There is no review methodology, databases searched, search queries/strings, inclusion/exclusion criteria, PRISMA structure, risk-of-bias assessments, preregistered protocol, or really anything scientific.
3. Cherry-picked epistemology: When a paper showed physicians or physicians + AI > AI, they rationalize it as "old LLM model" or "sub-optimal prompting." Vice versa is, of course, evidence AI > physician. Its a unidirectional epistemic criteria.
4. Endpoints are proxies rather than real clinical outcomes: Correct diagnosis/appropriate test/guide-line concordant treatment/simulated cost/top-1 diagnosis vs. mortality rate/re-hospitalization rate/adverse drug events/morbidity/healthcare utilization rate
5. The review is misleading: they cite an RCT with their claim that "AI is better at chronic management for conditions including diabetes" but in that RCT before the AI was activated, each patient's diabetes clinician selected the protocol... So in other words, it was a human-based AI management
6. The review is again misleading, and possibly confused: They cite a meta-analysis with their claim that "When AI is better than humans, adding a human can actually make AI performance worse." This paper covered 106 experiments, of which only about 20 were medicine related. And here's the kicker... a human always signed off on the AI-generated medical plans.
tl;dr: Dad funds son's health startup and write an opinion piece. Embarrassingly low scientific comprehension by the authors but they're the equivalent of 'non-technical' in this domain, as they like to say in Silicon Valley, so we'll give them a pass. But, @JAMA_current do better? I get it's a perspective but like... at least make sure the studies cited say what the perspective cites them for?
@CuraiHQ if need some consulting before waging war against physicians, I am open for a curbside peer-review next time
A case for AI alone —autonomous medical care @JAMA_current, by @ZekeEmanuel @vkhosla @nealkhosla @AbeBakerButler
jamanetwork.com/journals/jam…
But this remains unproven; none of the studies were in real world medicine.
We've written about this potential, too. @pranavrajpurkar
gift link
nytimes.com/2025/02/02/opini…
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
I am shocked that @DrJBhattacharya a known #COVID19 denialist and source of misinformation and disinformation would refuse to publish a study that not only doesn’t support his narrative but proves it wrong.
The damage done by those group of individuals is causing irreparable damage to public health
The CDC will not publish a report showing the effectiveness of COVID-19 vaccines. yahoo.com/news/articles/us-c…
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Political censorship has no place in science. Quite ironic that @NIHDirector_Jay who became “famous” for opposing such censorship, now practices it. The @CDCMMWR since 1953 has maintained a reputation as the most rigorously edited and peer-reviewed journal in American public health. Any CDC scientist past or present will attest to that.
Exclusive: The CDC delayed a report showing covid-19 vaccines reduced emergency visits and hospitalizations in healthy adults by half.
The move raises concerns about the Trump administration downplaying vaccine benefits. wapo.st/4tFqKqY
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
🙌 New HemOnc Pulse episode just dropped!
This week, @sagarpatel, of @Huntsmancancer @UofUHealth, joins @RahulBanerjeeMD to discuss recent advances in allogeneic HSCT and strategies to reduce post-transplant complications.
Don't miss it! ➡️ buff.ly/rHUmjMm
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
On behalf of @UofUHematology, join us tomorrow at @UofUMedicine, 9:30 AM to explore exciting Research Opportunities & Academic Careers in Hematology, among an incredible list of speakers! We looking forward to welcoming all interested trainees, including medical students, internal medicine residents and hem/onc fellows. @UofUHealth @UofUInternalMed @huntsmancancer
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
South Asian adults in the US develop cardiovascular disease risk factors earlier than other groups, according to new research from the MASALA cohort study. Here’s what that means for prevention. ja.ma/3NCyudL
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
.@SenBillCassidy - hope you and everyone will read this brilliant piece from @KatherineEban on Casey Means.
Surgeon generals usually represent the very best of the medical community. Means isn’t even a part of it, by her own choosing.
rollingstone.com/politics/po…
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Casey Means is a grifter who dropped out of ENT residency to start a wellness company selling glucose monitors to non-diabetics, a “health app” & paid subscriptions.
She lies about basic science concepts to sell books, where she claims to be a metabolism expert.
1/
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
MAHA “accomplishments” as we approach the SOTU:
-Saunas back!
-Acid rain, back!
-Smog year round: back!
-Measles, back!
-24million + with no healthcare, back!
-Promising new cancer treatments? Gone!
-The best and brightest next gen science talent? Gone!
Let the spin begin!
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
The people of Minnesota and Maine have shown more courage than the major corporate and academic institutions who have bent the knee to Trump’s lawlessness and intimidation.
Your actions are inspiring the world.
The power is with the people and always will be.
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
This response is from our current @NIH Director Jay Bhattacharya who is not a board certified clinician, has never been responsible for the care of patients and never led a public health crisis. Prior to #covid he was focused on economics (not science).
He sits in an ivory tower in the comfort of hindsight and abstraction continuing to minimalize #Covid
He didn’t run hospitals.
He didn’t manage outbreaks.
He didn’t staff ICUs, surge wards, or morgues.
He didn’t hold iPads for dying patients’ families.
He didn’t make real-time decisions with incomplete data while systems were collapsing
He accuses public health leaders of ignoring data, yet his narrative selectively cherry-picks facts divorced from context. In early 2020, the central problem wasn’t arrogance—it was uncertainty, exponential growth, fragile health systems, and the absence of vaccines, therapeutics, or immunity. Decisions weren’t made in an ivory tower; they were made in emergency rooms, on patient wards, ministries of health, and crisis rooms under conditions you never experienced.
He also continues to misrepresent history. #WHO did not “mandate lockdowns.” Countries made sovereign decisions based on local epidemiology, political realities, and system capacity. To rewrite that complexity as a moral failure of public health leaders is not analysis—it’s ideology.
What’s striking is not that mistakes were made—every crisis reveals blind spots. What’s striking is the confidence with which people who never carried responsibility now lecture those who did.
It’s easy to critique from the sidelines. It’s harder to lead when people are dying.
That difference matters and if you want to talk about leadership now, look at today.
#Measles is resurging in the U.S. — entirely preventable — and children are being hospitalized and dying as vaccination coverage falls and disinformation spreads.
So where is your leadership in this crisis?
Where is the accountability?
Where are the results?
From the frontlines, the problem isn’t too much humility from public-health leaders — it’s too much confidence from people who’ve never had to lead at all.
I think this thread is posted in at least a simulacrum of good faith, so I'll give a substantive response.
It is obviously true that in the moment of crisis, leaders face tremendous pressure to do something dramatic to address the crisis, and often those decisions turn out, in retrospect, to be wrong.
In the case of the covid crisis, the problems were confounded by a determined unwillingness of scientific and public health leaders to respond to data -- in real time -- that showed that core assumptions underlying the lockdown strategy were wrong.
Here is a short list of facts about covid that undermined these leaders' core assumptions:
* covid is airborne,
* covid spreads asymptomatically,
* covid infection fatality rate << case fatality rate,
* covid has a sharp age gradient in its infection mortality risk,
* lockdowns cannot suppress covid spread or protect the vulnerable for long,
* lockdowns crush the lives and well-being of children, the poor, and the working class, and almost everyone other than the laptop class
* lockdowns cause a form of psychological terror that guarantee they could never last just two weeks
The WHO and public health leaders got all of these facts wrong in 2020, which I suppose is understandable.
What is not understandable is that these same leaders conducted "devastating takedowns" of even well-credentialed outside critics who pointed out that the WHO's core assumptions were incorrect, and accepted these assumptions as true even as overwhelming data to the contrary emerged in real time.
What is not understandable is the utter confidence that the WHO and public health leaders expressed in these ideas and lockdown policies to the public as the only way to protect the population, going so far as to call for censorship of contrary voices on social media and elsewhere.
The closest analogue I can think of is the set of "best and brightest" advisors who told Pres. LBJ that victory in the Vietnam War was just around the corner, based on a whole host of faulty information.
Leaders who come out of such situations having embraced such a litany of catastrophically failed ideas and policies have a few choices on how to handle the post-crisis era.
1) They can, in good faith, admit their failures and work to reform systems so the disaster never happens again. This would be best, though I would understand why the public would want a new set of leaders to design and implement the reforms. I personally am very happy to work with and learn from public health leaders who choose this option.
2) They can pretend to have done nothing wrong, clinging to power for as long as they can, hoping against hope that history will vindicate them, crushing public trust in the institutions they lead.
3) They can try to pretend they never recommended or adopted the catastrophically failed policies, hoping that the public has a short memory. This is the current strategy that the @WHO is taking.
4) They can appeal to the difficulty of the job of handling a crisis under considerable uncertainty, not in a spirit of reform, but rather as an excuse to avoid responsibility for their failed crisis management. This is the approach that Koopmans is taking in her thread.
I have very little sympathy for the covid crisis leaders who choose options 2, 3, or 4. Their job was to manage the uncertainty with wisdom and humanity, which they failed to do. They cannot, at this juncture, turn around and expect public sympathy because their job was hard, or expect the public to forget their failure. These leaders have destroyed public trust in public health, and should step aside as a new set of public health leaders works to fix the damage they caused.
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Dear Minneapolis,
Words cannot adequately express how in awe I am of you right now.
Your city has been under siege by ICE, deliberately ramping up their aggressions against your friends, family, and neighbors, and yet you persevere.
You've kept it peaceful, yet still powerful.
We grieve with you.
We are ALL Minneapolis now.
Love,
America❤️🇺🇸
I did much of my medical training at @VAMinneapolis and @HennepinHC - horrifying to see illegal ICE activity disrupt clinical operations and now the murder of a member of the healthcare community #ICEOUT
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Awful self-inflicted wound for the nation. Today our federal govt gleefully condemned thousands of kids each year to chronic hepatitis and liver cancer, by denying them a vaccine invented in America, using microbial fermentation, our least expensive and safest technology
Sagar Patel, MD retweeted
Vinay Prasad sent Tracey Høeg dumpster diving in VAERS for pretext to block access to flu vaccines, alter safety standards, end combo vaccines, & hold clinical trials to impossible standards.
@FDACBER is supposed to regulate vaccines, not withhold them. FDA is as broken as CDC.
Big change: FDA to impose strict new vaccine requirements
Vinay Prasad signaled changes to annual flu shots, concurrent vaccines + more
Prasad said his team found link between covid-19 shots and kids' deaths, prompting new approach
w @rachel_roubein
washingtonpost.com/health/20…

































