Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604) profile picture

I ask questions and attempt to spit facts. #georgism #ClassConscious #NeuroDivergent

Joined May 2021
Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)Photo by Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° (@sam_ess604)
❄️ Economic Winter will unlock the biggest tax reform in generations. What if we stopped taxing work, savings and productivity and taxed land rents instead? Henry George proposed it in 1879, during the Second LongWave Winter. Could the Fifth LongWave Spring finally bring his ideas to life?
1
2
12
1,337
You don't hate capitalism. You hate the departure from classical political economy that gave us today's highly financialized, rentier economy, where extracting wealth through ownership has become more lucrative than producing it.
You don’t hate socialism. You hate the version that was explained to you by someone who owns 4 houses and 3 yachts
38
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
Replying to @TyKeynes
My take: I love how every conservative rails against the idea of social credit, then buys a ride to work on Uber or food on Door Dash and leaves a rating tied to the drivers access to work.
2
5
159
6,761
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
We're giving away a Hogwarts Legacy custom wrapped NVIDIA GeForce RTX 5090 to celebrate its official release with DLSS 5 πŸͺ„ To enter: 🟒 Share this post 🟒 Comment #RTXON Terms and Conditions: nvidia.com/en-us/geforce/con…
84,754
72,193
7,710
67,718
6,013,377
Canada's land is valued at $6.56 trillion, including $4.62 trillion in the land beneath our homes. Meanwhile, owning a typical home would consume 52.8% of median household income, and a staggering 83.9% in Vancouver. At a time of entrenched housing unaffordability, it's unacceptable that our governments continue treating housing as a vehicle for wealth accumulation while failing to confront the land rents capitalized into its price. That's why we should be calling for a land value tax, with the revenue redistributed through a universal dividend. At current valuations, a 1% tax on Canada's land base represents roughly $66 billion in annual revenue before exemptions and market adjustments. Unlike a conventional wealth tax, a land value tax directly targets the economic rents that contribute to housing inequality, discourages speculative landholding, and changes the underlying material conditions producing that inequality.
Canada’s 40 billionaires increased their wealth by $95 billion last year. At a time of unprecedented wealth inequality, it’s unacceptable that this budget contains no new measures to make the very richest pay their fair share. That’s why we’ve called for a wealth tax on the very richest that could generate up to $40 billion per year.
1
87
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
Lowering development charges wont make housing cheaper sadly. But it will make land speculators richer: biv.com/news/real-estate/hou…
7
34
2
75
4,130
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
#Georgism Most people implicitly believe in a tradeoff between equality and prosperity. There isn't. reddit.com/r/georgism/commen…
5
23
1
95
1,255
Nah. Land Value Tax or bust. If you're a Marxist, shouldn't you be advocating for remedies that transform the underlying material conditions of the proletariat rather than merely redistributing wealth after it has accumulated? A 100% inheritance tax addresses the intergenerational transmission of wealth, but it leaves one of the underlying mechanisms of wealth accumulation intact: the private appropriation of economic rent. Land Value Tax addresses that mechanism directly. It captures the socially generated value of land for public benefit rather than allowing it to be privately capitalized into ever-increasing land prices. It discourages speculative landholding and changes the distribution of economic rent that would otherwise accrue to landowners at the expense of tenants and productive economic activity. To borrow Nancy Fraser's distinction, inheritance taxation is primarily an affirmative remedy, correcting distributive outcomes without necessarily changing the processes that produce them. LVT is a more structurally transformative approach to land-based inequality because it intervenes in the process of accumulation itself. If the objective is to materially improve the conditions of the working class, why focus exclusively on redistributing accumulated wealth rather than confronting the institutional arrangements that continuously reproduce inequality?
Every Liberal and Marxist should support a 100% inheritance tax.
5
5
54
999
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
#Georgism If only we didn't know exactly what causes this for the last 200 or so odd years... reddit.com/r/georgism/commen…
1
5
23
449
Looks great on paper until you examine the sectoral balances, private credit expansion, and structurally reinforced boom-bust cycles. GDP growth tells us remarkably little about how that prosperity is financed or distributed. If liberalization produces debt-fuelled asset inflation and increasingly fragile private-sector balance sheets, you're mistaking a credit boom for sustainable economic development. A cross-sectional correlation between economic freedom and GDP per capita doesn't establish causation, much less prove that deregulation invariably produces prosperity. The lack of economic literacy among libertarians on Twitter continues to be a trend.
Just bc a fully libertarian society has never existed doesn’t mean the ideology has done nothing. *Every* time a country liberalises (deregulation, free trade), it booms. *Every* time it socialises (price controls, nationalising, heavy regulation), it stagnates. Quit LARPing.
2
145
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
After reading the replies to my original post, I've learned that some libertarians have a much bigger problem than their understanding of economics. Their complete lack of empathy is fucking astonishing. I suggested that paying half your income in rent because the alternative is sleeping in a freezing car isn't exactly a wonderful example of economic freedom. The responses were an extraordinary collection of lectures about voluntary exchange, personal responsibility, property rights, and why homelessness is apparently just another consumer preference. Here are the five most common arguments. 1. It's voluntary because nobody is forcing you. Apparently, choosing between unaffordable rent and sleeping in your car is the expression of liberty. Sure, nobody is holding a gun to your head. But someone with $500 in the bank doesn't have the same bargaining power as someone with $10 million in property. A decision made under financial desperation is still a decision. That doesn't mean the person has meaningful economic freedom. If your definition of liberty includes celebrating someone's choice to freeze in their car, perhaps your philosophy needs some fucking work. 2. Just move, get roommates, buy a house, or sleep in your car. This was my favorite. One person suggested getting a gym membership so you could sleep in your car and still shower. Others recommended second jobs, roommates, or simply buying a house. Fucking brilliant. But what happens when millions of households simultaneously move somewhere cheaper? Demand increases, and those locations become less affordable unless housing supply expands. What works for one individual doesn't necessarily work for everyone. It's called the fallacy of composition. An entire housing crisis cannot be solved by giving millions of people individual financial advice. Yet apparently, sleeping in a Toyota Corolla now constitutes a comprehensive economic policy. 3. Government regulations and central banks caused expensive housing. This was actually a reasonable argument, at least initially. Restrictive zoning and excessive development regulations absolutely can contribute to expensive housing. But blaming government for every undesirable market outcome is just ideological laziness. Housing prices also depend on incomes, credit conditions, construction costs, land values, population growth, speculation, and investment expectations. Developers build when they expect sufficient profits, not simply because people need somewhere to live. Removing bad regulations can improve housing supply. It doesn't magically eliminate every other economic problem. An economy is an interconnected system, not a fucking supply-and-demand diagram. 4. The landlord provides a mutually beneficial service. Several people argued that rental transactions must benefit both parties because otherwise they wouldn't happen. Yes, someone facing homelessness might prefer paying half their income in rent to sleeping outside. Congratulations. You've established that people prefer shelter to freezing. But that doesn't prove the housing market is competitive, affordable, or producing desirable outcomes. People routinely accept terrible arrangements because their alternatives are worse. Individual rationality doesn't guarantee desirable outcomes for society. The existence of a transaction isn't proof that the economic system is working particularly well. 5. You aren't entitled to someone else's property or labor. And naturally, someone had to start screaming about communism. Apparently, suggesting that people shouldn't have to sleep in freezing cars is now revolutionary Marxism. I support private property, competitive markets, and private enterprise. But supporting capitalism doesn't require celebrating every outcome it produces. Property rights don't automatically guarantee affordable housing, economic efficiency, or an equitable distribution of resources. You can defend private property without treating human suffering as an acceptable demonstration of economic liberty. Now, here's what genuinely disturbed me. I expected arguments about economics. What I didn't expect was how enthusiastically some people recommended homelessness. Sleep in your car. Get a gym membership. Work three jobs. Move away. Stop complaining. These weren't hypothetical responses. People actually suggested these things. Imagine seeing someone struggling to afford shelter and immediately explaining why they should be grateful to their landlord. What kind of fucking worldview produces that reaction? Markets are supposed to serve human beings. Human beings aren't supposed to suffer simply to validate someone's economic philosophy. I'm a supporter of free markets, but I don't believe that requires abandoning basic human empathy. The irony is that people who constantly preach individual liberty seem perfectly comfortable dismissing the economic circumstances that restrict it. If your response to someone facing homelessness is to congratulate them on having the freedom to sleep in their fucking car, perhaps you've spent too much time defending capitalism and not enough time interacting with actual human beings.
Libertarians believe every transaction is voluntary, including paying a landlord half your income because the alternative is sleeping in your fucking car.
248
159
36
796
125,602
I've always wondered about that. I've been really into understanding Marxism as someone who believes in class consciousness and economic justice, and I remember an encounter with a guy I befriended playing Counter-Strike who literally called himself "Marxist Feminist." He loved our conversations about hedge funds, financial markets, and the concentration of economic power. Eventually we invited each other into our respective Discord servers, but he really didn't appreciate the "gamer language" in my friend's server, which struck me as an oddly bourgeois attitude for a Marxist. Then one day I casually mentioned that I thought one of my stocks might be unethical because platinum tends to surge during wars. He banned me from his Discord shortly afterward. I always found the irony amusing. Here we were discussing the structural contradictions of capitalism, but apparently acknowledging my own participation in those contradictions was a step too far. I've never understood how a philosophy rooted in materialism and class consciousness becomes an exercise in moral puritanism and policing other people's behaviour.
i do not fuck with marxists because their main political ideology seems to be that no one is allowed to have fun, ever, for any reason just a deeply joyless, dogmatic people
1
3
331
I think you're also overlooking the MMT component here, and treating government finances as though they operate like a household budget. A monetarily sovereign government doesn't need to collect taxes before it can spend, nor is paying down the national debt inherently a prerequisite for providing public benefits. The real constraints are inflation, productive capacity, and available resources. More importantly, a citizen's dividend isn't necessarily welfare or dependence on the state. It's the distribution of economic rents that rightfully belong to the commons. The state is collecting and distributing that value, not creating it. George explicitly entertained dividing surplus revenue per capita in his 1885 discussion with David Dudley Field. I'm not arguing he considered it a necessary component of the single tax, only that the concept was present in his thinking. I personally frame it as economic justice because I've thought through the mechanisms by which asset inflation squeezes households, and how LVT and a citizen's dividend could address them. Here in Canada, household credit-market debt exceeds $3.2 trillion, with nearly three-quarters tied up in residential mortgages. A tremendous amount of private debt is tied to inflated property values and the capitalization of economic rents. An LVT could put downward pressure on land valuations and speculative borrowing, while a citizen's dividend would give households additional income they could use to pay down existing debts. Together, they could facilitate gradual private-sector deleveraging, reducing debt-servicing pressures and potentially easing the inflationary pressures associated with housing. There's also a broader transmission mechanism here that I think gets overlooked. @JamesYoung has documented Federal Reserve research showing that house-price inflation systematically leads rent inflation by roughly 12–24 months, with correlations around 0.7–0.8. Steve Keen, discussing Young's research, summarized the relationship: "What drives wage changes is actually house prices." In other words, housing inflation isn't necessarily downstream of wage inflation. Housing costs can rise first, squeezing household purchasing power and creating pressure for subsequent wage adjustments, which may then feed into broader consumer prices. Inspired by that Post-Keynesian literature, I put together an empirical analysis of this mechanism in Canada a few months ago. My results found that housing-price inflation preceded shelter-cost inflation, and shelter inflation preceded wage growth, with statistically significant lead-lag relationships. The analysis doesn't establish structural causality, but the findings are consistent with the hypothesis that wages are responding to earlier housing and living-cost pressures rather than initiating them. samsteprojects.github.io/Can… This is why I see LVT and a citizen's dividend as complementary policies. LVT addresses the upstream capitalization of economic rents into land prices, while a dividend returns some of that socially generated value to households, potentially reducing private indebtedness and weakening the downstream transmission of housing inflation into rents, wages, and consumer prices. And I don't think eliminating economic rents automatically eliminates involuntary poverty. People still experience unemployment, disability, illness, and economic insecurity. Georgism can address a major structural source of inequality without necessarily eliminating every other cause. It's not simply redistribution to me. It's an intentional attempt to address the mechanisms producing asset inflation, excessive private indebtedness, and economic inequality in the first place. That's why I consider it economic justice.
Replying to @sam_ess604
First, a pension is something workers get after they retire. And replacing Social Security with public revenue from the single tax is a reasonable consideration. But it isn't a UBI or a CD, which would make everyone dependent on the state for survival and unnecessarily raise the cost of living. Also, admitting that a CD would be possible with excess public revenue is not even close to suggesting such a thing is a component of basic economic justice. If he thought it were, the concept would be found somewhere within the many quite voluminous books he wrote. But, it isn't. If he were alive today, do you think he would suggest that it might be fair to pay out such dividends while saddling future generations with the mountain of debt our nation has accumulated since his day? He was fair-minded. Why wouldn't he say excess public revenue should go to paying off the national debt? Cleaning up our polluted oceans? Health care research? Suggesting a UBI or CD might be necessary under georgism implies that the single tax will not eliminate involuntary poverty. To avoid deceiving the gullible, we should avoid such implications.
1
1
189
I've been thinking about this a lot. Georgism seems like a good starting point. A huge share of private credit expansion in Anglosphere economies has been absorbed by housing and land, inflating asset prices rather than productive capacity. Tax land values, capture economic rents, and potentially extend that logic to AI/data rents, then return part of those rents as a social dividend. That could simultaneously reduce land speculation, de-financialize housing, and give households an income floor that isn't dependent on selling their labour. Then pair it with macroprudential policy aimed directly at private credit creation: restrain leverage during booms, prevent another property-credit spiral, and allow periods of private debt deleveraging without collapsing aggregate demand. The dividend matters here because it supports household balance sheets and consumption while debt is being reduced. So rather than UBI creating a politically powerless underclass, the goal would be to socialize part of the economic rent generated by land, technology and the commons, while structurally reducing household dependence on debt and wages in the first place. You kill two birds with one stone: curb private-debt accumulation and asset inflation, especially housing costs that eventually feed into wage demands and broader consumer prices. (I think this answers a handful of your thread. It maintains capitalism but removes part of the financialization machine that came about with neoliberalism.) Pt.2 in original thread.
Replying to @TyKeynes
1/6) How the hell do we organise society in the next decades if AI can rugpull 80% of the jobs? I can see how UBI is totally possible. But that ain't going to cut it That will just crate a UBI underclass and will soon be totally without political power. Most of the influence I
2
2
14
334
Taxing land and predistributing economic rents is the logical and compassionate choice.
Taxing income is even stupider
3
10
179
The capitalist machine β€” institutions, corporations, and government β€” making race, gender, and sexuality more important than a person's material conditions is recognition without redistribution. Reifying people through those identities while leaving their material conditions untouched functions as a barrier to class consciousness.
Same with LGBTQIA plus phobia.
1
127
What I think the Canadian turnaround requires 7. Change the tax incentive from speculation toward production. This requires careful design, but the broad principle is important. I'd rather Canada tax: economic rents and consumption more heavily than: work, entrepreneurship and productive investment. Taxes should discourage rent extraction more than productive activity. The OECD independently reaches part of the same conclusion, recommending shifting some taxation away from personal and corporate income and toward consumption. I'd go further conceptually. A tax system should ask: What behaviour do we want more of? If the answer is entrepreneurship, capital formation, labour, technology and business creation, taxing those things heavily while allowing extraordinary land appreciation to become the national wealth strategy is backwards.
3
2
3
13
1,611
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
Communism is a democratized economy. When the White House says it β€œhas no place in America,” it exposes the class reality: workers may vote for which capitalist faction runs the state, but they cannot control the economy that rules their lives. That’s the dictatorship of capital.
Communism directly opposes the United States Constitution and American values. While every Democrat voted against the largest tax cuts in American history and over 100 refuse to condemn socialism,Β President Trump will ensure that communism never has a place in America.
12
83
4
214
2,479
Sam πŸ‡¨πŸ‡¦ πŸ”° retweeted
betterdwelling.com/canadas-p… The economists at CMHC need to find different jobs. They now say 4 million new homes needed to get prices down to 50 percent of median take home pay. β€œThe agency now says adding 4.4 million homes by 2036 will restore affordability to 2019 levels. That’s not a typoβ€”the target affordability is now the same as pre-pandemic. Using RBC’s math, the goal post went from 36% of the median household income, to hitting 42.7% β€œ
8
14
32
3,284