Simon retweeted
Paul Feyerabend: "The younger generation of physicists, the Feynmans, the Schwingers, etc., may be very bright; they may be more intelligent than their predecessors, than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, Boltzmann, Mach, and so on. But they are uncivilized savages, they lack in philosophical depth" (quoted in Lakatos and Feyerabend, For and Against Method).
What Feyerabend said about that generation goes double for the current crop of pop science dorks (apart from the "may be more intelligent" bit, LOL).
Simon retweeted
I wish I could not think about politics. I wish it would just get dealt with quietly and sensibly in the background. But that doesn't happen. Governments for years have been grinding the country into the ground.
One in four women of the boomer generation (over 62) take antidepressants. This is quite stunning given that they have known life-degrading side effects including emotional blunting and dysregulation. More so given the lack of evidence that depression is caused by low serotonin.
Is the 1960s revolution a good candidate for the “abomination that causes desolation”?
1
19
We need some people from our universities over to Malawi quickly to ‘re-educate’ them. They clearly didn’t get the memo of what views are acceptable now.
The irony of course is that they *have not* yet been colonised by US left-wing ideology.
telegraph.co.uk/world-news/2…
37
What I don’t understand with these cases is that the bells were clearly ringing when this person bought/rented their house/flat. It’s like moving next to a railway and then complaining that trains come past. How can anyone make a judgement like this?
What has happened to the people running things? There has been a serious degrading of the ability of people to reason and follow common sense.
UK: A church has been ordered to stop ringing its bells – which have chimed since 1889 – after a single person made a noise complaint.
St. Margaret’s Church in Wolstanton received the surprising order from the Newcastle-under-Lyme Borough Council.
Local residents are not happy with the result, insisting the bells are part of the village’s history, charm and character.
The chiming of church bells is a blessing – may common sense prevail and this embarrassing decision be reversed.
H/T - @AJogee
2
21
It really is quite revealing to see where certain strands of modern philosophy have ended up. Having abandoned the ontological hierarchy of classical metaphysics, they eventually discovered that the mechanistic, detached observer of Enlightenment thought was itself an illusion.
Having also realised that a fully relativised reality dissolves all meaning, it then tries to hop back up one step, like a drowning man trying to save himself from Nietzsche’s pit of despair.
This article from @manueldelaflor is a prime example. It has sentences like this: “Here's what this lunatic sees that everyone else misses: Every philosophical position—materialism, idealism, dualism, even scepticism—starts by assuming there's a clear relation between our models and an external thing they model, and so they all play the same rigged game: arguing about which map matches their assumed territory”. The ontological vertical has been so wiped from the map, it doesn’t even exist in the modern philosophers mind. The map-and-territory metaphor the author relies on is itself rooted in assumptions about the relationship between knowing subjects and known objects that classical participatory metaphysics need not accept.
The article then points to AI LLMs as evidence that reality is just about “predicting patterns”, that a chatbot “writes meaningful texts by navigating through statistical regularities. No world required”. What is being ignored here is where the intelligibility comes from, and the constructivist roots of modern thinking become clear with “Every time we name a usable pattern, we don't discover an object; we birth one!”.
There is of course an arrogance here - humans as masters of the universe that create reality. But more than this, it ignores why we have intelligible order rather than relative chaos. It ignores the fact that independently trained AI models converge towards similar underlying representational structures, even across different modalities such as language and vision. A model's ability to recover meaningful structure from language does not demonstrate that the structure has no reality beyond language.
There is an underlying order to reality, something Christian Platonism makes sense of. Yes, you cannot reach out and grasp Truth, because reality is a hierarchy that we are only a part of, and that just requires some humility. But to dissolve reality instead, and cling to trivial crutches to avoid the chasm of meaninglessness is to become trivial. If you want to abandon the possibility of objective truth, at least confront the consequences honestly. Nietzsche recognised the problem of nihilism and struggled to overcome it. Simply substituting usefulness for truth doesn't resolve the philosophical problems created by a “dangerous” abandoning of objective reality.
iai.tv/articles/truth-is-the…
47
We know that God is overwhelming to all of us who are not perfect. Even the OT prophets go weak in his presence. Everything in us that is not pure wants to run from his presence, to hide from his face. It is a desire to hide our imperfections in the direct presence of truth, perfection and beauty beyond comprehension. Perfection that humbles itself to mere creatures is innately repulsive to the imperfect. I think the key characteristic of darkness is a lack of hope, a lack of humility. This may seem like two things, but it’s different aspects of the same thing.
1
1
45
It’s worth pointing out a distinction here that is arguably clearer in the Eastern Orthodox tradition - in the difference between a direct encounter with God, and the ‘divine energies’ of Palamism. In fact I think there are four distinct types of ways in which we can participate with God:
1: In sustaining our being. This applies to all creation, and is the least direct, but fundamental to the existence of anything real.
2: In participating with divine energies. This is the presence one can feel, such as in a holy place, or during contemplation. In the west it’s often called ‘grace’, but this word is to broad to be useful.
3: Direct experience of God ‘before the throne’. We see this with several OT prophets. They generally go faint and overwhelmed, until something resembling the eucharist is given to them (either the hot coal of sacrifice, or the edible bread of the Logos).
4: Mystical experience/theosis. This has different degrees, but is a participation in the Trinity.
Perhaps there is another which is when people are stirred to speak with the Holy Spirit, which is otherwise somewhere between 2 and 4.
I’m sure there will be people who will disagree with all of this, but I think it’s necessary.
33
Simon retweeted
Replying to @contagiousglory @johnmilbank3
Yes, in simple terms that is exactly what I am saying. This is also why I linked liberalism, and more broadly democratic political thought as such, to Girardian "scapegoating" in my reply to the original post. The attempt to identify a positive figure of evil is the inevitable outcome of claiming, in some broadly Habermasian fashion, that a sufficient political reason for the containment of evil is discursively transparent to all critically engaged parties.
In this way, I think it is a straight shot from Habermas to Alex Karp and Palantir, though the question of the relation between Bonaventurian apocalyptic and his buddy Peter Thiel is also very interesting here, given that Thiel has now turned his attention to Pope Benedict XVI, Agamben, and their different approaches to the question of Bonaventurian apocalyptic (firstthings.com/the-pope-and…), which for me is broadly a sine qua non to the systematic theological critique of any notion of "democracy." Thiel himself is more anti-democratic than Karp, in line with the kind of far-right libertarianism of Hans-Hermann Hoppe, but if that's pressing him into reading Benedict XVI, more power to him (not, of course, in a political sense!).
Very much to his credit, I think @johnmilbank3 understands the core of this problem very well, and it comes through very clearly in his inspired critique of Kant's doctrine of radical evil in defense of the classical "privatio boni" theory of evil in the first chapter of his book Being Reconciled. Kantian Enlightenment "sovereigntism," as a kind of obligatory neurotic repression of positive evil through the arm of the state is I think correctly linked by Milbank to both the foundations of liberalism and the horrors of Nazism, though, as a minimal defense of Kant, he is very clear about the categorical transcendence of voluntary and negative moral law over and against political law as an externally and positively enforced obedience to the sovereign (this is something I have been arguing with @defaultmuse about... her conclusion that moral law and political law must ultimately partake of a cosmically mediated speculative identity shows too how weak the claimed transcendence of moral law here really is, certainly to hold back a broader "authoritarian" conclusion, in whichever direction).
What I find more problematic in Milbank's position (obscure though this may seem) is that if we reciprocally swallow wholesale the doctrine of Dionysius the Areopagite that evil is not just privation AS SUCH (though I am not claiming either that Luther's critiques of Dionysius are correct; @backlovere has been developing the subtleties of this problem brilliantly in his dissertation), but specifically a privation of BEING, then we define good and evil EXTRINSICALLY to the self-showing of phenomena, which may or may not pertain directly or properly to being, or to a phenomenological framework as such. If "ontology" requires that we translate out the self-showing of phenomena into a reflective discourse or metalanguage of Being and its forms, then the minimal "discursive" assumption of Milbank's postliberalism relies on the possibility of a "political ontology" as such proper to the common good, which he calls an "ontology of peace." This is stirring rhetoric, but I worry that if you tug on this thread, its consequences are ultimately not that different from the Habermasian ones; phenomena are not truly given over to themselves, but are contained within a metalanguage, which has to project an opposing "ontology of violence" opposite itself as a positively situated discursive evil-"scapegoat".
However, it is here that I think an appeal to J. G. Hamann's notion of "metacritique," which has also helped shape the views of Milbank and others in his Radical Orthodoxy Christian socialist movement, may be helpful, in that the sort of analogical ontology promoted by @johnmilbank3 and @pickstockc in certain key ways is a paradoxically metacritical "non-ontology." As I am currently teaching a course on the thought of Jean-Luc Marion and François Laruelle at the invitation of @kkolozova, I have been carefully revisiting Catherine Pickstock's thoughtful engagement with Laruelle in her book Aspects of Truth, which makes the interesting claim that Laruelle's attempt to establish a "non-philosophy" that "suspends philosophical decision" is only necessary in the context of modern univocal philosophy, and that the antique analogical metaphysics of the Platonist and Plotinian traditions projects no such "authoritative" philosophical decision in need of suspension. This would effectively Platonism a "non-philosophy" avant la lettre, something I have been trying to work through in my engagement with St. Augustine's complex relationship to Platonism, mediated by the skepticism of Cicero, precisely as an anticipation of Marion's phenomenological rendition of Augustinianism.
Ultimately I think @pickstockc's suggestion that Platonism (and particularly the notion of "analogia" in the Platonic tradition) fail to truly be "philosophy" in Laruelle's sense also raises a lot of interesting questions that I would like to discuss further with @kkolozova in particular. I don't think I agree, precisely because of the problems raised in particular by Plato's Laws and the question of self-legislation vs. renunciation of the privilege of the judgment of evil to the historical unfolding of divine providence that I'm getting at in the OP; the grand paradox of Laruelle's discourse here is that he simply ties self-legislation in a knot, that he allows self-legislation to judge itself, to perpetually suspend itself, even in a "theological" form, just without an outlet in the form of any cosmic mediation of apocalyptic providence (since in Laruelle the "World" is always obscuring the truth of the Real-One and the gnosis of such truth, beyond any attempts to cosmically bind or contain this Real-One through philosophical decision, with no clear "World" distinct from this as a limit on it admitted by him; this, at least, has to differentiate him from Plotinus, and, as he confesses, put him more in the camp of the ancient Gnostics condemned by Plotinus).
In conclusion: Platonism is somehow both postliberal and liberal at the same time, the two somehow imply each other in any metalanguage which fails to reciprocally open itself to self-showing through metacritique, and only a more robustly non-discursive philosophy capable of calling fundamental aspects of Plato's Laws into question seems really to be capable of identifying and critiquing the foundations of what the phenomenological essence of modern liberalism (work that I think we see begun in Vladimir Solovyov, Hans Urs von Balthasar, etc.).
It’s interesting that @PageauJonathan talks of Adam and Eve ‘grasping’ the fruit, and relating it to Prometheus grasping the fire. The darkness refuses to acknowledge the light that it does not know, and so takes for itself that which could and should be it’s own - if held in it’s right place - but instead becomes the cause of it’s fall.
youtu.be/zvM1RkJ_D1E?is=qLLd…
“And the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not katalambanō it.”
I’ve been looking at different biblical translations recently. This word καταλαμβάνω is generally either translated as “overcome” or “understood”. The original word has several meanings:
- To seize or capture - physically taking hold of something.
- To overtake or overpower - gaining mastery over something.
- To grasp intellectually - comprehending or understanding something.
- To apprehend or attain - successfully taking hold of something, literally or figuratively.
So John could be intending either:
Overcome: The darkness cannot overpower, extinguish or defeat the light.
or..
Understand: The darkness cannot comprehend or apprehend the light.
Or maybe he deliberately meant both. Perhaps a better translation would be “The darkness had not grasped the light” - either intellectually or in the sense of taking possession of it. It doesn’t sound so natural in English, which I guess is why no one uses it, but the other choices lose this ambiguity.
The connection between intellectual apprehension and ontological possession is an important aspect that gets lost in English. The thinking of the world, and the way of living of the world, are fundamentally at odds with the reality of heaven. Light and darkness do not merge into some intermediate ‘grey’. Yes we experience the world in shades of grey, but I think those shades reflect our imperfect participation in ‘the good’, and our inability to perceive reality as it truly is.
Does the darkness fail to comprehend the light because it lacks knowledge, or because comprehending the light would require it to cease being darkness?
I think John 3:19-21 answers that question. You can have all the knowledge in the world, but it means nothing unless you participate in the light.
54
Yet another of the rising stream of decisions that will leave historians scratching their heads trying to understand what happened to the Western Civilisation. Assuming we have historians in this new world dawning.
Unbelievably, Iran (yes, Iran) has just been elected to the UN Committee that sets the priorities for women’s rights, counter-terrorism and peacekeeping. This, the country with an almost uniquely violent record of brutalising women, executing peaceful female protesters and of course sponsoring very widespread terrorism.
Equally unbelievably, the UK nominated Iran and although the voting is secret, we must assume it subsequently voted for Iran in the General Assembly. This is the same UK that is nominally run by PM Andy Burnham who declared only a few weeks ago that “we will always stand with the underdog and take what action we can to support them.”
If the young women of Iran who dare to remove their headscarves, or sing, or engage in peaceful protest to press for basic democracy aren’t the underdog in their battle with a vicious and murderous regime… who then is an underdog?
I can’t exaggerate how ashamed I am of my country. I’m sickened and repulsed by what it has become. I barely recognise it. Burnham should hang his head in utter shame.
And as for the UN, it has come to embody institutional corruption and gaslighting on a global scale.
It put China, Qatar and Cuba in charge of the body charged with protecting human rights worldwide.
It put China, Cuba, Nicaragua, Saudi Arabia, and Sudan (all of which crush/ban NGOs in their own countries) in charge of the body that decides which civil-society groups and NGOs get UN accreditation and access.
It put Syria (under Assad) in charge the body that promotes education, culture, and press freedom.
How long must this continue? The UN has no credibility whatsoever and should be stripped back to the basics- a debating chamber for the big global issues of the day. And nothing more.
How can anyone defend this?
1
38
Simon retweeted
The UK *nominated* Iran to join this committee.
Why @Ed_Miliband? Is this what you shook hands over?
Simon retweeted
Britain is like this once proud country that is now run by Guardian commenters
Exclusive:
SAS soldiers are reluctant to carry out missions where they may have to “shoot people” over fears they will be accused of war crimes, senior serving officers have told The Telegraph.
Special Forces officers said that the ongoing Afghanistan inquiry into the elite unit had left its troops concerned about going on operations that might require lethal force.
There have been no outright refusals within the SAS to go on high-risk missions.
However, a number of serving members are said to be “less inclined” to volunteer for roles that involve dangerous operations, should they later be investigated for their conduct.
I asked what kind of missions that included and was told: “Jobs where you might end up shooting people.”
It is highly unusual for current SAS officers to talk to the press, even anonymously.
Their intervention highlights concern within the service that its effectiveness risks being blunted.
I think this message is key: The SAS source said lawfare was “a contributing factor in the motivations of those who are leaving, or choosing not to extend”.
This was concerning, they said, because the military risked losing talented special forces officers, who could earn “excellent” promotions if they stayed, but would potentially leave for careers where they felt more valued.
telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11…
From The Cloud of Unknowing:
“ON A RELATED POINT, another person might tell you to gather together your powers of body, soul, and intellect wholly within yourself, and worship God there. This is good advice, well put, and if taken in the right way, you can’t find any better. But I don’t recommend this because I worry that such advice might be literally interpreted and mislead someone. My suggestion resists distortion. I only ask that during contemplative prayer steer clear of withdrawing into yourself. I also don’t want you outside, above, behind, or on one side or the other of yourself.
“Where then,” you ask, “will I be? If I take your advice, I’ll end up ‘nowhere’!” You’re right. Well said. That’s exactly where I want you, because nowhere physically is everywhere spiritually. Make sure that your contemplative work is fully detached from the physical. Remember that when your mind is focused on anything in particular, that’s where you are spiritually, just as certainly as when your physical being is located in a specific place, that’s where your body is. Obviously during contemplative prayer, your body’s five senses and your soul’s powers will think that you are doing nothing because they find nothing to feed on, but don’t let that stop you—keep on working at this “nothing,” as long as you are doing it for God’s love.
Persevere in contemplation with a renewed longing in your will to have God, remembering that your intellect cannot possess him. For I would rather be nowhere physically, wrestling with this obscure nothing, than be a powerful, rich lord, able to go wherever I want, whenever I want, always amusing myself with every “something” that I own. So abandon the world’s “everywhere” and “something” in exchange for this infinitely more valuable nowhere and nothing. Don’t be bothered that your intellect is unable to comprehend it. I love it even more for its inscrutability. Its infinite worth makes it incomprehensible. Also remember that you can more easily feel this nothing than see it. It can be experienced but not grasped. That’s why it seems completely hidden and totally dark to those who’ve only been looking at it for a very short time. Let me clarify “dark” here. When a person experiences this nothing, the soul is blinded by an abundance of spiritual light, and not by actual darkness or by an absence of physical light. So who labels this “nothing”? That would be our outer self. Our inner self calls it “all,” because experiencing this “nothing” gives us an intuitive sense of all creation, both physical and spiritual, without paying special attention to any one thing.”
29
Simon retweeted
Have you noticed the rise of the Christian footballers? The number of players praying on and off the pitch? The post match interviews giving glory to God?
In my latest documentary video I'm charting the Rebirth in Football.
Speaking to John Bostock of @BallersinGod, and Martin Saunders of @Youthscape I trace the new awakening among Arsenal's 'Bible Brothers' - including Saka, Eze & Timber, plus players across other top teams - Joel Ward, Gabriel Jesus, Ben Gannon-Doak, Maxence Lacroix, Antoine Semenyo & Mark Guehi.
Watch now 👉 justinbrierley.com/surprisin…
Simon retweeted
Britain - led by ‘do the right thing’ team of PM and Foreign Sec - effectively supported U.N. General Assembly by 144 votes just elected Iran's Islamic Regime to the Committee for Program and Coordination, which shapes priorities on Women’s Rights, Disarmament & Counter-Terrorism.
How by any definition however deluded is this doing the right thing @Ed_Miliband ?
“And the light shines in the darkness, and the darkness did not katalambanō it.”
I’ve been looking at different biblical translations recently. This word καταλαμβάνω is generally either translated as “overcome” or “understood”. The original word has several meanings:
- To seize or capture - physically taking hold of something.
- To overtake or overpower - gaining mastery over something.
- To grasp intellectually - comprehending or understanding something.
- To apprehend or attain - successfully taking hold of something, literally or figuratively.
So John could be intending either:
Overcome: The darkness cannot overpower, extinguish or defeat the light.
or..
Understand: The darkness cannot comprehend or apprehend the light.
Or maybe he deliberately meant both. Perhaps a better translation would be “The darkness had not grasped the light” - either intellectually or in the sense of taking possession of it. It doesn’t sound so natural in English, which I guess is why no one uses it, but the other choices lose this ambiguity.
The connection between intellectual apprehension and ontological possession is an important aspect that gets lost in English. The thinking of the world, and the way of living of the world, are fundamentally at odds with the reality of heaven. Light and darkness do not merge into some intermediate ‘grey’. Yes we experience the world in shades of grey, but I think those shades reflect our imperfect participation in ‘the good’, and our inability to perceive reality as it truly is.
Does the darkness fail to comprehend the light because it lacks knowledge, or because comprehending the light would require it to cease being darkness?
I think John 3:19-21 answers that question. You can have all the knowledge in the world, but it means nothing unless you participate in the light.
Simon retweeted
In the 1912 essay “The Barbarians” Belloc says the mark of the barbarian is that he wants the goods of civilization without the hard virtues and discipline that created them:
“The Barbarian hopes—and that is the very mark of him—that he can have his cake and eat it too. He will consume what civilisation has slowly produced after generations of selection and effort but he will not be at pains to replace such goods nor indeed has he a comprehension of the virtue that has brought them into being. Discipline seems to him irrational, on which account he is for ever marvelling that civilisation should have offended him with priests and soldiers.”






















