Simon (@si_ad) header
Simon (@si_ad) profile picture

. _ . / \ | ☧ | \_/

England, United Kingdom
Joined May 2011
Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)Photo by Simon (@si_ad)
Paul Feyerabend: "The younger generation of physicists, the Feynmans, the Schwingers, etc., may be very bright; they may be more intelligent than their predecessors, than Bohr, Einstein, Schrödinger, Boltzmann, Mach, and so on.  But they are uncivilized savages, they lack in philosophical depth" (quoted in Lakatos and Feyerabend, For and Against Method). What Feyerabend said about that generation goes double for the current crop of pop science dorks (apart from the "may be more intelligent" bit, LOL).
Nobel prize winning physicists VS pop scientists on philosophy
43
220
14
1,488
50,470
Simon retweeted
I wish I could not think about politics. I wish it would just get dealt with quietly and sensibly in the background. But that doesn't happen. Governments for years have been grinding the country into the ground.
4
5
3
61
2,050
Herbert McCabe liked to be provocative. (From God Matters, p.60)
13
51
6
362
25,383
Yes, in simple terms that is exactly what I am saying. This is also why I linked liberalism, and more broadly democratic political thought as such, to Girardian "scapegoating" in my reply to the original post. The attempt to identify a positive figure of evil is the inevitable outcome of claiming, in some broadly Habermasian fashion, that a sufficient political reason for the containment of evil is discursively transparent to all critically engaged parties. In this way, I think it is a straight shot from Habermas to Alex Karp and Palantir, though the question of the relation between Bonaventurian apocalyptic and his buddy Peter Thiel is also very interesting here, given that Thiel has now turned his attention to Pope Benedict XVI, Agamben, and their different approaches to the question of Bonaventurian apocalyptic (firstthings.com/the-pope-and…), which for me is broadly a sine qua non to the systematic theological critique of any notion of "democracy." Thiel himself is more anti-democratic than Karp, in line with the kind of far-right libertarianism of Hans-Hermann Hoppe, but if that's pressing him into reading Benedict XVI, more power to him (not, of course, in a political sense!). Very much to his credit, I think @johnmilbank3 understands the core of this problem very well, and it comes through very clearly in his inspired critique of Kant's doctrine of radical evil in defense of the classical "privatio boni" theory of evil in the first chapter of his book Being Reconciled. Kantian Enlightenment "sovereigntism," as a kind of obligatory neurotic repression of positive evil through the arm of the state is I think correctly linked by Milbank to both the foundations of liberalism and the horrors of Nazism, though, as a minimal defense of Kant, he is very clear about the categorical transcendence of voluntary and negative moral law over and against political law as an externally and positively enforced obedience to the sovereign (this is something I have been arguing with @defaultmuse about... her conclusion that moral law and political law must ultimately partake of a cosmically mediated speculative identity shows too how weak the claimed transcendence of moral law here really is, certainly to hold back a broader "authoritarian" conclusion, in whichever direction). What I find more problematic in Milbank's position (obscure though this may seem) is that if we reciprocally swallow wholesale the doctrine of Dionysius the Areopagite that evil is not just privation AS SUCH (though I am not claiming either that Luther's critiques of Dionysius are correct; @backlovere has been developing the subtleties of this problem brilliantly in his dissertation), but specifically a privation of BEING, then we define good and evil EXTRINSICALLY to the self-showing of phenomena, which may or may not pertain directly or properly to being, or to a phenomenological framework as such. If "ontology" requires that we translate out the self-showing of phenomena into a reflective discourse or metalanguage of Being and its forms, then the minimal "discursive" assumption of Milbank's postliberalism relies on the possibility of a "political ontology" as such proper to the common good, which he calls an "ontology of peace." This is stirring rhetoric, but I worry that if you tug on this thread, its consequences are ultimately not that different from the Habermasian ones; phenomena are not truly given over to themselves, but are contained within a metalanguage, which has to project an opposing "ontology of violence" opposite itself as a positively situated discursive evil-"scapegoat". However, it is here that I think an appeal to J. G. Hamann's notion of "metacritique," which has also helped shape the views of Milbank and others in his Radical Orthodoxy Christian socialist movement, may be helpful, in that the sort of analogical ontology promoted by @johnmilbank3 and @pickstockc in certain key ways is a paradoxically metacritical "non-ontology." As I am currently teaching a course on the thought of Jean-Luc Marion and François Laruelle at the invitation of @kkolozova, I have been carefully revisiting Catherine Pickstock's thoughtful engagement with Laruelle in her book Aspects of Truth, which makes the interesting claim that Laruelle's attempt to establish a "non-philosophy" that "suspends philosophical decision" is only necessary in the context of modern univocal philosophy, and that the antique analogical metaphysics of the Platonist and Plotinian traditions projects no such "authoritative" philosophical decision in need of suspension. This would effectively Platonism a "non-philosophy" avant la lettre, something I have been trying to work through in my engagement with St. Augustine's complex relationship to Platonism, mediated by the skepticism of Cicero, precisely as an anticipation of Marion's phenomenological rendition of Augustinianism. Ultimately I think @pickstockc's suggestion that Platonism (and particularly the notion of "analogia" in the Platonic tradition) fail to truly be "philosophy" in Laruelle's sense also raises a lot of interesting questions that I would like to discuss further with @kkolozova in particular. I don't think I agree, precisely because of the problems raised in particular by Plato's Laws and the question of self-legislation vs. renunciation of the privilege of the judgment of evil to the historical unfolding of divine providence that I'm getting at in the OP; the grand paradox of Laruelle's discourse here is that he simply ties self-legislation in a knot, that he allows self-legislation to judge itself, to perpetually suspend itself, even in a "theological" form, just without an outlet in the form of any cosmic mediation of apocalyptic providence (since in Laruelle the "World" is always obscuring the truth of the Real-One and the gnosis of such truth, beyond any attempts to cosmically bind or contain this Real-One through philosophical decision, with no clear "World" distinct from this as a limit on it admitted by him; this, at least, has to differentiate him from Plotinus, and, as he confesses, put him more in the camp of the ancient Gnostics condemned by Plotinus). In conclusion: Platonism is somehow both postliberal and liberal at the same time, the two somehow imply each other in any metalanguage which fails to reciprocally open itself to self-showing through metacritique, and only a more robustly non-discursive philosophy capable of calling fundamental aspects of Plato's Laws into question seems really to be capable of identifying and critiquing the foundations of what the phenomenological essence of modern liberalism (work that I think we see begun in Vladimir Solovyov, Hans Urs von Balthasar, etc.).
5
4
20
1,629
The UK *nominated* Iran to join this committee. Why @Ed_Miliband? Is this what you shook hands over?
SHAME: The U.N. General Assembly by 144 votes just elected Iran's Islamic Regime to the Committee for Program and Coordination, which shapes priorities on Women’s Rights, Disarmament & Counter-Terrorism. Disgraceful reward for a regime that massacred tens of thousands of people.
133
624
70
2,177
84,566
Britain is like this once proud country that is now run by Guardian commenters
Exclusive: SAS soldiers are reluctant to carry out missions where they may have to “shoot people” over fears they will be accused of war crimes, senior serving officers have told The Telegraph. Special Forces officers said that the ongoing Afghanistan inquiry into the elite unit had left its troops concerned about going on operations that might require lethal force. There have been no outright refusals within the SAS to go on high-risk missions. However, a number of serving members are said to be “less inclined” to volunteer for roles that involve dangerous operations, should they later be investigated for their conduct. I asked what kind of missions that included and was told: “Jobs where you might end up shooting people.” It is highly unusual for current SAS officers to talk to the press, even anonymously. Their intervention highlights concern within the service that its effectiveness risks being blunted. I think this message is key: The SAS source said lawfare was “a contributing factor in the motivations of those who are leaving, or choosing not to extend”. This was concerning, they said, because the military risked losing talented special forces officers, who could earn “excellent” promotions if they stayed, but would potentially leave for careers where they felt more valued. telegraph.co.uk/news/2026/11…
16
130
1
1,726
31,788
Have you noticed the rise of the Christian footballers? The number of players praying on and off the pitch? The post match interviews giving glory to God? In my latest documentary video I'm charting the Rebirth in Football. Speaking to John Bostock of @BallersinGod, and Martin Saunders of @Youthscape I trace the new awakening among Arsenal's 'Bible Brothers' - including Saka, Eze & Timber, plus players across other top teams - Joel Ward, Gabriel Jesus, Ben Gannon-Doak, Maxence Lacroix, Antoine Semenyo & Mark Guehi. Watch now 👉 justinbrierley.com/surprisin…
7
68
8
314
37,061
Britain - led by ‘do the right thing’ team of PM and Foreign Sec - effectively supported U.N. General Assembly by 144 votes just elected Iran's Islamic Regime to the Committee for Program and Coordination, which shapes priorities on Women’s Rights, Disarmament & Counter-Terrorism. How by any definition however deluded is this doing the right thing @Ed_Miliband ?
SHAME: The U.N. General Assembly by 144 votes just elected Iran's Islamic Regime to the Committee for Program and Coordination, which shapes priorities on Women’s Rights, Disarmament & Counter-Terrorism. Disgraceful reward for a regime that massacred tens of thousands of people.
86
418
37
1,371
36,481
In the 1912 essay “The Barbarians” Belloc says the mark of the barbarian is that he wants the goods of civilization without the hard virtues and discipline that created them: “The Barbarian hopes—and that is the very mark of him—that he can have his cake and eat it too. He will consume what civilisation has slowly produced after generations of selection and effort but he will not be at pains to replace such goods nor indeed has he a comprehension of the virtue that has brought them into being. Discipline seems to him irrational, on which account he is for ever marvelling that civilisation should have offended him with priests and soldiers.”
55
662
50
2,637
59,516
2,300 years old, this astonishingly life-like bronze head of Thracian king Seuthes III ~ with alabaster & glass paste eyes (bloodshot!), copper strip eyelashes & eyebrows, & maybe evidence of old injury to cheekbone (Nat Mus Archaeology, Sofia) Photo: Krasimir Georgiev
30
382
26
3,105
86,273
Simon retweeted
John is a former advisor to Tony Blair. 10 years ago not even hard left anarchists would have said this. Can we stop pretending it’s the working class who have become radicalised?
I simply said the strange belief in English ethicity was a racist evil
11
115
1
984
8,557
This is a mad kind of victim-blaming. Successive govts have hollowed out our industrial capacity and given no tosses at all about what happened to the areas that were devastated. What were people meant to do? Compete with the slave labour, IP theft and govt subsidies of 'free trade' with China? Create their own off-grid factories as Net Zero further turned industry into a luxury hobby? Physically cordon off the border and prevent cheap labour from arriving en masse? If govts of all stripes just throw public money at the flood of negative consequences from their disastrous choices, then we end up with this picture.
Frankly jaw dropping the number of constituencies where welfare spend exceeds income tax and NI raise. Real devolution would halt the extreme extent of current fiscal transfer away from the productive bits of the country. Funny how our leading devo maxxers never address this.
16
50
1
236
7,469
Government imposed policy costs make up 57% of the clearing price of a new flat in London and 42% of a new home in the Home Counties. Despite a big housing shortage and positive planning reforms, new home starts in England are declining from 182,000 in 2022 to under 125,000 last year. While the macroeconomic context has worsened with build cost inflation and high interest rates, the Government is imposing more burdens on new homes, not fewer. Taxes, levies, planning, and mandates add over £440,000 to the cost of delivering a home in London and nearly £225,000 nearby, with several of these imposed recently like the Second Staircase, Future Homes Standard, Building Safety Levy, Biodiversity Net Gain and Residential Property Developer Tax. Individually these may be justified, but together they are making new homes unviable. As a result, large developers are buying less land and small builders are going out of business; nearly 4,000 construction firms went bust just last year. If we want to build more homes, we should be easing the burdens on them, not adding more. Making housebuilding viable again is the most important issue in housing policy and my co-author, Edward Donovan, has completed excellent modelling showing how big the challenge is. Read the full report: cps.org.uk/wp-content/upload… And simulate what changing the policies does with Edward's modelling here: easing-the-burdens.cps.org.u…
74
274
97
1,105
242,039
UK government deciding what to ban today
🚨 NEW: The Government is set to ban under-16s from eBay, Vinted and Depop over fears their messaging features allow adults to groom children
60
5,787
28
50,092
554,593
Men tend to be more system-oriented. Women tend to be more people-oriented. Men are often drawn to building, competing, and solving problems. Women are often drawn to caring, nurturing, and maintaining social bonds. Of course, there are countless exceptions, and the distributions overlap enormously. But these patterns are not simply social constructs. Research in psychology has consistently found average sex differences in interests, particularly the distinction between things-oriented and people-oriented preferences. Biology, hormones, evolution, and socialization all play a role. This doesn’t mean men are incapable of empathy or women are less rational. Both sexes are capable of extraordinary reasoning, creativity, ambition, and compassion. It means that equality of human worth does not imply identical psychological distributions. And when you observe different outcomes between men and women, you shouldn’t automatically assume discrimination is the explanation. Sometimes, differences in preferences and choices are part of the story. I think these results are another illustration of that reality.
Ces data sont sidérantes.
6
33
2
162
9,344
The explanatory notes include truly Orwellian double speak. The North Sea is both in "natural decline" and yet the ban is necessary to show "climate leadership". New licences "wont change the UK as a net importer", but they would reduce those imports, reduce global carbon, and benefit the UK's BoP, inflation and fiscal balance. Treasury should kill this part of the bill if it is serious about owning a growth plan, and cheaper energy. gov.uk/government/publicatio…
Rationing: Resilience.
12
68
276
9,555
This made my eyes leak
Mel Gibson paid Robert Downey Jr.'s insurance bond when no insurer would cover him. Eight years later, with Gibson's own career in ruins, Downey asked Hollywood to forgive him. In 2003, Downey was coming off years of drug arrests, and no insurance company would cover him on a film set. Gibson, a producer on The Singing Detective, covered the insurance bond himself so Downey could play the lead. Downey has said Gibson also told him not to give up hope and urged him to find his faith. The only thing Gibson asked in return was that someday Downey help the next guy. In 2006, Gibson was arrested in Malibu, and his own career collapsed. In October 2011, Downey received the American Cinematheque Award and asked Gibson to present it. In the video below, Downey tells the room why he chose him. About that old favor, he says Gibson "didn't imagine the next guy would be him." Then he urged Hollywood to forgive his friend. Gibson later told Esquire it was "a bold and generous and kind gesture." Did Downey owe Gibson that speech, or was it a risk nobody else in Hollywood was willing to take?
11
112
4
1,089
64,597
Slavery was an evil in which people from every continent and region participated. We should be honest about the whole history, not select the parts that are politically convenient today, especially given Britain's leading role in ending the transatlantic slave trade. If Caribbean countries are asking Britain for a formal apology for Britain’s role in the transatlantic slave trade, will they also be asking the same of the descendants of African kingdoms, rulers and merchants who captured, sold and profited from the trade? On demands for reparations, whether through cash or debt relief, we have been down this track before. Twenty-five years ago, Jubilee 2000, Drop the Debt and Make Poverty History argued that cancelling the debts of poorer countries would give them a fresh start. More than $100 billion of debt was eventually written off, but many of those countries have since built up even bigger debts. Labour are already spending too much on Britain's welfare state, now is not the time for Andy Burnham to be providing global welfare. There is no reason British taxpayers today should be held financially responsible for things that happened generations before any of us were born. And I have even less patience for political elites in commonwealth countries who don’t know how to make their own citizens prosperous now looking for another opportunity to blame Britain. As Prime Minister, Andy Burnham should be Britain’s greatest defender. Instead, he is writing articles saying we need to confront our history (as if we haven't done enough of that) and considering another formal historical apology. Tony Blair already expressed Britain’s deep sorrow and regret for our role in the slave trade nearly twenty years ago. There is no need to do so again. This is all another navel-gazing distraction. The Commonwealth should be looking forward, not endlessly backwards. That means economic partnerships to make us all richer and deeper military and security cooperation against common threats. If every Commonwealth summit becomes an exercise in presenting Britain with demands for cash then we need to start asking if it is worth the effort.
2,779
7,991
1,502
59,419
7,227,703
Simon retweeted
Physics is hard to visualize through static images alone, so I turned my 174 pages of high school physics notes into an interactive website. It covers mechanics, electricity, and magnetism, breaking down complex concepts into intuitive visualizations, real-world scenarios, and interactive problems. Check it out here: atlas-of-physics.vercel.app/
180
1,037
94
6,553
477,542
Simon retweeted
The most amazing, heart-breaking, dramatic start to any documentary series ever. TV at its finest.
31 October 1973. 1st episode of the 26-part classic ITV documentary series World at War was broadcast. It was narrated by Laurence Olivier with music by Carl Davies. It cost £900,000 (worth £11 million today).
417
825
49
7,327
367,474