Tim Stephenson (@sphexish) header
Tim Stephenson (@sphexish) profile picture

Critical Rationalist, Popperian, Classical Liberal, Socionics Enthusiast (LII)

Willerby, Hull
Joined April 2009
2,300 years of free will in 78 seconds. From Epicurus to Dennett: is the path yours? The third site in the series, after time and mind 👇 freewill.philosophyoftime.or…
1
42
Replying to @ToKTeacher
@ToKTeacher @NeilHudsonexp 1/ Deutsch would say "it's an illusion" can explain anything. True of the bare claim. But the science of optical illusions is hard to vary: a specific mechanism, specific predictions. Illusionism about consciousness takes on the same burden.
1
320
5/ So a challenge: give a better explanation of why we're convinced we have qualia, or show where this one fails. What observation would refute it?
2
38
7/ Other refuters: a damaged self-model leaving experience's felt character unchanged, or introspection proving accurate exactly where a self-model should simplify (peripheral richness, unity). It fails there. Now yours: what would refute "qualia are real but unexplained"?
7
6/ To answer my own question: tie illusionism to a mechanism, e.g. Graziano's attention schema, and it forbids things. It predicts attention to unseen stimuli is worse controlled. Equal control would refute it. Webb et al. (2016) tested this and found the deficit.
1
43
4/ The rival, "qualia are real but unexplained", isn't an explanation. It's a placeholder. And "they must be real because they seem real" treats introspection as infallible, the empiricism CR rejects. Why exempt introspection from fallibilism?
7
After Philosophy of Time, a sister site: Philosophy of Mind. Is consciousness real, or the brain’s best illusion? Dennett’s answer, set against 24 thinkers from Aristotle to Chalmers, with a ten-part film series. mind.philosophyoftime.org.uk
1
50
A study of 49 countries finds: "market-oriented societies have a greater aversion to unethical behavior, higher levels of trust, and are not significantly associated with lower levels of morality" doi.org/10.1016/j.jebo.2022.…
8
123
16
555
19,620
The laws of physics are deterministic, and time doesn't flow. And yet we have free will. Conjecture Institute Fellow @Sam_kuyp explains with Fellow @maxdesalle 👇
3
6
31
1,484
Does time flow? Physicist @DavidDeutschOxf says no: there’s no moving “now”, just moments, each a complete universe of its own. A free site setting his idea against 2,500 years of thought on time, from Heraclitus to Einstein, with 10 short videos: philosophyoftime.org.uk
4
13
2
60
3,217
Tim Stephenson retweeted
A reminder that if @andyburnham doesn’t stick with FPTP we will not have decisive failure of candidates such as @ZackPolanski
Zack Polanski lost. George Galloway lost his deposit! Bad night for tankies!
1
1
12
490
Tim Stephenson retweeted
“But it is not just the ambition to explore the unknown that we inherit from the Greeks. It is the conviction that the unknown can be known.”
We believe that the West can awaken from its long slumber – and rekindle the fire that was first lit in ancient Greece millennia ago.
16
31
3
212
7,012
Tim Stephenson retweeted
The Norman Conquest was a cataclysm for the English people. After 1066, the country was clenched in a mailed fist. Castles, until then a rarity, sprang up everywhere. Many still stand, handsome and crenelated, their geographical situation advertising their grim purpose. For these were not defences against a foreign foe, but instruments of internal repression, from whose arrow-slits new proprietors peered out at a beaten people. Having put down the North with terrifying savagery, leaving stretches of country depopulated, William began to rule as an absolute monarch. Quite how absolute can be seen from his compilation, some years afterwards, of a comprehensive inventory of the kingdom he now possessed. For there was no question in his mind that England was his to do with as he would. As the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle put it: “So very thoroughly did he have the inquiry carried out that there was not a single hide of land, not even – it is shameful to record it, but it did not seem shameful to him to do it – not even one ox, nor one cow, nor one pig which escaped notice in his survey.” The resulting tome became known as the Domesday Book, for it was said that you might as well try to deceive God on the Day of Judgment as hide your goods or chattels from the king’s officers. William parcelled out almost the entire country among his mercenaries and liegemen. At least 92 per cent of England was owned by men who had been born on the other side of the Channel. Of more than 200 landowners who held their estates directly from the king, only two were Anglo-Saxons: Thorkell of Arden and Colswein of Lincoln. Equality before the law was forgotten as the new aristocracy settled down to enjoy its privileges. Men were required by law to work on their lord’s estates, and forbidden to leave without his permission. Englishness became, almost by definition, a badge of subjugation. Human nature being what it is, people soon began to adopt the names and manners of their overlords. On one English farm in 1114, records Peter Ackroyd, the workers were listed as being called Soen, Rainald, Ailwin, Lemar, Godwin, Ordric, Alric, Saroi, Ulviet and Ulfac. By the end of the century all those names had disappeared. The status of the defeated English is often illustrated with reference to the vocabulary of meat. The Anglophone farmer in the field used plain Saxon words for his livestock: cow, pig, sheep. But by the time these animals found their way onto his Norman master’s plate, they had acquired French-derived names: beef, pork, mutton. More telling, though, is the political vocabulary introduced under the Normans. Out go witan, folkmoot and folkright. In come fealty and homage, fief and vassal, villein and serf. The progress toward personal liberty, free contract and equal access to the common law was suspended. In the words of the early twelfth-century chronicler, Orderic Vitalis: “The English groaned aloud for their lost liberty and plotted ceaselessly to find some way of shaking off a yoke that was so intolerable and unaccustomed”. The idea of “throwing off the Norman yoke” was to animate English radicals for the next seven centuries. Civil War Roundheads spoke of struggling against “William’s lieutenants”, meaning that the landowners of their own time were heirs to the men who had expropriated the English. “Wurðe god se ende þonne God wylle”, says the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle, lamenting the subjugation of 1066: May the end be good when God wills. The seventeenth century struggles may be seen – were seen by the key actors – as a belated reversal of the catastrophe. It is that reversal which truly deserves to be celebrated.
148
266
69
1,454
208,561
Tim Stephenson retweeted
So cool!
なんと動いてません
1
1
15
1,073
With the release of ChatGPT Work yesterday I produced a philosophical reflection on AI consciousness and whether future artificial minds might have structured information metabolism in a way Socionics Model L can help us think about. tetratypes.org.uk/blog-chatg…
🤖 Made with AI
84
Tim Stephenson retweeted
The fact that the wealthiest person in history is alive today is exactly what you’d expect in a world of sustained economic growth and wealth creation. It’s emblematic of progress.
8
12
1
238
4,223