
#1God1Religon #GodAlone #QuranAlone YouTube: https://teapawt.org/t.co/EwDA8mIhUS Podcast: QuranTalk Apple: https://teapawt.org/t.co/02Y7dqdPD9 Blog: https://teapawt.org/t.co/KD0yvWMmv7
Joined October 2014
- Tweets5.1K
- Following490
- Followers1.8K
- Likes36.1K
[47:3] This is because those who disbelieve are following falsehood, while those who believe are following the truth from their Lord. GOD thus cites for the people their examples.
What an odd comparison. We need the ulama about as much as we need the IRS.
I agree to your terms.
Abolish them both!
What would Muslims do without their millennium of scholarly tradition to tell them whether bestiality invalidates Hajj and fasting?
God forbid they have to use their brains and realize that if they're having sex with animals, they have bigger problems to worry about than whether their Hajj or fasting is invalidated. ๐
And remember, Malik didn't deal in hypotheticals.
islamweb.net/amp/en/fatwa/32โฆ
Guys like Raymond fuel the very radicalism they claim to oppose. By insisting that the worst interpretations of Islam are the only authentic ones, they validate the extremists while alienating the very Muslims who might otherwise reject those interpretations.
American anti-Islam activist @RaymondIbrahim5 on whether the mass arrest, detention & expulsion of Muslim communities en-masse is a โsolutionโ
Link to the full debate hosted by @MrWinMarshall below:
1
15
780
โ๐ฆ๐ฃ๐๐๐๐๐๐ retweeted
ุนุจุฏ ุงููู ุจู ูุซูุฑ ุงูู
ูู (ุช: ูกูขู ูู) ููุฑุฃ ุจู
ุง ุฑุขู ูู ุงูู
ูุงู
ุ ููู ุฃุญุฏ ุงููุฑุงุก ุงูุณุจุนุฉ ุงูุฐูู ุงุฎุชุงุฑูู
ุงุจู ู
ุฌุงูุฏ (ุช: ูฃูขูค ูู). ูุงูุฃุตู ูู ุงููุงุฑุฆ ุฃู ููุฑุฃ ุจู
ุง ุชููู ุนู ุดููุฎู ุนุฑุถุง ูุง ุจู
ูุงู
ุฑุขู.
ููุง ููุนุชุฑุถ ุนูู ูุฐุง ุจูุฐุง ุงูุญุฏูุซ: ยซู
ููู ุฑูุขููู ููู ุงูู
ูููุงู
ู ููููุฏู ุฑูุขูููุ ููุฅูููู ุงูุดููููุทูุงูู ูุงู ููุชูู
ูุซูููู ููู ุตููุฑูุชููยป (ุฑูุงู ุงูุจุฎุงุฑู ูู
ุณูู
). ูููุณ ููู: ุฎุฐูุง ุนูู ูุฑุงุกุฉ ุงููุฑุขู ูู ุงูู
ูุงู
.
ุงูุตูุญุฉ ู
ู ยซูุชุงุจ ุงูุณุจุนุฉยป ูุงุจู ู
ุฌุงูุฏ.
It was a common practice to fabricate Hadith to promote one's business interests:
"During the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd centuries after hijrah, when Islamic rule had spread across the major part of the world, shopkeepers and businessmen needed to advertise their commodities and the only method available for commercial publicity was verbal communication. It seems that businessmen resorted to using prophetic traditions for this purpose. Unfortunately, when they failed to find anything in Hadith literature to promote their goods, they dared to fabricate traditions in the name of the Prophet to make their businesses profitable and attract more and more customers. It is apparent in the sources that a number of traditions were fabricated in praise of pomegranates, date fruit, almonds, melons, grapes, bread, milk, vegetables, cucumbers, lentils, salt, dairy products, endives, chickens, egg-plants, woolen cloth etc. It is very likely that businessmen paid those capable of fabricating traditions in favor of their respective commodities. Even physicians followed suit, fabricating Hadith to promote sales of their medicine."
โ๐ฆ๐ฃ๐๐๐๐๐๐ retweeted
let's invoke "scholarly attestation" when the qur'an is preserved but not when there is near unanimous consensus on the mass unreliability of hadith, bringing back this gem from reinhart on the cognitive dissonance among muslim apologetics
This might be one of the most ridiculous copes Iโve ever heard.
Replying to @talkquran
Ya jahil retard
Bukhari is the the collection of AUTHENTIC HADITH not AUTHENTIC ISNAD [Chain]
The chain may contain defect however the Hadith is authentic because it has other chains, some are in Bukhari itself or in another books of Hadith
๐คก๐คก๐คก๐คก๐คก๐คก
3
12
671
Some ilm al rijal on Ismฤสฟฤซl ibn Abฤซ Uways- from Ibn Hajr:
Ismฤสฟฤซl ibn Abฤซ Uways-
Ibn Abฤซ Khaythama reported from Ibn Maสฟฤซn:
โTruthful, weak-minded, not that reliable.โ That is, he did not know hadith well, did not know how to transmit it, and could not recite from anything other than his own book.
Muสฟฤwiya ibn แนขฤliแธฅ reported from him:
โHe and his father are both weak.โ
สฟAbd al-Wahhฤb ibn [Abฤซ] สฟIแนฃma reported from Aแธฅmad ibn Abฤซ Yaแธฅyฤ, from Ibn Maสฟฤซn:
โIbn Abฤซ Uways and his father steal hadith.โ
Al-Nasฤสพฤซ said:
โWeak.โ In another place he said: โNot trustworthy.โ
Al-Lฤlakฤสพฤซ said:
โAl-Nasฤสพฤซ went to extremes in speaking about him, to the point of leading to abandoning him. Perhaps something became clear to him that did not become clear to others, because the statements of all of these [critics] amount to the conclusion that he is weak.โ
Ibn สฟAdฤซ said:
โHe narrated from his maternal uncle rare (gharฤซb) hadiths that no one corroborates him on, and [likewise] from Sulaymฤn ibn Bilฤl and other teachers of his. People have narrated from him, and Ibn Maสฟฤซn and Aแธฅmad praised him. Al-Bukhฤrฤซ narrates a great deal from him, and he is better than [his father] Abลซ Uways.โ
[1/158] Al-Dลซlฤbฤซ said in al-แธuสฟafฤสพ: โI heard al-Naแธr ibn Salama al-Marwazฤซ say:
โIbn Abฤซ Uways is a liar. He used to narrate from Mฤlik the legal questions (masฤสพil) of Ibn Wahb.โโ
Al-สฟUqaylฤซ said in al-แธuสฟafฤสพ:โUsฤma al-Daqqฤq, a Baแนฃran, narrated to us:
I heard Yaแธฅyฤ ibn Maสฟฤซn say: โIbn Abฤซ Uways is worth two fils (copper coins).โโ
Al-Dฤraquแนญnฤซ said:
โI do not choose him [as a source] in the แนขaแธฅฤซแธฅ.โ
Ibn Abฤซ Khaythama related from สฟAbd Allฤh ibn สฟUbayd Allฤh al-สฟAbbฤsฤซ:
the governor of Yemen, that Ismฤสฟฤซl took a bribe of twenty dinars from a merchant, in return for which he sold the emir a garment worth fifty for a hundred.
sunna.alifta.gov.sa/BookToc/โฆ
Ibn Hajar reports that Ismaสฟil ibn Abi Uways (d. 841 CE) admitted:
"I sometimes fabricated hadith for the people of Medina when they disagreed over something."
Yet Bukhari included him as a narrator in his Sahih.
Imam Malik was Ismaสฟil's uncle!
๐ @HadithCritic for the find
3
7
929
Ibn Hajar reports that Ismaสฟil ibn Abi Uways (d. 841 CE) admitted:
"I sometimes fabricated hadith for the people of Medina when they disagreed over something."
Yet Bukhari included him as a narrator in his Sahih.
Imam Malik was Ismaสฟil's uncle!
๐ @HadithCritic for the find
Ibn Hajar al-สฟAsqalani, Tahdhib al-Tahdhib, preserves a report from Salamah ibn Shabib stating that Ismaสฟil ibn Abi Uways admitted to fabricating hadith for the people of Medina when they disagreed among themselves.
If youโve ever wondered what the people who transmitted the Hadith corpus were like, just watch todayโs dawah scene and connect the dots. Same rascals, different era.
โ๐ฆ๐ฃ๐๐๐๐๐๐ retweeted
What If We Got Muhammad Wrong? | Historian Juan Cole teapawt.org/i/broadcasts/2qVjvMqrpโฆ
Christian apologists claim, โWe have all the things Jesus said.โ
The Gospels refute this: John 21:25; 20:30; 16:12; Mark 4:33โ34; Luke 1:1; Acts 1:3.
John 21:25 says Jesus did more than could ever be written, while Luke 1:1 confirms that many other accounts existed.
โ๐ฆ๐ฃ๐๐๐๐๐๐ retweeted
Linguistic scholar thinks itโs hilarious for Christianโs to criticize Quranโs preservation! ๐



























