ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
When Ideology Becomes Law, Truth Becomes a Sackable Offence
He was not rude. He did not shout. He did not threaten or abuse anyone. By all accounts his tone was calm, firm and respectful. David Toshack, an army veteran in the final week of training as a prison officer, said one thing in a classroom in Edinburgh: he would not call male prisoners "she" or "her" because that would be a lie. Within hours he was removed from the session, taken into a corridor, HR was consulted, and he was dismissed with immediate effect. Not suspended. Not warned. Gone.
That detail matters. This was not a case of misconduct. It was a case of belief. More precisely, it was a case of a man refusing to say something he believed to be untrue after being told ā falsely ā that the law required him to say it. Toshack pointed out that this was company policy, not statute. He was right. UK law does not compel pronoun use. Parliament has passed no such requirement. Courts have not imposed it. Yet a trainer stood in front of a room of recruits and declared it "the law" anyway. That lie is the heart of this case.
Once an institution starts presenting contested ideology as settled law, the transformation is complete. Training stops being about competence and becomes about belief. Policy hardens into doctrine. Disagreement is no longer something to be answered, but something to be managed and punished. This is not mission creep or confusion. It is the end result of a long capture by a left-progressive worldview that treats language as a weapon, truth as optional, and dissent as a form of harm to be neutralised.
For years, universities trained graduates to believe that sex is subjective, speech is violence, and discomfort is oppression. Those graduates moved into HR, safeguarding, training and compliance roles. From there they rewrote internal rules, redefined "harm", and quietly blurred the line between law and belief. What begins in seminars ends in staff handbooks. What starts as theory ends as dismissal.
Look at how quickly the system moved. There was no attempt to clarify the law. No effort to accommodate a reasonable, calmly stated belief. No recognition that prisons, of all places, rely on clear sex-based language for order and safeguarding. Instead, the machinery activated automatically. Corridor discussion. HR escalation. Termination. The outcome was pre-decided because dissent itself was the offence.
The justification offered only deepens the rot. The company spoke of "care and welfare", yet no prisoner had been mistreated. No incident had occurred. The only person visibly distressed was Toshack himself, described as shocked and upset as he was walked to his car. The harm was theoretical. The punishment was real. That inversion tells you everything.
This is how progressive ideology now operates inside institutions. Respect is redefined as affirmation. Dignity is equated with submission. And HR is used as the enforcement arm ā not to manage conduct, but to police belief. The law is dragged in as cover, even when it does not say what they claim it says. Few challenge this, because challenging it carries a cost.
What makes this case especially serious is the setting. Prisons are not lecture halls or marketing firms. They deal with violence, sex-based risk and vulnerable people. Biological reality matters. Clear language matters. Yet ideology was prioritised over clarity, and punishment over truth, without hesitation.
If David Toshack loses his case, the precedent will be stark. You may keep your job only if you say what you are told to say. It does not matter whether it is true. It does not matter whether the law requires it. What matters is that you comply.
"David Toshack, an army veteran in the final week of training as a prison officer, said one thing in a classroom in Edinburgh: he would not call male prisoners "she" or "her" because that would be a lie."
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
I think I said this first about self ID and now the Conversion Practices Bill.
If you are serious about good, sustainable legislation then listen more carefully to your opponents than to your allies. They may have a point or two; and they will be the ones litigating about it
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
āThe Trustees have made the decision that The Bridgeās women-only gym, studio and projects are now for biological women only.ā
A win for @DrPamSpurr and message from @ChtyCommission - women-only spaces & activities must be on the basis of biological sex
Take note @parkrunUK
šØ Calling all TERFs: we CAN make a difference tackling a business, org or charity one at a time that's AVOIDING the law!
Excited to say my persistent challenging of The Bridge Women's Charity's women-only gym, in Southwark, means it'll now be MEN-free.
This is their new guidance (left image) & part of the CEO's email to me. (Note her pronouns š¤Ŗ)
ps amusing that in previous emails she used my title & spelt my name correctly (far right image). BUT when she had to concede defeat she misspells my name & doesn't use my title š)
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
@justsay_mother NEVER THOUGHT IT BE SO DIFFICULT TO GET 100,000 Signatures, when you cannot say our words, you can NEVER protect us, do the right thing and sign and find 4 other friends to do the same
thanks so much
š¤ Made with AI
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
1/ Humanists UK believe they've conducted a "fact check" on a Telegraph piece in which a mother of a trans identifying daughter sets out her fears of the conversion bill.
I intend to defend the mother and her well justified fears in this thread.
humanists.uk/2026/11/05/teleā¦
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
It captures things "which aren't unlawful at the moment and certainly should never be unlawful...such as family interactions, teachers, social workers.."
@akuareindorf talking to @NickFerrariLBC on the report she wrote with @KishwerFalkner on the draft Conversion Practices Bill.
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Not good enough for Ministers to make such comments. It needs to be written in the Bill
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
The founder of @parkrunUK puts comparing times and beating others in his main description of @parkrunā¦
⦠the only way women & girls can do this fairly is by having a female category on the basis of sex
Hereās the clip @mara_yamauchi dissects
Parkrun founder Paul Sinton-Hewitt was on Desert Island Discs today. From 3 mins in, in explaining parkrun, he mentioned where people finish **relative to others** FOUR times:
1. āā¦as they finish, we will give them a little token which will indicateā¦
bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/m0033qā¦
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
SEEN in Health are supporting @BinTheBill_ , as a staff network we recognise the perils the Conversion Practices Bill in it's current form will bring to the freedom of thought and speech for all healthcare professionals
Conversion Therapy is wrong, we already have many laws in place to prevent and prosecute such practices. Healthcare professionals must remain free to pursue evidence and follow safeguarding guidance. The Bill in it's current form treats contested belief as settled fact and places those who dissent at legal risk
We will be sharing resources and supporting the call for evidence submissions from healthcare professionals on how this bill may affect your practice
We recommend the following links for further reading and information
Battle of Ideas panel recording
teapawt.org/BinTheBill_/status/211ā¦
Sex Matters Briefing - Who is at risk?
teapawt.org/SexMattersOrg/status/2ā¦
Gay Mens Network
teapawt.org/MensNetwork1/status/21ā¦
1/ Weāve written to the Secretary of State for Equalities concerning misinformation that appeared in an article she wrote over the weekend. Itās important that the debate around the draft conversion bill is accurate and the Minister should promote this.
gaymensnetwork.co.uk/letters
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Iām a middle-class woman in my thirties. I have a good career, a comfortable life and a degree of financial security that gives me choices many others donāt have. Iām well aware that Iām fortunate, and Iām not going to pretend otherwise.
Many of the issues raised in J.K. Rowlingās latest essay are less likely to affect me directly than they might other women.
But why on earth should that make them any less important to me?
If I need healthcare, I may be able to access alternatives. If I disagree with an institutionās decisions, I have the education, confidence and potentially the means to challenge them. Not everyone has that luxury. And circumstances can change quickly. Importantly, a comfortable life is hardly a permanent magical shield.
I donāt have to be a woman in prison to care about the rights of female prisoners, or a woman seeking refuge after sexual violence to believe single-sex services not only matter, but are vital in society. Nor do I have to find myself vulnerable on a hospital ward, or be a nurse required to change at work, to understand why privacy, dignity and safeguarding are important.
What troubles me is the expectation that women should accept the erosion or reinterpretation of their sex-based rights without question, and that objecting somehow makes them unreasonable, intolerant or hateful.
I believe biological sex matters. Women are entitled to privacy, dignity and safety, and single-sex provisions are and entirely reasonable necessity.
I also believe trans people deserve dignity, safety and protection from discrimination. That doesnāt require me to abandon biological reality or my support for safeguarding measures based on sex.
Then thereās the law.
The Supreme Court clarified the meaning of sex under the Equality Act in 2025. Yet disputes continue over how institutions apply that judgment. What happens to women who cannot afford those battles?
It shouldnāt require a legal team, financial security and the patience of a saint to exercise rights enshrined in law.
And this is where class matters. Those with the greatest influence over institutional policies arenāt necessarily the people who must live with their consequences. Those with the least choice are often expected to accommodate decisions they had little influence over. That is profoundly unfair.
Iām not an activist. Iām somewhat introverted, I donāt have a significant public following, nor would I particularly want one. I have no desire to make myself a public figure.
But I have opinions. Quite strong ones, as it happens. And I have a voice. One that my own conscience insists I use.
I donāt presume to speak for every woman. Women arenāt a monolith, and weāre perfectly capable of disagreeing. I donāt expect everyone to share my views, any more than I expect to share theirs.
But I do expect to be able to express mine. And I believe those of us who can speak have a moral obligation to do so, particularly when others cannot.
As for Rowling, I donāt agree with an argument simply because she makes it. I have profound respect for her, but sheās a woman, not a deity. I respect that she had no personal need, with her current circumstance, to enter this debate, yet chose to because of her convictions.
I donāt need to be personally disadvantaged to recognise something is wrong. I donāt need to know the women affected, or have anything to gain from defending their rights.
My current circumstances arenāt a reason to care less. If anything, they make me more conscious of why those rights matter.
Iād rather use my voice to defend something I believe in than stay conveniently silent simply because the consequences are less likely to land on my own doorstep.
I wrote a new piece about womenās rights and whether or not I want trans people dead. (Spoiler: I donāt)š
jkrowling.com/opinions/an-upā¦
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
There is a widespread amnesia to a widespread cultural norm in UK š¬š§ especially older women about bodily privacy when in states of undress, which mean we exclude all of the opposite sex except very close relatives and medical professionals. This is a need by many in hospitals
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Big shifts underway ā¬ļø Government departments that have been "working at pace" š to revise their policies to bring them into line with FWS have finally done so.
The old model policy staff may use facilities based on āgender identity and expressionā and individuals know āwhich facilities are the best match for their gender identityā.
The new policy says staff should use facilities for the their biological sex, or single-user unisex facilities where these are available.
NEW: Several government departments have released new policies on trans-identifying civil servants and service personnel. These policies restore single-sex spaces but retain gender-identity language.
sex-matters.org/posts/updateā¦
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Yeah we don't have the š¢ However over 9000 folk have signed our petition that we never met
š£ Be number 9209
petition.parliament.uk/petitā¦
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Next week, for @FiLiA_charity I am speaking in defence of Equality Act focusing on womenās interests. In doing so Iāve read various reports from opponents. But interested in wider views. For those genuinely opposed to EA or aspects of it, please kindly summarise your thinking.
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Yesterday I attended the @ChtyCommission annual public meeting online. I typed in a question on the Equality Act and waited and waited... it was never asked.
Two other charity people told me their questions on the Equality Act were also "held in review".
It is not 2018! We are allowed to talk about this.
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Actually there were considerable numbers of grassroots womenās organisations campaigning for single sex wards, same sex intimate care etc but womenās voices are clearly too shrill
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Day 35: person who has physically experienced the pregnancy loss, guess the words missing? The words they choose to delete? Not signed yet, make sure you do because:- š§µ
ThirdSectorSEEN retweeted
Let's decipher what @NadiaWhittomeMP is saying here:
"I am pleased to continue denying women their rights to single-sex spaces.
I do not understand that women's rights are workers' rights too.
Trade unions should keep working together to take sex-based rights away from women."
Many constituents have contacted me, devastated by the University of Nottinghamās decision to approve plans to close modern languages and music degrees, cut support services and end one-to-one personal tutoring.
Not only will this decision impact livelihoods and opportunities for students, but it will have wider cultural and economic implications for our city, region and international relations.
Throughout this period, I have stood in solidarity with striking staff and met with university leaders, urging them to protect jobs and courses. It is not too late for the leadership to engage with @UoNUCU and its detailed counter-proposals.
































