
21. feels like home. so long our work is not over. IL-BLR-ISK-HYD-BLR-DXB-WA-IN-?? @hestabbedhim
purdueee
Joined November 2018
- Tweets8.1K
- Following2.4K
- Followers1.7K
- Likes31.1K
also, even if it's you, is it your head, or your legs? how do you decide where "you" are? see what I mean: you have to make a choice for where the origin is at some point
1
35
Replying to @yooyo3d @MathMath901
let's say you have a friend who says he is the origin. now who is right?
1
38
Replying to @yooyo3d @MathMath901
think about an actual infinite plane passing through the room you are in right now. where is the origin?
1
1
47
Replying to @Poopcrates @ryancbriggs
thats true if the rod has length 0. but remember the string needs to stretch between the ends of the rod, so intuitively you need a bit of extra string
17
1,523
yeah i think its just that i don't consider this a "contradiction of the contrapositive" but i can see how it could be reasonable to. i think i was interpreting contradiction as the implication being false if p.
1
16
i think all i wanted to agree with you on is that contrapositives are equivalent to what they are derived from.
like if we are told "if A then B" then whether that person is telling us the truth is exactly the same as whether its true if they say "if Not B then Not A"
2
Replying to @DavisOlds @EgeErdil2
okay... unfortunately i am used to thinking of people saying contrapositive of X having to only do with things in X
1
4
Replying to @DavisOlds @EgeErdil2
oh okay i think what you were saying by "contrapositive contradicts the stimulus" is that "first part of contra. contradicts the stimulus"?
i think the main confusion is that the truth value of an implication is independent of the truth value of its parts.
1
12
Replying to @DavisOlds @EgeErdil2
I see the issue now. you cannot take the contrapositive of a logical statement. you can do that to implications.
you can apply "contrapositive" to a statement like X = "if you have a square you have a rectangle".
the only thing you could do to X = Live in Texas is negate it.
2
1
15
Replying to @DavisOlds @EgeErdil2
i think we may be misunderstanding what the other means by "contrapositive". i am talking about things in a very precise mathematical sense
1
3
if you don't, i would be curious how you define contrapositive. here is mine
let x and y be logical statements that are true or false.
let (x -> y) be true when x being true means y must be true
then the contrapositive is the statement (~y -> ~x) and is always equal to (x -> y)
1
2
Replying to @DavisOlds @EgeErdil2
i agree, and in fact one step further: X contradicts Y. do you agree?
2
15
what i hope to convey is: if you say "the contrapositive of X contradicts Y" then you must say "X contradicts Y"
you seem to be saying that "the contrapositive of X contradicts Y" implies "X does not contradict Y", which is wrong. please correct any mischaracterization.
1
44
Replying to @DavisOlds @EgeErdil2
u claim:
(p -> q) = D
(p -> q) = (~q -> ~p) (contrapositives are equiv.)
but then you claim (~q -> ~p) != second sentence
therefore, D = (p -> q) != second sentence. therefore, D does not follow from that sentence.
i have tried to only use ur logic. what have i done wrong?
2
43