We’ll write abt this more, but briefly:
1) yes, the difference between toshavim (pre-Sephardic) & megorashim is worth noting
2) there is almost no evidence of Jewish continuity in Morocco from Roman times
3) Berber ancestry is very low
4) the two groups seem closely related
*Aktchually* he's probably not Sephardic (patrilineally speaking) but toshav
As his amazigh surname (despite the "ashkenization" attempt) suggests his people never left Morocco since Roman times
Azenkod : gazelle teapawt.org/BreizhLondon/status/21…
Replying to @JoeRoganRecaps
Where to even begin.
(Other than the fact that we’ve tested dozens and reviewed the test results of hundreds of Israelis of different backgrounds…)
Replying to @sickofskis
Do I? I often get mistaken for Lebanese or Turkish. Which makes sense given that I'm from a Levantine/Eastern Mediterannean ethnic group.
Ale retweeted
Replying to @LibyaLiberty
That's a quote from a letter he sent to someone in the USSR during the 1930s, after having been denied citizenship in France during the rise of the Nazis, who were already busy attacking his work. The USSR was known for checking foreign mail and Chagall was in a precarious position for where to seek help. Meanwhile, see the letter written to a friend in Haifa during the same period. Still think he thought of himself as a Russian?
People often write to us confused about why Jewish Y-DNA haplogroups are so varied, asking about Abraham, "true Israelites", admixture, etc.
This is just the norm for Near Eastern/East Mediterranean populations. Very different from the continental European pattern shown below:
Ale retweeted
While I'm not yet sold on the Da Vinci claim, you're not addressing the real world. Khazaria was long gone and there is no need to speak of their alleged conversion. Circassia has had Jews and it did have Jews at that time. These were ethnic Jews and not converted Circassians. These Jews would've likely been Mountain Jews. From what I can tell, Circassians heavily, if not entirely, relied on their native names at the time and therefore were unlikely to have some form "Jacob". This at least makes it unlikely that this woman would've been a Circassian. Now, Circassia did have other minorities, such as Greeks and Armenians, who did seldomly use the name Jacob.
Ale retweeted
Replying to @HistoricalJW
Kogan isn't a distortion nor part of a European phenomenon. The G in Kogan is strictly phonological and language specific: the /h/ sound didn't exist in Russian nor its script and was thus replaced by G. Same reason Russians today speak of Garri Potter instead of Harry potter! :)
Ale retweeted
Shabbat shalom and a happy weekend! And remember: Our ancestors are smiling upon us.
שבת שלום לעדה הקווקזית ולעם ישראל.
(Animated photo of Baniel Shaulov, taken by Dmitri Yermakov in the late 19th century)
#MountainJews #Kavkazi #Shabbat #genealogy #ancestry #heritage
Ale retweeted
Replying to @Em35V12 @JewishGenomics
I'll elaborate on what I think is being spoken about. 3 known Jewish lines in the broader branch (E-CTS8411) are circled. With the fraction of its branches being Jewish today and the broader line being in E-V12, it's hard to imagine that E-CTS8411 wasn't someone in Bronze Age Canaan
Ale retweeted
People these days are shocked when seeing most ethnically Jewish people look like this & rarely blue-eyed blondes.
When I was younger, blonde blue-eyed Jews were often not perceived as Jewish. I remember a teacher angrily telling a blonde Jewish classmate that he wasn’t Jewish.
Ale retweeted
Universities in the USSR explicitly discriminated against Jews, but the average European/British leftist thinks that’s actually a good thing.
Ale retweeted
Even if you set halacha aside (which I do not), there is nothing more pathetic, desperate, and pick-me than paying for someone to come to your country and offering him your women just so he’ll say something nice about it.
Ale retweeted
"Did you know that some people have practices that have Jewish origins and also have some Hebrew in their language? That means that they're more Jewish than Jews. The fact that Jews have more Jewish practices than these people do is irrelevant bc Judaism is just a religion."
Ale retweeted
The substrate in Egyptian Arabic is more Aramaic than Coptic & pervades the verb system (see the reflexive stems below). There's little lexical material otherwise. Meanwhile in Yiddish, Hebrew & Aramaic account for a whooping 20-30% of the lexicon, that includes many doublets.
Replying to @narwhaldevil95
Modern-day arabic dialects in egypt and levant are more influenced by Coptic and Aramic than yedddish (a literal German dialect) been influenced by Hebrew
Ale retweeted
A lot of us look the same, actually.
None of these guys are Ashkenazi, but they could easily pass for Ashkenazi.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
Ale retweeted
Hebrew doesn't bother them because Israelis say 'khamas' instead of 'ḥamās' or because it "sounds ugly". Even the Zionist context which led to the revival of Hebrew doesn't really bother them.
Hebrew bothers them because the Palestine Arabs have no language of their own.
Ale retweeted
Replying to @wana_visualss @menavisualss
Why do you constantly misrepresent images of Jews?
The photo was taken in Israel.
Ale retweeted
Gazan uncle: "Oh Allah destroy the Jews and make them spoils for the Muslims 🤲"
Nassim Taleb: "Now that's what I call a real Judean!"
History__Speaks: "Don't mind him, he's just insulting himself."
Tucker Carlson: "Perhaps we need to DNA test those Jews just to be sure."
Ale retweeted
Arab is an ethnic marker — and people like you, Mouin, use that to deny our separate existence as an ethnic group, and therefore our right to self-determination separate from Arabs, and the sordid history we experienced while living under Arab dominance.
So stop playing the victim.
I'm immensely enjoying the meltdown over my use of the term "Arab Jew".
For Israel flunkies, it contradicts their position that Arabs and Jews have not only been distinct groups since the beginning of time, but have been existing in continuous enmity with each other since their first encounter.
So you can add any geographic, cultural, ethnic, or national prefix to "Jew" that you like, except "Arab". Kurdish Jew, Persian Jew, English Jews, it's all good.
One particularly unhinged flunkie went to far as to insist that the mere term "Arab Jew" is "violently anti-Semitic".
But German Jew? That is apparently 100% kosher.































