John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker) header
John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker) profile picture

Soundbites suck. Ask why. Test the math. Let’s move the needle. Check replies MAGA/MAHA Unfiltered? This IS my filtered cut. 🇺🇸

The Jungle
Joined September 2024
Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)Photo by John Clayton (@CriticalPlinker)
What’s up with all the data centers getting built? 
Why do we need them? These aren’t the data centers we’ve had before. 
These are high-density AI compute clusters. 
Data storage is just a sideline, the point is the compute. They aren’t here to answer your questions… they’re here to take your job. They’re the infrastructure that lets AI handle routine work across industries cheaper than people. They aren’t “data centers.” They’re job replacement factories on a very large scale. I’ve laid it out here…
teapawt.org/criticalplinker/status…
In tech AI writes and reviews code, routes tickets, and handles large parts of the work that once used to take multiple engineers. In logistics it builds routes, sets schedules, and decides which loads move when. In healthcare it drafts notes, flags findings, and sits in the path of treatment and billing decisions so that the approved option is the one that appears first. In insurance it reviews claims and determines what gets paid. In law firms it runs research, pulls relevant cases, and drafts or redlines documents. In engineering it generates designs, checks calculations, and flags issues against standards. In marketing it creates content, adjusts campaigns, and admin rolls. In accounting it does math faster. In customer service it answers questions. These are not the same tasks, but they share the same practical feature:
they are built on language, data, rules, past examples, or structured decisions that a system can process once it has been shown the inputs. That’s why the same advantages move from one sector to any sector so effortlessly. Point them at the new set of rules, and connect them to the existing system. The cost difference versus a person stays the same (pennies on the dollar). A person requires wages, benefits, leave, taxes, and liability. AI requires electricity and cycles. 
Extra capacity is added at low additional cost, and it can run continuously. Let’s repeat that, it’s important. It can run 24/7 eliminating multiple jobs with a single AI agent. Once the output is good enough for the routine work, the payroll can shrink while the work still gets done. 
Companies describe the change as efficiency, attrition, or restructuring.
What they call it can vary. The savings doesn’t care what it’s called. The same pattern is already appearing outside the technology companies. Government agencies use the systems to process forms, permits, benefits claims, and records, and plans to reduce staff are in process. Universities/schools use them on admissions, transcripts, scheduling, and routine questions. Real-estate work uses them to pull information from contracts, track deadlines, and check disclosures. Banking compliance and lending teams use them to collect documents, triage alerts, and prepare reports. Human-resources use them to screen resumes, rank candidates against job criteria, and schedule interviews. Marketing groups use them to generate variations and execute plans. Utilities use them to handle billing questions, payment arrangements, and outage inquiries. In each case the work includes decisions, classifications, drafting, or analysis that used to require people. 
Once the tools reach a usable level of reliability and are connected, fewer people are needed for the routine share.
The remaining staff gets shrunk to bigger decisions and oversight. Rules (regulation) could slow the pace in some places, but the incentives are huge across industries. It merely depends on whether the same output can be produced at lower cost. Previous technologies changed specific industries or specific steps inside an industry. The tractor changed farming. The computer changed calculation, record-keeping and matured slowly. AI applies to any task built on language, data, rules, and common decisions, and scales quickly for pennies. The economic numbers that matter are the ones that compare it to work completed. 
What companies or reports call it in the headlines will vary.
The savings won’t care. The underlying math does not change because the work moved from a technology company to a government office, a hospital, an insurance company, a law firm, a university, a real-estate transaction, a bank, a recruiting desk, a marketing team, or a utility call center. The tools don’t need to become perfect. They only need to be good enough, cheap, and scalable enough that keeping the old headcount stops making sense. What makes AI an attractive tool in one sector works for any industry. We need to plan on it.
1
2
1
6
212
THE HISTORY OF VACCINES: Let’s go back to the beginning when it all first began. It was coined by Edward Jenner, he’s the guy that created the first one. The disease he was working with? Cowpox. He called it Variolae Vaccinae back in the late 1790s. The word vaccine comes from the Latin for cow. The treatment was administering cowpox material to protect against smallpox. It worked! In fact it worked so well that today smallpox isn’t even around any more. We quit getting the vaccine to prevent it decades ago. About 100 years later, along comes Louis Pasteur to broaden the term to mean something more. It was Pasteur’s tribute to Jenner. Pasteur redefined what a vaccine meant, he applied it to other treatments that worked so well that a person became immune to the disease in nearly all cases. It’s not exactly fair to say 100% of the time (for any of you nit pickers out there) but close… damn close. These treatments were so successful against the disease a person became immune. Vaccine would forever go down in history as a word that meant the treatment worked so well that immunity was the outcome… well almost, more on that later. Let’s look at the word “immune” for a minute. It hasn’t changed much in centuries, its meaning unchanged. It’s Latin and literally means “not paying a share” in a word... exempt. To be immune means you have an exemption. Originally it was a legal term (taxes do not apply or military service, etc). Later (around the time Pasteur made his tribute to broaden vaccine’s meaning beyond smallpox/cowpox) the word immune was broadened as well, it wasn’t just a legal term, it was applied as a medical term. Same definition, just applied to science. Immune: to be exempt Vaccine: a treatment that makes one immune That’s what they mean, that’s how it’s been for ages. In 2021 that all changed. Pasteur’s tribute to Jenner and what he created with the smallpox vaccine no longer applies. Most of us still think of these words in those very same terms though. When we think of a vaccine it carries heavy emotional weight with us… we think of immunity. When we get a vaccination we no longer need to worry about that disease because we’re immune. Prior to 2021 the CDC knew what those words meant too. Their definitions? Immunity: “Protection from an infectious disease. If you are immune to a disease, you can be exposed to it without becoming infected.” Vaccine: “A product that stimulates a person’s immune system to produce immunity to a specific disease, protecting the person from that disease.” Those were the actual definitions the CDC used. In 2021 they “updated” the definitions to mean something else, something less. There are treatments (especially the recently introduced Covid shot) that no longer fit the definition. But a vaccine still carries with it that high emotional impact. People associate a vaccination with something that eliminates the risk entirely... produces immunity. Not, kinda sorta, not a little less severe, “Immunity”, exempt. If you are immune, you can be exposed to a disease without being infected. That’s their words, not mine and that’s still what we think of today. Maybe consciously, maybe subconsciously. Point is, the emotional effects are real. That definition no longer works for some of the treatments they want to apply the word to though… the word still has the same emotional effects but the shots don’t offer it. Why use the term vaccine? The definition doesn’t fit. The definition may not fit, but the impact does. It sells more shots. If you can get a shot that makes you immune from a disease that grabs your attention. It works too, they sell more shots…. A marketing gimmick, not reality. Not reality? That doesn’t work either does it? The healthcare industry or government can’t legitimately pedal something that doesn’t reflect reality? That’s a problem and they found the solution. Redefine reality. Redefine the words themselves to more closely match the treatments they want them applied to. The new definition from the CDC, since 2021? Vaccine: “A preparation that is used to stimulate the body’s immune response against diseases.” “Stimulate a response”. The word changes are subtle but they do an incredible amount of work. It went from “producing immunity” to almost anything they want it to mean. Reality, redefined. Problem solved. Immunity? More recently they changed that one too. They added a second layer. “Or being partially resistant”. The definition that’s stood for centuries just got eradicated. Pasteur’s tribute to Jenner and the smallpox vaccine has been effectively erased. But hey it’s for a good cause… the almighty dollar.
1
6
69
Think it’s real? What’s up with the identical child in the background? Identical twins right down to their socks and hair or more AI fakes? Idk, but I wonder where the redheaded parent is.
Even Grandpa's slow little head nod made the copy 🌹😂 She studies him like it's her full-time job...
27
Dysentery (diarrhea) was probably the single biggest killer 125 years ago (the era Stone is referring to with his 1 in 5 mortality rate), especially for infants and young kids. Pasteurization, refrigeration (especially fast freezing), cleaner water, better sanitation/sewers (basically better hygiene) saved even more lives than the vaccines… all taken for granted today. Good chance you never knew it was that big a deal… but it was. Stone wants to argue vaccines made all the difference and then extrapolate that out to today… it doesn’t work that way. Those other innovations I mentioned had a huge impact… huge. Now, to your point, yes medical innovations have made a big impact too (including some of the older vaccines), and antibiotics… but I’m damn sure not going to put a flu or Covid shot on that same kind of pedestal… they’re not. I wasn’t joking when I said calling them a vaccine was a marketing gimmick… Now days to even call them vaccines (because that word carries so much emotional weight) they changed the definition in the dictionary! (Specifically, May of 2021). They literally changed the definition so they could call the stuff they’re peddling today a “vaccine”.
Smallpox Diptheria Pertussis Polio Tetanus These diseases killed millions. One is contracted from bacteria in the soil, and the other 4 from coughing and sneezing. How does "Better nutrition, antibiotics, living conditions, sanitation improvements and so on…" prevent these?
1
2
6
275
Reviving an old reply because it’s one of my favorites. It’s a good one because it’s so spot on, even more apparent now, and it’s going virtually unnoticed. More people need to be aware… you should know. Now, Grok would tell me it’s “unpolished” and it probably is. I wrote it myself, not an AI. Maybe one of these days I’ll actually write a more polished version… but if I do, I’ll still write it myself. Please take a look, it won’t take much longer than what it took you to read this far… and if you have, thanks.
Replying to @r0ck3t23
“The AI race stopped being about compute. It became about truth.”… A sound bite, easily missed, but goes to the crux of the issue. Let’s unpack this so maybe it doesn’t get glazed over. The race seems like it’s about hardware and software, but is it? Really? OR, is it about creating “truth”, and the next evolution of manufacturing it? Yes, you’re onto something here, though you didn’t highlight it. As people depend more on AI for their daily lives beyond simply performing mundane tasks we’d prefer to relegate to a computer or robot, we’ll also depend on it to provide us information in all scopes of life. The genuinely curious will (are) using it to satisfy curiosity and the uneducated will use it for learning. Here’s the rub, as this transition becomes more and more mainstream it will no longer be an option to satisfy curiosity or education. It will become the “logical” sole source. Logic… it’s, yours, ours…society’s. AI will no longer be the grunt performing tasks, it will be the teacher of all and everyone. The race isn’t about AI domination to simply create efficiency… This is about creating “truth” as we know it which is to say our beliefs, our very thoughts. Sure people in this generation see the flaws in its logic with programming bias, but as it becomes more and more mainstream, more embedded into society, more a monopoly on information, the next generations may no longer see flaws. The programming becomes the programmer. Let me repeat that, THE PROGRAMMING BECOMES THE PROGRAMMER. Programming what?… well us of course, us as individuals and us as a society. Think this won’t happen? Think again, it’s already happening. Pilot programs are in place now schooling millions of our kids…. Millions learning the “truth” as it’s taught. Honest question, did you notice what it wrote and said out loud? Or, did you glaze over it too? I wrote this reply myself, these are my thoughts written with human brain cells, it took me longer, but how often does that happen online now days? “The AI race stopped being about compute. It became about truth.”…. Did you unpack the sound bite?
2
60
Maybe I’m just being too cynical, call me out if you think I am. As I see it, you just described virtually all of Capitol Hill for ages now. Nobody… and I mean almost NOBODY is there except to get their piece of the pie. Representing the people of this great nation has been left in the dust. If an instrument panel had a gauge labeled “for the people,” the needle never leaves empty. Are there a few exceptions? Sure, I think there are. At least I’d like to hope there are. A handful maybe. Trump is clearly the exception. I’d put RFK Jr. in that tiny basket as well, probably a few others that actually care about our nation. This is what needs to change. We don’t get to fix our economy, or environment, or anything else until we pay attention to what’s really broken… the MACHINE. The machine that is DC doesn’t just need to be fixed, it needs to be fixed first! You can’t make a good widget with a faulty assembly line. Same goes for politics. We can’t fix our issues until we actually have a system that’s actually made to fix issues. I’ve said my piece. Let the outrage begin.
I think the number one thing that two Trump administrations have taught us is that SO MANY "conservatives" saw the conservative movement as a money-making grift, and nothing more. They never had actual values other than greed. Consider people like Bill Kristol, the bald losers at The Lincoln Project, the "Bulwark" crowd, etc., etc. I know they branded themselves initially as merely conservatives who were "opposing Trump," yet the reality is that today they have fully gone over to the Democrat camp--a party now controlled by literal communists and jihadists. They are now Democrats. They did this even though the modern Democrat Party stands wildly in opposition to every value they ever once claimed to hold dear. That Democrat grift pays better, I guess. These people never had conservative values. They saw our movement solely as something to be exploited, and when Trump kicked them to the curb they simply switched sides. They did not grow. They did not have an intellectual awakening. They simply revealed who they are: intellectually bankrupt people, devoid of values, Judas-like for pieces of silver, caring only about lining their pockets and having legacy media prestige. Disgusting.
4
73
I haven’t followed this whole Epstein mess closely, and this is exactly why. There is absolutely nothing about this we can believe. This isn’t how a “dead man’s switch” would actually work. Credibility would come from the people she supposedly gave the information to. They’re the ones who could verify the chain of custody. They’re the ones who would put their names on it and release it. It wouldn’t just appear anonymously with a vague “I gave it to a few people I trust… you know who you are.” The entire point of setting up a switch in the first place depends on those trusted recipients being able to authenticate it. Without that, there’s nothing… NOTHING! This is a psyop, and you are the target of its deception. Period.
This Post is from an account that no longer exists. Learn more
4
44
Tensions were high at my wife’s work already. It’s a smallish pediatrician’s office, somewhere around 100 employees, so not tiny but not corporate America either. A couple of months ago they “affiliated” with a much bigger group. It was a big deal with a lot of extra work getting everything set up, especially for the billing department… my wife’s department. She’s a senior biller and a lot fell on her shoulders and a couple others in billing. Everyone had a learning curve though. Just as they’re getting settled in and things are beginning to click again, the big corp they affiliated with did their thing… job cuts. A lot of them. Enough that it made the local news. It’s all admin positions getting cut. This was an AI cut, though it wasn’t framed that way in the announcement. “Efficiency” is enough said apparently. The affiliates weren’t affected (yet), just the parent company. So, tensions have been high. Then, just yesterday, they get a memo from their practice administrator… They have some announcements of their own. They announced 3 new “partners.” Two are sub-contractors. The first is a company that does language translations so they can communicate better with their patients. It sounds good on paper, it probably will benefit the practice, but we should all know by now AI has gotten really good at translating. They hired a company… the company uses AI. The second partner will take triage calls, mostly after hours they say. I honestly don’t know if this is AI-related or not. The 3rd partner is literally two AI agents. It’s offered through the software company they use to operate the practice. They’re expensive, but they still cost less than more employees. Nobody knows yet how they intend on using them, but it’s a safe bet at least one will be in billing. Now, the practice administrator says they don’t “plan” on anyone losing their job. That’s probably true too. They don’t plan on it. But what I can almost guarantee they plan on is not replacing certain people when they quit or retire… that’s the “plan.” We’ll see. As I said, tensions are high. What’s your story?
1
1
9
248
Timeline cleanse. Fall finally arrived. Colors turning, leaves dropping. I’d love to see some pics. Drop yours below.
1
3
130
Color me skeptical how much this protects our kids. “No AI for kids without prior authorization” Sounds suspiciously like protecting the narrative to me. What kids are taught “pre-approved” by big government entities and the corporate world isn’t “safety”… it’s mind-washing at international scales.
Another great Paris Peace Forum. The Paris Call for AI Safety and Security and the Children First Declaration are real commitments on two of the defining challenges of our time: making AI safe and making sure it serves the next generation. Thank you to my friend President @EmmanuelMacron for his leadership and his commitment to making the forum a success. 🇫🇷 🇪🇺
2
107
I’ll bet you a dozen donuts that take is dead wrong. If you’re white collar and have a desk your job may already be on the chopping block. 200K jobs have evaporated so far this year in the tech sector alone, and AI isn’t even ramped up yet. We’re not building “data centers”. Those are Workforce Replacement Factories!
AI WILL CREATE MORE JOBS THAN IT DESTROYS BY 2030, GARTNER SAYS Gartner forecasts AI will generate a net gain of 1.7 million jobs globally by 2030. 10.6 million new jobs are expected to be created, offsetting 8.9 million jobs eliminated by AI. More than 20% of the global workforce will see their roles transformed, with technology workers facing greater proportional disruption than those in asset-intensive industries or the public sector.
2
36
I call bs.
Just this year it’s evaporated around 200,000 jobs in the tech sector alone.
No jobs? Think again. Block… 40% of its staff Oracle, Amazon… tens of thousands EACH Meta, Microsoft, Cisco, Cloudflare, Coinbase… need I go on? If you’re white collar and have a desk, AI is coming for you. teapawt.org/CriticalPlinker/status…
Me: "People spewing left and right that AI is taking everyone's job... that must be some pump and dump stock bullshit. You're fun to talk to and all that, and genuinely useful. But goddamn, you're not taking any real job." Gemini: "That hits the nail on the head."
1
3
58
Apparently she’s using the new Glock CO2. Where’s the smoke from the ammo? That many rounds fired inside a car and no smoke? The fake AI generated videos are getting pretty old.
Girl was almost robbed and being followed, so she pulled out her sidekick and blew both passenger and driver into the next life, apparently she made the news
1
3
58
Nice little studio apartment, built from nothing. Next time I’m in Hogwarts I’ll check it out.
This is really cool. I could not stop watching it. Enjoy.
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
This video is AI-generated fake construction; the narrow exterior gap unrealistically expands to a much wider interior. youtube.com/watch?v=qDG-eF… youtube.com/watch?v=0U8HWv… realestate.com.au/news/why-this-… leadstories.com/hoax-alert/202…
3
170
I’m kinda the opposite. There’s a lot I really like about AI. The issues are with how it’s being utilized. Those aren’t data centers they’re Workforce Replacement Factories. “Data” is only a fraction of what they do and they’re getting built at scales we’ve never seen before.
you all know i don’t even like ai, but im legit curious why the general public has such an aversion for data centers specifically. Just a total rejection of data centers by the majority of people
3
115
It’s fine for a Christian to embrace technology. That’s a different matter. It’s wise to show some discernment and have some wisdom about how it’s utilized. In this case there’s a real danger. You’re literally going to a machine programmed to respond in a certain way to seek insight. It doesn’t matter what the topic is. That requires being very careful and skeptical of what it’s telling you.
Replying to @sonlamho @GeminiApp
So, as Christians, we're supposed to be unaware of technology? That's ridiculous. Christians started the first universities in Europe and the US and have been at the leading edge of technology developments until evangelicals have persistently attempted to dumb us down since the 70s (or thereabouts). I'm an active evangelical, so I see the anti education and anti technology persistence of many evangelicals first-hand. If you want to talk about the Devil, I'd say there's more impact from evangelicals resisting education and technology than my daily gemini work.
2
3
189
I wrote this post a few months ago. Now it’s becoming more apparent and we’re seeing some of the risks involved when we allow AI to be our primary source of information… teapawt.org/criticalplinker/status…
Last night, I was troubleshooting an autopilot glitch aboard my sailboat when ChatGPT discovered I was anchored near Point Honda, site of one of the worst peacetime disasters in U.S. Navy history. That’s when things went completely off the rails. ChatGPT and suddenly stopped troubleshooting and insisted I immediately contact the Coast Guard and broadcast a PAN-PAN distress call. Never mind that the weather was excellent. Never mind that the glitch was minor. Never mind that my MANUAL STEERING WORKS PERFECTLY. It even walked me through the emergency radio procedure and explained when I should escalate to MAYDAY. All because my autopilot had a MINOR glitch. So I switched to Claude. BIG MISTAKE. Claude repeatedly insisted that I stop troubleshooting, go to bed, and spend $2,500 on a replacement autopilot, plus another $3,000 to have it installed by a “certified marine electrician.” Mind you, replacing the autopilot computer involves swapping a handful of cables. I know because I HAVE A SPARE COMPUTER ABOARD AND HAD ALREADY TRIED IT. But Claude wasn’t interested in that. Instead, it instructed me to immediately leave my anchorage, sail to a marina charging $500 a night, and have a replacement unit overnighted from some obscure online retailer claiming to have 100 in stock. And then it could not stop telling me to GET SOME SLEEP. It was 9:30 p.m. Here’s what makes this particularly absurd. Both AI systems know my background. I’ve been sailing for FORTY YEARS. I competed on a Division I collegiate sailing team. I graduated from a maritime academy. And the bits KNIW I hold the highest professional maritime license available, a credential held by only a small fraction of mariners. I my license literally says I’m a MASTER MARINER of vessels of ANY tonnage upon ALL oceans. It’s right there in the name! If I didn’t have so much experience I’d be a nervous wreck right now thanks to these bots. Yet neither AI seemed capable of distinguishing between a genuine maritime emergency and an experienced captain troubleshooting a minor equipment problem. At least ChatGPT was trying to keep me safe, however ridiculously. Claude’s solution was somehow WORSE: Leave a protected anchorage near one of California’s most notorious maritime hazards, IN THE DARK, sail 12 hours with what it thinks is a broken autopilot, and spend $500 at a bougie marina. All so I could “get some rest.” Apparently, the safest thing you can do aboard a sailboat is spend $6,000 and sail through the night because a chatbot told you to stop bothering it and go to bed. And I thought THAT was absurd. But pulling this nonsense on JESUS? Wow. Just wow. Tony.
1
42
Love your “we need more unity” take, and you’re absolutely right. Divided we fall is more than just a bumper sticker. I’d gladly let the left dominate the coffee shops; anyone can learn to make a great cup of coffee 😝.
If you’re right wing and you can’t admit liberals (not communists) are way better at art and design and boutique coffee shops and restaurants, you’re not living in reality. If you’re left wing and you can’t admit conservatives are way better at running cities and businesses and police departments, you’re not living in reality. You step inside a beautiful coffee shop in the PNW and think “man, these liberals are great at this stuff…conservatives should take notes.” Then the moment you step outside and trip over a homeless drug zombie shooting up fentanyl on the sidewalk, you think “man these liberals are terrible at this stuff…they should really take notes from conservatives” Communists make disgusting anti-beauty art, but classical liberals aren’t like that. Put the libs in charge of the coffee shops, put the conservatives in charge of city hall. This is how you get a city that is beautiful, clean, and functional. If you can’t accept that, you need to check your tribalism. We are never getting rid of each other, so figure out how we strike a balance or else the communists swoop in and take everything from us while we quarrel over stupid bullshit…which is exactly what’s happening now.
1
2
63