Jonas Wolterstorff @bloodmandarin@tooting.social (@JoFreWo) profile picture
Göttingen/Capetown/Utrecht
Joined May 2013
...and the world cannot be saved parttime. @orschiro #MindfulMeerkats
5
1
26
Tolles Gespräch mit @DerGraslutscher und #Frosch’s Reinhard Schneider von diezuversichtlichen.de/, moderiert von @zackesberlin. Mein Beitrag: wir sollten versuchen #Zuverzicht als Begriff für Lebensqualität durch Verhaltenswandel zu etablieren. #Reframing
1
43
Jonas Wolterstorff @[email protected] retweeted
Mad respect for Hofstadter for: - updating instead of rationalizing reasons to preserve his intellectual edifice - not shrinking from the magnitude of the implications - being honest about his uncertainty We usually see opposite patterns from public intellectuals.
33
122
13
1,000
108,642
Big news: Douglas Hofstadter, a legendary scholar and famous AI skeptic, changed his mind: "I think [AI progress] is terrifying. I hate it. I think about it practically all the time, every single day.” “It feels as if the entire human race is about to be eclipsed and left in the dust. The accelerating progress has been so unexpected, caught me so completely off guard - not only myself but many, many people - there is a kind of terror of an oncoming tsunami that is going to catch all of humanity off guard." "[AI] renders humanity a very small phenomenon compared to something else far more intelligent than us, and [AI] will become incomprehensible to us, as in comprehensible to us as we are to cockroaches. “Very soon these entities [AIs] may well be far more intelligent than us, and at that point we will recede into the background. We will have handed the baton over to our successors. If this were to happen over a long time, like hundreds of years, that would be OK, but it’s happening over a period of a few years. “To me it’s quite terrifying because it suggests that everything I used to believe was the case is being overturned. I thought it would be hundreds of years before anything even remotely like a human mind would be [soon]. I never imagined that computers would rival or even surpass human intelligence. It was a goal that was so far away I wasn’t worried about it. And then it started happening at an accelerating pace, where unreachable goals and things that computers shouldn’t be able to do started toppling - the defeat of Gary Kasparov by Deep Blue, and going on to defeat the best Go players in the world. And then systems got better and better at translation between languages, and then at producing intelligible responses to difficult questions in natural language, and even writing poetry.”
Doug Hofstadter, author of Gödel, Escher, Bach and I Am a Strange Loop, is an AI doomer. Hofstadter was previously known for being dismissive of the potential of artificial neural networks & deep learning. Recent AI progress has apparently sparked a major change in his outlook.
69
231
52
1,173
790,861
Currently planning to install #heatpump+ #solarthermal+ #CeilingHeating and it is tricky but fun. (#PV is already installed) #Waermewende #RenewableHeating #Transition
1
36
Makes me quite annoyed how much the #ampel government is currently effing up, bc/ @fdp is strongarming them w/o scientific basis.
23
I keep asking ab/ a unified hierarchy of #AIrisk: #xrisk > #srisk > #erisk (#EpistemologicalRisk, my proposal) > [letter]-risk > [...Insert 10 more...] > work disappears, everyone #UBI (> measures "damage/loss", not "likelihood")
1
69
Replying to @davidchalmers42
I was curious about this also and tried to get GPT-4 and Bing to explain using argdown. I got these two ok, but unimpressive graphs before I ran out of time to experiment with this. I am guessing an AutoGPT-like system could do much better. I'd be interested to see the results.
1
405
What I see right now is people building bigger and bigger rockets with no specific ideas of how to do this safely, and then asking for specific watertight arguments for why the astronauts won't survive
4
12
1
124
6,803
It irks me that the debate of #AI #Alignment betw/ a) #Doomer/#EA/#LW eg @ESYudkowsky, b) #TechOptimist's eg @pmarca + c) #Critihype folk like @tante has so little focus on finding a common denominator. Maybe we lack a #VisualSpace for that? @Kialo?
2
267
A human brain is about 3x larger than a chimp’s, our nearest evolutionary cousin. Chimps don’t go to the moon; humans do. GPT4 is about 10x larger than GPT3. Next year we’ll likely meet systems 10 times larger than GPT4. Let’s hope they're friendly.
124
37
30
476
119,077
Can someone explain this expression to me? #UnevenAI ChatGPT believes it refers to the generality of the capacities of a hypothetical AGI in the context of the "transformative AGI" that "can perform all valuable tasks at human cost". Thoughts? @sandersted
1
241
🔎 for coherent scale/typology of AGI-induced/caused risk from w/ #xrisk to #srisk & has risk of #IdentityTheft via #Deepfakes etc. as lower risk somewhere? Does that exist? #EpistemicDoom vs #OntologicalDoom CC: @foomagemindset @_techyBen @robertskmiles @Simeon_Cps @Kat__Woods
1
192
Part of my anxiety around #AIalignment stems from the fact that I already notice greater willingness to open up to #ChatGPT ab/ anxiety than w/ my employer... Ironic. #BenevolentDictator #AInglerfish
32
I think most people (quite reasonably) think "We built ChatGPT, so we must basically understand how it works" This is not true at all. Humans did not build ChatGPT. In a way it would be closer to say we 'grew' it. We have basically no idea how it does what it does.
79
344
57
2,333
406,649
Weil eine @derspiegel-Kolumne vom letzten Sommer kürzlich in @DieZeit als scheinbar seriöse Quelle erwähnt wurde, habe ich die Kolumne einem Faktencheck unterzogen. Es fanden sich erhebliche Irreführungen! 👇 (1/14) claudiakemfert.de/6943/
66
160
30
741
151,606
.@janleike If #AIalignment is front and center of @OpenAI’s objectives w/ #GPT4, how about a podcast debate between you and @ESYudkowsky, moderated by @robertskmiles (or @bankless)? #AInglerfish #shoggoth (Meme for visibility, credit to @NellWatson)
1
1
11
566