Open Your Eyes retweeted
This story by @Imran_posts catalogues some of the ways in which the habibi account spread defamatory anti-Muslim hatred and incited violence. How is this going to genuinely 'fight antisemitism'? One MP was threatened /1
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Even Foreign Secretary @Ed_Miliband attacked as the "Palestine Secretary", with 'Palestine' cast as a racialised slur /3
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Yes, this is a major part of this story.
This broader network including habibi, GnasherJew and Labour Against Antisemitism frequently target left-wing Jews like Justin Schlosberg, Andrew Feinstein, Stephen Kapos, Michael Rosen etc. Quite often, when the true identity of these agitator accounts are revealed, they turn out to be run by non-Jews.
But this story isn't just some snowflakey reaction to robust online discourse. There are massive real-world implications about how this network operates.
First, many of the accounts in this network are anonymous. They say defamatory things about people who cannot defend their reputation - you can't sue anonymous amounts or put social pressure on named individuals to retract defamatory statements.
Second, these accounts directly feed into alarmist stories in the right-wing press: the type of story that calls Misam Harriman or Linkeker racist. These are absurdities. It is genuinely absurd that they are being accused of anti-Jew hate. Madness. Yet these accounts provide grist to mill for the press to go after public figures who criticise Israel or challenge the status quo.
These stories are important. They send the message to other celebrities or politicians that speaking out, even mildly, about Israel, can see your words taken out of context, driving media coverage, and then driving you out of your job.
They also create a sense of ambient, unrelenting crisis; that there is an epidemic of hate seeping into every corner of our society; that it is so pervasive that even the nice guy from the footy has been infected.
Most often this becomes coded and couched in Islamophobic terms - just look at how often habibi goes after pro-Gaza Muslims. The right-wing press is adept at using this to feed into broader "clash of civilisation/anti-immigration" rhetoric. This empowers and emboldens the far-right, but also builds elite consent for attacks on civil liberties and protest.
Third, the "evidence" these accounts produce feed into formal processes. Labour Party files show that there are loads of complaints submitted to the Labour Party with evidence from Habibi and GnasherJew. Some emails show GnasherJew advising people on complaints. Habibi, using a Gmail address, had complained directly to the Party in certain cases.
Mish Rahman has confirmed that candidates were blocked from standing for the Labour Party based on dossiers with Habibi evidence - the Starmerite bureaucracy, which routinely blocked left-wingers for nonsense, were provided with the ammo they needed to transform the Party by habibi and other agitators.
This is genuinely mad: anonymous agitator accounts, who code most expressions of pro-Gaza views as hate, and who routinely target left-wing Jews, were being used as the evidential bedrock to decide who could and couldn't be an MP or councillor.
Finally, there is the human cost. People's lives have been upended, sometimes destroyed, by this tiny ecosystem. It's sometimes caused real pain.
In The Fraud, I used the story of the Jewish Labour Party member Riva Joffe to illustrate this.
Joffe was born to parents who fled antisemitic pogroms in Eastern Europe, and who were forced to flee South Africa (where they had settled) because they became anti-apartheid activists. Joffe became a respected psychoanalyst in the UK.
In 2021, on her deathbed, she was sent a letter by the Labour Party saying she was being investigated for antisemitism. Her "crime" was to share an invite on Facebook to a BDS event at a university.
The complaint was submitted by "David Gordstein" - the made-up identity created by Euan Phillips, a spokesperson for LAAS. Joffe spent her last weeks answering a charge the she was antisemitic, based on a complaint from a made-up identity.
Joffe died while under investigation for antisemitism. The Party refused to tell her son if the case had been resolved after she died.
If you think any of that is OK, then you need to have your head checked.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
.@BylineTimes has unearthed the identity of the man behind the core anonymous habibi_uk X account at the centre of 57 accounts, including about a dozen or so other anonymous accounts.
Why is this account important? Because, behind anonymity, and through a network of anonymous allied accounts which self-boost and self-amplify, it works to get picked up in the mainstream to influence national conversations. So the question of who and what are driving this process is a matter of public interest.
Contrary to the beliefs and expectations of many, this account is not a British Jew at all. This story reveals that he is an American, a former State Department foreign service officer, specialising in counter extremism and political military diplomacy. He is also, bizarrely, the grandson of the philosopher Bertrand Russell.
In this exclusive, we reveal not only the key named individuals with whom habibi works, including senior politicians and think-tankers, but also startling evidence of his pivotal role in a dark money funded online attack operation against the Labour Party.
He runs - or ran, until this investigation - the habibi account full-time. He has direct ties with Lord Austin, UK trade envoy to Israel, and Lord Walney. He works with the Henry Jackson Society. It is unclear how his activity is financed, or where from.
Habibi - who is actually Benjamin Tait - is surrounded by several constellation anonymous trolls accounts such as the fascist Subversive Force X account which is its top anonymous booster: a racist, anti-Muslim, anti-Black account that regularly demonises 'Islam', calls every Muslim it sees an 'Islamist', and portrays any Muslim public figure as some sort of 'Shariah Law' toting demagogue.
I know this well because of being regularly targeted in hateful, defamatory posts full of far-right extremist bile and conspiratorial lies which portray minorities, particularly black and Muslim minorities, as an inherent jihadist threat.
The countless number of racist and bigoted anti-Muslim posts by these accounts is astonishing. I find it really hard to understand how someone can look at an account like Subversive Force and see it as a bulwark against antisemitism and a force against extremism. It is not. Whatever it is, it is not that.
Yes, there are times when real extremism and antisemitism is found and targeted. But there are countless examples of online harassment, defamation, misinformation, deliberate distortion and plain bullshit put out by these accounts, at the centre of which is Ben Tait.
That is the problem and the danger of hiding behind online anonymity. The scope for unhinged defamation, uncontrolled misinformation, and even plainly unlawful and criminal conduct in the form of harassment and even incitement, is without limits.
bylinetimes.com/2026/11/16/w…
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Replying to @BylineTimes
All those people slandered, smeared and lied about by this cunt should sue the pants off him.
The irony of a non Jew targeting left wing Jews all to defend genocide and ethnic cleansing is the most disturbing of the findings.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
This is one of the false & libellous statements “Habibi” aka Ben Tait made about me and my work. Thanks to @BylineTimes for revealing this troll account and how it’s amplified falsehoods about me @misanharriman @GaryLineker& others for calling out the Israeli Govt for murdering children in Gaza.
@zeteouk @mehdirhasan
Open Your Eyes retweeted
The anonymous account @habibi_uk that has been posting lies, defamatory statements and has been involved in character assassinations has now been unmasked.
Did those that amplified the account know the identity and funding behind the account ?
Were the retweets , amplifications and endorsements a concerted and planned approach?
Genuine questions not pre legal action questions.
This is an attack on our democracy and we need to get to the bottom of who was involved and what they knew.
@danwootton @stephenpollard @JakeWSimons
@LordIanAustin
@ Simon Myerson KC
@alanmendoza
@davidtoube
Open Your Eyes retweeted
"whose account I didn't know existed..."
I'm now following @habibi_uk whose account I didn't know existed before I read @BylineTimes "six month investigation" into "online coordinated attacks" by Jews against people who want to kill Jews. Cheers for that.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
A leading pathologist says there was “zero per cent chance” that convicted sex offender Jeffrey Epstein died by suicide.
Professor Michael Freeman is a cause of death specialist, who was an expert witness in the George Floyd case.
After reviewing the New York medical examiner’s file provided to him by Epstein’s family, he said the most likely cause was an assault followed by strangulation from behind.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
This story is more sinister than just an anonymous troll account being exposed. And it should be treated very seriously.
Habibi UK smeared Jeremy Corbyn in 317 posts from behind a fake name. But it gets worse.
The man behind it, as just revealed by @BylineTimes, is Ben Tait, who was sole director and controlling owner of the company that spent £134,457 at the 2019 election, including on ads attacking Corbyn and Labour.
No donor was declared. £6,880 of it was paid to Tait himself.
So the "anonymous researcher" was the paid director of an anti-Corbyn campaign. He ran the adverts under one name and the smears under another.
That campaign was Mainstream. Its founder and chairman is Lord Austin, the UK's trade envoy to Israel.
Austin shared Habibi's posts at least 34 times. Habibi shared Austin's 79 times. A peer was promoting his own campaign's director to the public as if he were a stranger.
It gets worse in Leicester.
In September 2022, Hindu and Muslim men clashed on the streets of Leicester for weeks. Two months later the Henry Jackson Society published a report on it that played down the part Hindutva activists had played. That report cited the anonymous Habibi account in nine endnotes.
In May 2023 Michael Gove ordered an independent government review of the violence. He put Lord Austin in charge.
The Muslim Council of Britain protested. Leicester's Federation of Muslim Organisations told the Prime Minister the review would have no credibility. More than 100 Muslim groups and individuals in the city refused to take part.
They did not know the half of it. The man chairing the review had spent years sharing an anonymous account that attacked Muslim politicians by name. That account was a source for the main report on the same violence. And the man running it was the director of Austin's own campaign company.
This is the account that attacked 363 people. It called Stephen Kapos, a Holocaust survivor who marched for Gaza, a "stain". It called people opposing Israel's genocide "hate marchers".
This isn’t just an anonymous hater on the internet. He has secretly participated in so-called “independent reviews” and has been part of a network that has harassed, doxed and smeared hundreds of individuals.
Ben Tait is now a name that can be directly attributed as the figure behind these attacks. The recipients finally have the ability to seek justice against him, as a named individual.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Habibi, you're fucked now that you've been identified.
Loads of people will be suing your ass.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Would just like to state, for the purposes of clarity, and because this is now far beyond ridiculous, that I am not in fact a drug addict.
I mean, for heavens sake 🤣🤦♀️ – at Carmarthen, Wales
Open Your Eyes retweeted
You've a nerve. Aleks spent that entire video with her hand covering her mouth. And no, my above tweets are not actionable. This is though. – at Carmarthen, Wales
Women with autoimmune diseases such as lupus or rheumatoid arthritis wait around four years for a diagnosis, compared with three months to less than a year for men, according to a survey by British researchers. Women also face having their symptoms dismissed as “psychological.” nbcnews.com/health/womens-he…
Open Your Eyes retweeted
You've made several false and defamatory claims in this post.
1. You fabricate the claim that we work with the antisemitic Putinist shill David Miller. I presume we are talking about this guy? teapawt.org/NafeezAhmed/status/210… Suffice to say, no, this is a lie. Are you in the habit of simply stating things without any basis in fact?
2. You claim that Byline Times receives tax payers' money. This is also false, but if you want to rely on Gilligan for this, you may want to check his track record when it comes to libel cases.
3. You call Ben Tait a counter extremist. Why then does he fabricate lies? His sister account, Subversive Force, regularly calls ordinary Muslims in public 'Islamists'. That you equate this anonymous trolling with 'fighting antisemitism' is a disgrace.
So @BylineTimes, which was so angry about people reporting on Jason Arday, have presented their ‘journalism’ about the account Habibi.
Working with one of the nastiest antisemites in the country, conspiracist David Miller, they’ve doxxed someone who has been working in counter extremism for years.
The reason people do this anonymously is because it’s dangerous work. Many of these people are dangerous. I have friends who have to have bodyguards because of the danger they are in.
And the company which runs this conspiracy outfit - can’t call it journalism- which doxxes people who make our country safer, just got £250,000 of our money.
This stinks. @AngelaRayner @lisanandy at the very least, these people should not be getting tax payers’ money.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
This is the same woman who argued with me that using the N-word is 'free speech'.
Bearing that in mind I think it's fair to say she doesn't like Black people 🤔
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Just one of the world’s best people, full stop.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
Please read this folks.
Heidi, We have never interacted before, so before I begin I would like to say I am deeply sorry for what the horrors your family has suffered at the hands of the terror group Hamas. I oppose Hamas and antisemitism unequivocally, and whatever else we may disagree about, I will stand with you on that no matter what.
However, your posts about my 2010 talk seriously misrepresent what I said, my work on 9/11 and appear to be aimed at deliberately damaging my professional reputation.
My published work in books, essays and talks holds al-Qaeda responsible for the 9/11 terrorist attacks. It investigates how Western governments’ relationships with states supporting Islamist militants - Saudi Arabia and Pakistan above all - compromised intelligence and accountability. Investigating those relationships does not mean claiming that the US government perpetrated the attacks.
My 9/11 work has received substantial recognition. My first book on the subject, The War on Freedom, was among 99 books made available to each 9/11 Commissioner. In 2005, I gave evidence at a Congressional briefing (this is how I first met Cynthia McKinney who at that time was not a conspiracy theorist but a Democrat Congressional representative who had twice won the state of Georgia); an extract appears in the Congressional Record.
The Independent described my second 9/11 book, The War on Truth, as “disturbing and clearly evidenced”.
The bin Laden line you quote comes from my closing remarks. In those same remarks, I called for moving beyond the division between conspiracy theorists and their opponents to focus on facts:
“… we need to come out of this constructed divide and focus … fundamentally on what we know, and ask really hard questions about those issues. Because it’s clear that we cannot establish a paper trail on either side.”
You make out as if questioning the government's evidential case amounts to denying al-Qaeda's involvement. That is not the case. Legal scholars routinely distinguish between intelligence consensus and admissible courtroom proof. Although intelligence agencies documented al-Qaeda’s responsibility for 9/11, the US and UK governments bypassed and compromised standard criminal procedures, leaving the wider official narrative heavily reliant on unverified detainee interrogations rather than open-court convictions.
While I questioned the government’s evidential case, I also criticised conspiracy theorists and said "there was no paper trail establishing that a particular individual had ordered or allowed the attacks." I concluded:
“… we’re much stronger if we focus less on those particular interpretations and focus on the contradictions [and] anomalies.”
You cannot fairly present that passage as endorsing an alternative theory while omitting its explicit warning that the alternative had not been established either. This is especially clear given my repeated published criticism of inside-job reasoning. You omit to acknowledge that I described “inside job” as a “meaningless bullshit euphemism” for claiming government responsibility without proof, and “a vague, amorphous cop-out typical of the conspiracy industry in general”.
I also recorded challenging David Shayler at my 2006 House of Lords book launch when he declared that 9/11 and 7/7 were inside jobs. I described his pronouncements as “a disgraceful affront to the 9/11 and 7/7 families”.
These are my own words, publicly available from over a decade ago: nafeezahmed.net/thecuttinged…
You also wrote that I “cast doubt on the hijackers being Islamists because a few went to Las Vegas”. Yet in the same talk I described the men at the centre of the plot as “very, very close to Osama bin Laden, part of this very strict Salafist Wahhabi puritanical trend”.
Their Islamism was the starting point of that discussion. I noted that Las Vegas visits were documented by US investigators and examined former CIA officer Robert Baer’s account of ignored warnings. The Commission itself noted the anomaly, saying it had “seen no credible evidence explaining why” the hijackers visited Las Vegas. Reducing that passage to “a few went to Las Vegas” strips out its substance.
Such questions are more live than ever because of the mounting evidence of the ties between the hijackers and Saudi military intelligence - which anomalies such as above may be consistent with. In August 2025, a US federal judge rejected Saudi Arabia’s attempt to dismiss the 9/11 families’ claims on sovereign-immunity grounds. The judge concluded that the evidence was sufficient to support an inference that two Saudi men had assisted the hijackers through their employment by the Saudi government. This demonstrates why investigating possible state support for al-Qaeda is a serious evidential question.
On the meeting itself: it took place in Parliament in 2010, not 2011. As I recall, the room was booked by the late Michael Meacher, then a Labour MP and former environment minister. Recordings were subsequently posted online by others, including a 9/11 truth website, independently of me.
You also linked me to Cynthia McKinney, who spoke at that meeting. I first met her in 2005, when she convened the Congressional briefing. The 2010 meeting was the last time I met or had any contact with her.
Her subsequent claim that “Zionists” carried out 9/11, made in 2021, is undoubtedly an antisemitic conspiracy theory. The suggestion that I am presciently responsible for views she expressed more than a decade after our last contact is indefensible.
Your posts grotesquely disregard and misrepresent my own published position, which is clear for anyone to check and see. And your selective omissions change the meaning of what I said.
You are of course entitled to challenge my research, and my actual views. Identify a factual error and substantiate it. You are not entitled to attribute positions to me that I have explicitly criticised and then use them to attack my professional credibility.
I regard your posts as defamatory and reserve my legal rights.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
You have made it very clear that you dislike me and everything I stand for, @nicolelampert. Why on earth are you friend requesting my private Instagram page? Please leave me alone.
Open Your Eyes retweeted
You say: "I also find the suggestion that gender-critical feminism is increasingly converging with the far right particularly lazy? Are we talking about specific individuals, organisations, political alliances or simply women who disagree with the author's interpretation of immigration and women's safety?"
I am one of those who think that "gender-critical feminism is increasingly converging with the far right" and I mean *you* for example:
📌 On 11 February 2026, you implied that Muslims are "goat fuckers" in a reply to KJK: teapawt.org/AjaTheEmpress/status/2…
📌 On 24 March 2026, you wrote "Muslims would hunt down and cut the heads off" those who smash the "statute of Muhammad" and that "You can’t risk offending Muslims without risking your neck": teapawt.org/AjaTheEmpress/status/2…
📌 On 2 June 2026, you wrote "You think we didn't already know muslims hate us homosexuals? We have seen your rooftop parties, we know": teapawt.org/AjaTheEmpress/status/2…
📌 On 8 October 2025, you wrote "Why are people shocked by her views? These are pretty normal for a Muslim in my experience. Obviously not all (its never all) but a lot of them have a red hot simmering hated of Jews that's easily exposed if you just scratch the surface.": teapawt.org/AjaTheEmpress/status/1…
I include the links for contexts. There are many more. In your case, we cannot talk about a convergence between gender critical and the far right. This *is* far right, of the racist kind.
I've read the Women's Resource Centre article, and I have to say I'm deeply uncomfortable with its argument.
There is a difference between making sweeping generalisations about an entire population and raising legitimate concerns about patterns of behaviour, cultural attitudes, institutional failures and women's safety.
What concerns me about this article is how quickly it moves from describing a handful of survey responses to making sweeping claims about the political direction of an entire section of the women's movement.
Apparently, if women raise concerns about migrant men, asylum policy, sexual violence or the treatment of women within particular cultural and religious communities, we're now dangerously close to the far right.
Really?
Women have spent decades being told to speak up about male violence. We've been encouraged to name it, challenge it, examine the conditions that enable it and demand that institutions take it seriously. But apparently there are now restrictions on which men we're allowed to talk about, which cultural practices we're allowed to criticise and which questions we're allowed to ask.
Women's safety doesn't become less important because discussing it makes somebody uncomfortable.
And let's talk about the three examples the WRC uses to illustrate what it considers hostility towards migrant men.
• Firstly, concerns about male asylum seekers and women's safety.
Of course women are going to be particularly concerned about male asylum seekers when discussing women's safety. That's hardly surprising, is it?
Women are discussing sexual violence, safeguarding, accommodation and the risks associated with living alongside unfamiliar men. Why would we expect women not to raise those concerns?
Perhaps we should establish exactly who we're talking about here. Are we discussing asylum seekers generally, or are we specifically discussing the men arriving in the UK by small boats?
These are not interchangeable categories, and pretending they are doesn't help anyone have an honest conversation about immigration policy or safeguarding.
The fact that the men in question are migrants doesn't mean women must switch off their safeguarding instincts.
And why does the article seem to treat concern about the safety of migrant women as legitimate, but concern about the safety of women in communities receiving asylum seekers as somehow suspicious?
Both deserve consideration.
And here's the elephant in the room: we know that some of the men arriving in these circumstances come from countries and cultural backgrounds where women have significantly fewer rights, where misogyny is deeply entrenched and where women's freedom and independence are restricted in ways that would be unacceptable here.
The suggestion seems to be that once these men arrive in the UK, those attitudes somehow disappear at the border. That they leave those beliefs behind along with their belongings. But why would we assume that? Cultural attitudes don't automatically change because somebody crosses the Channel.
Of course, not every man from those countries holds the same beliefs, and individuals should be judged on their own actions. But pretending that cultural attitudes have no bearing on how women are treated is just as dishonest as making sweeping assumptions about every individual.
And if anyone thinks I'm making this up, look at the Government's own actions.
In August 2026, the Home Office published a nine-page guide for asylum seekers explaining that rape and sexual assault are crimes, that consent is required every time, that women have equal rights to men and that men cannot control what women wear, where they go or whether they work.
Think about that for a moment.
The Government considers it necessary to explain these basic principles to men arriving in this country. We're talking about having to spell out that you cannot rape women, sexually harass them or control their lives.
So when women raise concerns about the attitudes some men may bring with them, perhaps those concerns aren't quite as unreasonable as the WRC would like us to believe.
Why is the Government recognising the need to communicate these expectations while women who raise the underlying concerns are accused of prejudice?
We should be able to have an honest conversation about why this guidance was considered necessary in the first place, without immediately being accused of racism.
We should be able to talk openly about these differences, ask how they affect women's safety and discuss what expectations we have of people coming to live in this country. That isn't racism. It's a legitimate conversation about women's rights.
• Secondly, concerns about sexual violence against women travelling through irregular migration routes.
The article describes one respondent's claim that women and girls arriving through irregular migration routes face an almost universal risk of rape as a sweeping assertion.
But this isn't some fringe concern invented by an angry respondent on a survey. There are very real, documented cases of women being raped, sexually assaulted and exploited during these journeys.
And these aren't just dangers experienced on migration routes elsewhere in the world. There have been documented cases involving women arriving here in the UK.
One woman had disclosed being repeatedly raped by a people smuggler just five days before leaving France. She was described as suicidal and inconsolable. Another woman disclosed that she had been raped twice during her journey to the UK.
The Home Secretary, Shabana Mahmood, has also recently raised this issue, stating that nearly every woman attempting to reach the UK by small boat from northern France has probably been raped during the journey.
So is the Home Secretary also expressing hostility towards migrant men? Or is it possible that this is a serious safeguarding issue that deserves to be discussed?
You cannot dismiss concerns as racist simply because they overlap with arguments being made by people whose politics you dislike.
If anything, these accounts demonstrate precisely why the safety of women and girls should be central to any discussion about migration.
• Thirdly, the suggestion that refugee protection should prioritise women and children.
Well, yes. Women and feminist organisations have historically advocated for women and children to receive particular protection in situations of war, conflict, displacement and sexual violence.
Why? Because women and children are often particularly vulnerable to sexual violence, exploitation, trafficking and abuse.
That's not a radical concept. It's a fairly fundamental part of safeguarding.
Prioritising women and children doesn't mean that men cannot be victims, that male refugees don't deserve protection or that every individual man is responsible for violence.
Since when did advocating for women and children become evidence of prejudice?
And let's talk about intersectionality, because it's being used here as though it gives some women the authority to decide which concerns are legitimate and which are politically unacceptable.
Intersectionality should mean recognising that women have different experiences. It shouldn't mean creating a hierarchy in which some women's experiences are given greater legitimacy while others are treated with suspicion.
Working-class women, black women, white women, migrant women, lesbian women and women from religious minorities all have the right to speak about their experiences.
None of us should have to qualify our concerns by first demonstrating that we hold the correct political opinions.
Who gets to decide which concerns are acceptable, and whose voices are being dismissed? There's something particularly patronising about women in organisations and institutions telling working-class women what they should be concerned about, how they should interpret their own experiences and which opinions they should hold.
Working-class women are often the ones living with the consequences of decisions made by people who don't share their circumstances.
We're expected to accept those decisions quietly, and if we question them, we're told our concerns are rooted in prejudice. It's another way of telling certain women that they don't know what's best for themselves.
Dose the writer live next door to a HMO? Is there one next to their daughter's school? Do they pass encampments of men on their way to work in the morning? Do they see groups of men hanging around drinking all day in the local park or by their local shop?
Because this is the reality for many women, including myself. These aren't debates happening in a conference room or on a survey.
They're things women encounter in their everyday lives, in their neighbourhoods and on their doorsteps.
It's easy to dismiss women's concerns when you aren't the one living with the consequences.
Just look at Piddington in Oxfordshire. Plans to accommodate up to 1,256 male asylum seekers at a former military site near the village prompted 133 local women to write an open letter to female MPs, raising concerns about their safety and the impact on their community.
And this isn't some political debate for those women. It's their village, their homes, their children and their everyday lives.
It's easy to lecture other women about tolerance and accuse them of prejudice when you aren't the person being asked to live next door to the accommodation, walk past it every day or consider what it might mean for your family.
I also find the suggestion that gender-critical feminism is increasingly converging with the far right particularly lazy? Are we talking about specific individuals, organisations, political alliances or simply women who disagree with the author's interpretation of immigration and women's safety?
If there are examples of racism, name them. If there are examples of far-right political alliances, identify them. But don't use the existence of some unacceptable comments to cast suspicion over an entire movement.
And let's not forget that the article itself acknowledges that there are legitimate debates to be had about sex-based rights. Yet it seems remarkably comfortable drawing political conclusions about the women having those debates.
There is something deeply ironic about an organisation that says it doesn't want to police the women's sector while simultaneously setting out which political positions it considers acceptable and which women need to examine their assumptions.
A women's movement that only welcomes women who arrive at the approved political conclusions isn't much of a movement for women at all.
And then we get to the conclusion, which I think is particularly telling.
The author appears frustrated that, rather than accepting the WRC's position, women have challenged it, raised objections and expressed views that the organisation finds unacceptable.
And what is the proposed response? Apparently, the women's sector must now spend time making sure women aren't racist.
Just stop and think about that for a moment.
Women raise concerns, disagree with an organisation's position and challenge its political framing, and the response is to suggest that those women need educating about racism.
Whatever happened to engaging with the arguments? Whatever happened to taking women's concerns seriously, even when you disagree with them?
You cannot claim to be building a broad women's movement while treating women who disagree with you as a problem that needs correcting.
The problem isn't that women need to be taught not to be racist every time they express an opinion the organisation dislikes.
The problem is an apparent unwillingness to accept that women can arrive at different conclusions, raise uncomfortable questions and disagree without their motives being put on trial.
We should be able to challenge misogyny without making excuses for it when it appears in communities we'd rather not offend.
We should be able to discuss immigration without being branded extremists, and we should be able to defend women's sex-based rights without having our politics defined for us by somebody else.
Truth doesn't become racism because it's politically inconvenient.
And women's rights shouldn't come with a list of subjects we're no longer allowed to discuss.
Women are not a political re-education project.
wrc.org.uk/Blog/womens-right…















































