I'm offering a USD$500 reward to the first person who can present pre-2020 human-written text that the latest version of @pangram flags as AI.
The specific requirements to claim the reward are:
1. At least 750 consecutive words.
2. Pangram flags it as 75% or more AI generated.
3. You provide proof that the text was first written in 2019 or earlier and is unmodified.
4. The text was ostensibly human written. This requirement only exists to avoid trick answers like output from GPT-2, machine translation, markov chains, the same word 500 times etc.
Regarding requirement #3, unfortunately in 2026 there's no way to prove that new text wasn't AI generated, so what I need provided is proof that the text existed in 2019 or earlier, before AI writing got so good. For example, valid proof might be:
- A link to the text on a website that's been logged by the Internet Archive's Wayback Machine before 2020.
- A link to a paper published on a third party website with a pre-2020 publication date. Note: I will need to be able to access the paper through the same website that has its publication date. Otherwise someone could send a modern AI generated paper and simply link to the date and abstract of a paper with the same name but different content.
- A chapter from a book edition with a known pre-2020 publication date where I can access a pre-2020 copy for myself. Note: For the same reasons as above, simply sending a passage of text and a link to a book's name and publication date doesn't prove anything on its own. The ideal situation would either be that there's an eBook of it available somewhere with a known pre-2020 upload date, or it's a well-known enough book that the content simply couldn't be faked everywhere.
Q&A:
"Why are you offering this reward?"
Some people are blaming the detector because they don't want to admit to using AI for their writing. I don't like people lying for personal gain.
"Are you affiliated with Pangram in any way?"
No.
"How do I submit something to you?"
Just reply to this tweet with the necessary info and I'll have a look when I can.
"How can I trust you to judge fairly?"
I'll publicly reply with my verdict on submissions and the world can judge me. The world can also judge you - please only submit something if it really fits all the criteria. Especially since I'll need to review all submissions in my free time.
"But it's my private writing, can I send it to you privately?"
If it's always been private then how will you prove that it's pre-2020?
"I have the perfect example but I left the text with my girlfriend in Canada."
She can submit it and win $500.
"Won't this be trivially easy to claim? I heard even chapters of Don Quixote and Moby-Dick get fully flagged as AI!"
Tell me which chapter and win $500.
"Conversely, isn't 750 words at >=75% a high bar? If Pangram is so reliable, why not 1%?"
At very low word counts Pangram IS somewhat unreliable, and with a monetary incentive I can imagine someone scanning every book on Project Gutenberg just to find one paragraph that's falsely flagged as AI. At the same time, most claims that Pangram is flagging human writing as AI have it showing the entire text as AI. I recently saw someone on X say that they personally knew of "thousands" of examples of human text that was flagged like this (unfortunately they declined to mention any). So I've set the bar somewhere in the middle.
"But Pangram was trained on existing text; that's why it always flags OLD text as human but falsely flags NEW text."
As far as I'm aware this isn't really how Pangram works. But I'd love to be able to award this bounty for new human writing, it's just that there's no way to verify people's honesty online for the new stuff.
"How will you pay out if I win?"
However works. Probably an international bank transfer via @Wise .
"How can I help?"
When someone says they know of an old published paper or story that Pangram flags as AI, you could point them to this tweet. They can win $500.
"How long will your offer last if nobody wins?"
As long as this post is up. If you're reading this, it's still available.
Got to attend the SOMC meeting a few weeks ago. Piskorski, Howard Marks (Oaktree capital mgmt), and Ken Kencel (Churchill asset mgmt) made up an excellent panel with great data on the role, and stability, of private credit.
Replying to @ProfJAParker
But isn’t this just banking—minus the bank? Matvos, Piskorski & Seru: not currently. Private-credit funds are 65–80% equity financed, have little maturity mismatch, and diversified portfolios. That is not the classic bank-run recipe.
aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.12…
1
4
324
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
Still, “not a bank” is not a free pass. Both papers point to watching for: opaque valuations, liquidity provision, links to banks and PE, and who ultimately absorbs losses. Boring plumbing—until it isn’t. But so far, it appears that private credit has moved risk out of banks.
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
But isn’t this just banking—minus the bank? Matvos, Piskorski & Seru: not currently. Private-credit funds are 65–80% equity financed, have little maturity mismatch, and diversified portfolios. That is not the classic bank-run recipe.
aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.12…
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
The fact that two Huangs are involved in an affair, but only one takes the blame is commonly known as Jensen's Inequality.
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
My piece in @ProSyn explains the reality of the benefits and costs of discretionary fiscal stimulus payments to households
Whether they are labeled “stimulus” or “dividends,” government giveaways amount to nothing more than buying political goodwill with taxpayers’ money, argues @UChicago’s @GregWKaplan. project-syndicate.org/commen…
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
This is such a great overview of how AI beating humans in a task can actually unlock human ability—it allows understanding that was impossible otherwise.
This is what I expect to happen in math btw: first shock, then a dawn of math research as new understanding becomes possible.
JOE ROGAN: The computing power on your phone today. can you beat your phone at the highest level?
MAGNUS CARLSEN: No. No chance.
JOE ROGAN: That’s crazy. Wasn’t Deep Blue basically a whole stack of computers? And your phone is probably more powerful than that today.
MAGNUS CARLSEN: It’s shocking. I have no chance against my phone.
JOE ROGAN: So how do you even play against computers?
MAGNUS CARLSEN: I rarely play against engines because they just make me feel stupid and useless. I think of them more as a tool.
JOE ROGAN: But have computers actually changed how you understand chess?
MAGNUS CARLSEN: Absolutely. Neural networks have improved our understanding of the game immensely.
JOE ROGAN: What did you learn from them that humans weren’t already doing?
MAGNUS CARLSEN: One big thing was long-term king safety. Humans used to push pawns mainly as an attacking tool. But the engines showed that you could push a pawn and create a weakness 20 or 30 moves later that would make the opponent’s king less safe.
JOE ROGAN: So the computer basically showed you ideas that humans weren’t seeing.
MAGNUS CARLSEN: Exactly. There was a period where you could clearly see which players were using these new neural-network ideas and which weren’t.
JOE ROGAN: And you were one of the guys who figured it out early?
MAGNUS CARLSEN: Yeah. My coach got into it very quickly, and we gained an advantage over almost everybody.
JOE ROGAN: That’s insane. The machines aren’t just better at calculating, they’re actually teaching the best players how to think differently.
MAGNUS CARLSEN: That’s probably the biggest impact they’ve had on chess.
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
If you are hiring in Macro-Finance/Monetary, I urge you to take a look at Lennart, an outstanding candidate on the market from Cambridge.
His JMP won the 2026 ECB Young Economist Prize and the Cambridge Finance Best Student Paper Award.
lennart-niermann.com/
Excited to present my JMP: Decomposing the Investment Channel of Monetary Policy
❓How does corporate investment respond to lower borrowing costs? And how do contemporaneous belief revisions around monetary policy surprises affect this response?
💡We find that investment is more responsive to small changes in borrowing costs than previously thought. Further, belief revisions that coincide with monetary policy surprises appear to play a sizable dampening role.
🔗lennart-niermann.github.io/J…
👇Summary
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
Here’s an interesting incentives problem: Strikes like this one benefit incumbent students, but not entrant cohorts. On the flip side, you can think that Universities have a reverse hold up problem (e.g. no incentives to raise salaries after inflation as PhD’s are locked in.) So there’s a tension between rent extraction from younger cohorts and from a monopolist.
My hunch is that a planner with imperfect info may respondo to strikes by promising raises only to incoming cohorts: wanna fight for fairness? Then make it about fairness toward others.
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
Binghamton econ is hiring this year in applied micro, and I'm on the search committee. Our job posting: aeaweb.org/joe/listing.php?J…
If you are on the market and think this could be a good match, please apply! If you know someone who may be interested, please help spread the word!
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
Does this guy realize he's getting a Harvard PhD education for free (tuition is 60k per year at Harvard, and most PhD students don't pay it)? Does this guy realize the extensive margin effect of these strikes? At UCI, PhD enrollment fell 30.3% from F22 to F23 after the strike.
This is a bad equilibrium, actually. AI, when asked to find errors, will do so w/ near certainty*. That does not mean the errors are worth taking seriously, and says nothing about the work at hand.
Peer-reviewed journals are now more important than ever for providing signals.
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
Woke up this morning to a clear and overwhelming repudiation of the Treasury buyback program. Wow.
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
This time of year, as it gets dark around 430pm, I remember this Milton Friedman passage...
The argument for a flexible exchange rate is, strange to say, very nearly identical with the argument for daylight savings time. Isn't it absurd to change the clock in summer when exactly the same result could be achieved by having each individual change his habits? All that is required is that everyone decide to come to his office an hour earlier, have lunch an hour earlier, etc. But obviously it is much simpler to change the clock that guides all than to have each individual separately change his pattern of reaction to the clock, even though all want to do so. The situation is exactly the same in the exchange market. It is far simpler to allow one price to change, namely, the price of foreign exchange, than to rely upon changes in the multitude of prices that together constitute the internal price structure.
in The Case for Flexible Exchange Rates
(or, In Recognition of Sticky Prices)
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
An honor to have @UChicago's @GregWKaplan on the @HooverInst @CapAndFreedom podcast talking history of macroeconomics from Keynes to HANK. We talk about the Hall-Woodford Nobel Prize, the importance of microfoundations, monetary & fiscal, the purpose of models, and Greg's book.
Why do some households spend their stimulus checks while others save them?
On @CapAndFreedom, Hoover Visiting Fellow @Jon_Hartley_ and University of Chicago economist @GregWKaplan explore how differences in income, wealth, and access to cash shape the effects of interest rates and fiscal stimulus—and what that means for economic policy.
Watch on Hoover+: hoover.org/plus/research/his…
Sid Gundapaneni retweeted
🗳️The entire country is watching to see if California voters will soon approve a proposed one-time, 5% tax on the state's wealthiest residents. Want to know what the fuss is all about? Tune into this fiery SIEPR Economic Summit debate, linked in 🧵 below. #Prop40 #BillionaireTax




























