Michael J. Relyea retweeted
In late 2020, Elon Musk asked the SpaceX team why the tower arms that already stack the rocket couldn't catch the returning booster too, and after hours of debate in which most engineers leaned toward landing legs, he put Stephen Harlow, the one engineer who kept pushing for the tower, in charge of making it happen. Later, when a follower asked why not just use legs, Elon replied: "Legs would certainly work, but the best part is no part."
Four years later, on October 13, 2024, the tower caught a Super Heavy booster on its very first try. On November 14, 2026, those same arms closed around Starship itself, and Walter Isaacson wrote that he will "always remember the looks on the engineers' faces in the Starbase conference room in December 2020" when Elon "suggested, then insisted" on it. And it's so fkng cool that a wild idea in a conference room became one more step toward the Holy Grail of rocketry. What a time to be alive!
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
忍不住把这两段视频拼了一下,你们感受下。
两个看点,一是星舰二级直径 9 米,最后被「筷子」架住的结构承力销钉托住,也就是左右那两个「耳朵」,大小只有 10 cm 左右。估算一下,托住星舰二级的两个「耳朵」大约只占星舰二级飞船本体面积的 0.05%。
打个比方,这真就是用两根筷子架住一栋 50 多米的大楼,架住楼的是左右两边门把手大小的凸起。
这什么变态的姿态控制精度?!
二是前襟翼上的摄像头,要经历在太空中几十个小时在轨的极低温考验,回来以后轨道再入承受大概 1400 ℃ 高温的加热,以及再入时的振动和气动载荷,当然摄像头本体、通信和布线都是有陶瓷热防护瓦片防护的,那也很变态了。
顶尖的工程,顶尖的传播。
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
Replying to @Opkegger1 @DesoGames
Thats insane technology. Does it have uses outside space travel?
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
I don't really get why this type of comment has been showing up so much lol. This is an intentionally ablative add-on that's already been carbonized and would likely have to be replaced regardless. Pretty clear that it's just a cheap/easy stopgap for a more permanent fix.
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
That's... interesting, and to me at least confusing. 🤔
Some sort of material that survives entry and doesn't scrape off?
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
Replying to @Opkegger1 @DesoGames
Awesome. can you test the layer depth automatically and then reapply? Sorry, i've got a thing for spray on ablative heat shields.
was looking at ablative spray on systems, and aligning fibre direction with electrostatics. seems a far more promising direction for the long term, in that deficiencies in a spray on coat can be rectified with surface prep and sprat, and you can measure your depth releatively easily, and find cracks using ultasonics.
Quick clarification since people are asking. The boron oxide layer was my first iteration, open-sourced to SpaceX. It’s designed to ablate and glassify under plasma load, so the expansion you see is the material doing its job, not failing. The blistering is almost certainly a process variable, application atmosphere, not enough inert purge during spray. That’s fixable on their end. The one tile that popped is a mechanical pin issue, separate from coating chemistry. I do have a second-generation formula that stops the expansion and self-heals, but that one’s not public. Rapid reusability is closer than the noise suggests.”
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
I read through your posts, I hope you're doing alright in real life. It is not healthy to dedicate so much of one's energy to negativity.
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
That's pretty much a fundamental flaw if i ever saw one. There's no way to get a massive object steady enough to not go for the scrape catch. The Chinese might have better luck with the adjustable ropes, maybe.
It might land but it cannot possibly be rapidly reusable.
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
Seems like SpaceX needs to work on it's tower catching technology.
Zero reason in 2026 for this to be happening. It sort of ensures that re-usability in the way we see commercial aircraft never becomes a thing honestly.
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
Battle scars.
Marks left by the tower catch arm.
I wonder how to avoid this at future landings.
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
Ok, so I feel like Starship is very close to becoming reusable, which is already great.
However, being RAPIDLY reusable is completely different. Starship is great and wtv, but I struggle to see it ever having an hourly cadence.
Is it just me?
Replying to @space_jm_
Yep, unfortunately. Everywhere that a tile is slightly higher from the body than its neighbors it gets dramatically eroded away, in some cases yes it's just the gap filler, but in others the tile is damaged or destroyed. This is especially rough on the smaller tiles with their straight edge facing into the flow
Michael J. Relyea retweeted
The TPS under the catch pins might need another look over to improve its reusability.













































