Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani) profile picture

Economist at IUSS Pavia. Opinions are my own

Pavia, Lombardy
Joined July 2016
Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)Photo by Alessandro Caiani (@ale_caiani)
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
1/ Congrats @IsabellaMWeber, well deserved! Interesting timing too. I’ve spent the last few weeks going through what some mainstream economists have been saying about this book on here, and I believe it says a lot more about the discipline than about the book 🧵
ANTI-FASCIST ECONOMICS is one of the Financial Times’ Best Books of 2026 in economics. So humbled! I wrote this book because I believe economics has a role to play in safeguarding democracy. I couldn’t be happier about this recognition. It gives me hope! Thank you @martinwolf_!
3
31
4
140
15,338
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
Some people do not learn from mistakes: the European Commission's new fiscal rules of 2024 use 90 percent debt ratio as an additional rule for guiding debt reduction, while this number was debunked more than 10 years earlier. This is not evidence-based but error-based policy.
A 28-year-old UMass graduate student got a homework assignment to reproduce a famous economics paper, couldn't make the numbers match, and found a spreadsheet mistake in a study that politicians had used to argue for budget cuts. His name is Thomas Herndon. In 2010, two Harvard economists, Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, published a short paper called Growth in a Time of Debt. Its headline finding: once a country's public debt goes above 90% of its economy, growth falls off a cliff. In their numbers, average growth for that group was minus 0.1%. It came out right after the 2008 financial crisis, and it spread fast. In the US, the Paul Ryan budget cited it as its only evidence on what high debt does to growth. In Europe, an EU commissioner pointed to the research in a speech. In Britain, George Osborne cited the authors by name. Herndon was a PhD student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, taking a class called Econ 753: Applied Econometrics. The big assignment was to pick a well-known paper and replicate it. He picked this one. He couldn't get the same results. He asked the authors for their spreadsheet, and they sent it. When he spotted the problem, he called his girlfriend over to make sure he wasn't seeing things. He wasn't. > One formula stopped five rows short > That quietly left out five countries: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada and Denmark > Some available years of data for other countries weren't included > The way the averages were weighted let a single bad year in one country count as much as decades in another Herndon and his professors, Michael Ash and Robert Pollin, published the critique in April 2013. Fixing the problems, average growth for the high-debt countries came out to 2.2%, not minus 0.1%. Reinhart and Rogoff publicly admitted the spreadsheet error. They disputed the other criticisms and defended their broader view. Economists still argue about debt and growth today. But the formula was wrong, and for about three years nobody had publicly caught it. A student doing homework did. Most people assume famous research has been checked many times. Often the first person to really check it is someone with nothing to lose and an assignment due. Have you ever found a mistake in your boss's spreadsheet and kept quiet?
7
96
12
335
19,657
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
Today's @washingtonpost puts Flávio Bolsonaro on its front page, treating his flight to Miami after losing an election as a personal drama. An intimate portrait of a frightened politician. The attack on democratic institutions is secondary /1
23
70
12
350
27,506
Ovviamente nulla contro i colleghi (bravissimi) di Bologna/Bocconi che hanno vinto. Avere più risorse permette di assumere gente più brava che permette di avere più risorse e così via. Ma anche così, rimane una curiosità statistica notevole rispetto agli altri settori.
PRIN 2026, settore SH1. 7 progetti finanziati su 9 (!) hanno un PI di Bocconi o Bologna. I soliti 2 atenei monopolizzano quasi tutta la graduatoria. Meritocrazia? O è il caso di chiedersi quanto conti la cooptazione e il potere nelle reti accademiche? (Io non ho applicato in SH1)
2
7
4,061
PRIN 2026, settore SH1. 7 progetti finanziati su 9 (!) hanno un PI di Bocconi o Bologna. I soliti 2 atenei monopolizzano quasi tutta la graduatoria. Meritocrazia? O è il caso di chiedersi quanto conti la cooptazione e il potere nelle reti accademiche? (Io non ho applicato in SH1)
12
2
2
48
19,105
a comprare berardi con ogni probabilità
Curioso di sapere a cosa stia pensando vedendo questo scempio senza fine. #GenoaJuve
2
149
Sarebbe anche la peggior juve stabia di sempre
Domanda per chi c’era all’epoca Maifredi (se no è troppo facile). Peggior Juve di sempre? #GenoaJuve #jvtblive
1
113
La Juventus non esiste più.
1
116
Rafforzato il sospetto che, pur avendo avuto i suoi momenti bui e con l'enorme limite di non saper tirare, l'ingiustamente bistrattato #locatelli tenesse su la baracca praticamente da solo negli ultimi due anni. Il problema non era lui, sono quelli attorno. #juventus
1
4
247
ma santissimo iddio fate cagare come calciatori... almeno dovreste correre #juventus
97
"Non sono d'accordo con quello che dici ma darei la vita affinché tu possa marcire in carcere per quello che hai detto" cit. #TuttiLiberaliConIDissidentiDegliAltri
2
74
Forse perché fasciste lo erano, letteralmente? La Polizia di Stato italiana nasce in totale continuità istituzionale col fascismo. Nessuna epurazione: erano gli stessi agenti ed ex funzionari fascisti. Anche le leggi sulla pubblica sicurezza rimasero le stesse per decenni. Studia
Si trattava, in realtà, di un film tipico di propaganda del periodo. L'idea era rappresentare le forze di polizia come fasciste e intimamente malate. Lo stesso Volonté era un estremista di sinistra, solo in tarda età confluito nel PD.
3
103
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
Questa mattina i quotidiani sono pieni di articoli sull’11enne identificato a Milano. Articoli, ripresi ovviamente pure dai talk televisivi che ci stanno ampiamente sguazzando, pieni di dettagli sul ragazzino, in che quartiere vive, dove esce, che classe frequenta, conditi da voci di piazza sbattute nel pezzo come fossero la verità assoluta. Stanno banchettando sulla pelle di un cazzo di bambino, mostrificandolo per un pugno di click e di spettatori. Una totale violazione della Carta di Treviso, presa e fatta completamente a pezzi da colleghi che teoricamente dovrebbero conoscerla e sarebbero vincolati a rispettarla. In tutto ciò l’ordine dei giornalisti - volutamente minuscolo - sta zitto. Per l’ennesima volta. E mi domando davvero se sia arrivato il tempo di stracciare il tesserino perché, onestamente, se nemmeno di fronte a palesi violazioni qualcuno é in grado di parlare e sanzionare, i miei 100 euro annuali preferisco usarli per cose più utili.
105
365
16
1,547
36,514
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
Replying to @florianederer
@florianederer asks a fair question, but the counterfactual is unobservable, b/c nobody publishes rejection letters (unless Florian is asking authors to share those). What we can observe is impact. So here’s a different test. 🧵 1/
Heterodox economists claim that they're systematically shut out of top econ journals. So I have a genuine question: What are the best recent heterodox papers that deserved publication in a top journal but were rejected? @IsabellaMWeber @devikadutt @DanielaGabor
5
41
4
113
8,061
I contestatori ricordano un punto chiave: chi difende l'operato di Israele difende la sua deriva autoritaria, ultra-nazionalista e teocratica, la restrizione delle libertà civili e il controllo del governo sui media. Difende i fascisti israeliani. repubblica.it/esteri/2026/10…
1
49
Qualsiasi cosa tocchi Elkann diventa una merda #Juventus
1
112
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
First time in as long as I can remember that I’m turning a Juventus game off. No desire to watch this any longer. This team doesn’t care. This management doesn’t care. This coach doesn’t care. I care too much to watch this embarrassing group insult that shirt. We deserve better. Nothing has changed. Nothing will. Another season over before it’s even started. A Juventus of old was 13 points behind and still came back to roar to a title. This group can’t string together 3 passes, let alone 3 points. Goodnight.
90
155
17
1,284
33,922
marci, ad ogni livello #juventus
1
100
Alessandro Caiani retweeted
By a weird coincidence this just came out, as scheduled for the past weeks. I managed to squeeze a mention to Perry’s passing and a dedication at the end of the acknowledgment note in the cover page right before it was scheduled to come out. A tiny homage bis.org/publications/paper-1…
9
75
8
279
28,409