Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps) header
Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps) profile picture

Building @terrahelix_tech, Interests include geospatial, climate, history and the environment.

Pune, India
Joined July 2009
Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)Photo by Chinmay Shaligram (@chinmaymaps)
Reminder that nobody. Absolutely nobody likes to see advertisements and hoardings: On land, on sea, in air or digitally. It’s nuisance by design.
Four are planned along Mumbai’s coast, at Juhu, Worli, the Sea Link and Lotus Jetty. Eleven more are slated for creeks around Navi Mumbai, Thane, Vasai and Alibaug. Each can be 40 ft by 40 ft. Critics warn of light pollution and lost sea views indianexpress.com/article/ci…
1
5
152
Now that Pune is congested again, a PSA for people who have no idea what those round things in chowks are, and how you should turn at one.
2
10
133
Chinmay Shaligram retweeted
.@SoniaGandhi’s memoir, Belonging, has crossed 1,40,000 in sales, becoming the fastest selling political biography in India. This is within a week of release In comparison, Arundhati Roy’s Mother Mary Comes To Me, another bestselller, has sold 75,000 copies till now
66
313
62
2,068
242,709
Chinmay Shaligram retweeted
LEST WE FORGET: Jawaharlal Nehru spent a total of 3,259 days (approximately 9 years) behind bars across 9 separate prison terms during the Indian independence movement. And quite incredibly, wrote Discovery of India while in jail (IMHO, a classic book worthy of even greater literary recognition). On his birth anniversary , my respect to India’s first Prime Minister. 🙏🙏 #Nehru
537
472
63
3,200
112,454
Chinmay Shaligram retweeted
Horrific……….. Don’t trust any restaurant!
Crazy news! FDA has suspended the licenses of Vaishali and Rupali Hotels on FC road due to food safety and hygiene violations!
20
52
7
504
46,707
Had the privilege of meeting @Ram_Guha in person for the signing of his latest work, Arguments with Gandhi. Couldn’t have asked for a better start to the weekend!
2
70
I love looking at cities as the plane lands.
3
104
Received my copy of @SoniaGandhi’s memoir today. From whatever excerpts I’ve read so far this should be a brilliant read!
1
50
Chinmay Shaligram retweeted
Sorry, @CPCB_OFFICIAL. In your haste to defend the indefensible, you seem to have overlooked that your comments on the National Air Quality Index (NAQI) run contrary to the very documents available on your own website! If anything, this Press Note has only reinforced public suspicion that your systems conceal far more than they reveal. 1️⃣ Your own AQI Calculator does not impose any cap of 500. An AQI Calculator in the form of an Excel sheet is available on your website (cpcb.nic.in/upload/national-…). It allows one to enter the concentration values of PM₂.₅, PM₁₀, SO₂, CO, NH₃, NO₂, O₃ and Pb and obtain the AQI in accordance with the NAQI methodology followed by CPCB. Significantly, the Calculator does not impose any upper cap on the resulting AQI. For instance, please see the accompanying screenshot showing the calculation for MBS Nagar Chaukhandi. 2️⃣ Has either @aiims_newdelhi or the other two institutions, @SRIHER_Official and @MAMC_NewDelhi, cited in your Press Note, ever stated in writing that the adverse health impact remains unchanged once the AQI crosses 500? If so, please place such rather bizarre medical advice in the public domain. I have spoken to several senior pulmonologists, including those who have served at AIIMS, New Delhi, on this subject. They corroborate what is a commonsensical inference: the health risks arising from inhalation of PM₂.₅ and other particulate matter, as well as exposure to harmful gases, are related to the concentrations inhaled and the duration of exposure. The deposition of pollutants in the respiratory system (particularly infiltration of PM₂.₅ in the bloodstream) and the resulting pulmonary and cardiovascular damage cannot simply be assumed to plateau once an arbitrary AQI threshold is crossed. Even exposure to exceptionally high concentrations for a few hours, particularly when people venture outdoors during Diwali celebrations, can have serious health ramifications, including in the medium and long term. The sweeping, unsubstantiated assertion in paragraph 4 that adverse health effects arise only from long-term exposure ought, therefore, to have been avoided. The prescribed 24-hour and 8-hour averaging periods may serve a purpose in standardised AQI computation, but they cannot be a substitute for reporting hourly pollution levels, particularly during extreme pollution episodes. The need for hourly reporting is best illustrated by the familiar anecdote of a mathematics student who drowned while crossing a river because he assumed it was safe, having calculated that its average depth was less than his height! 3️⃣ Your own Press Note, in paragraph 5, acknowledges that the cap of 500 was borrowed from the US EPA. But did anyone bother to consider whether the US experience and pollution levels are remotely comparable with ours? An AQI of 500 in the United States is virtually unimaginable. This is particularly striking when the US AQI scale itself permits much higher numerical readings at the upper end. Blindly importing a ceiling without examining its relevance to Indian conditions makes little scientific or administrative sense. 4️⃣ Please do not summarily dismiss the reliability of Community AQI Monitoring Stations. Their accuracy may be somewhat lower in the case of certain pieces, and they may not monitor gaseous pollutants. However, their sheer numbers and geographical spread provide an invaluable additional source of information. @AQI_India alone has approximately 600 community monitors in Delhi and nearly 4,000 across the country, compared with just 59 CPCB monitors in Delhi. This extensive network offers a much wider picture of localised pollution levels and deserves to be taken seriously, with due regard to the limitations of a few individual instruments. Besides, the reference in paragraph 6 to a calibration limit of 1,000 is outrightly ludicrous in the face of the unprecedented pollution levels being recorded. If pollutant concentrations have risen beyond the instruments' calibrated range, the obvious response is to recalibrate the analysers or replace the machines with ones capable of measuring the actual levels. It cannot be an excuse for allowing the monitoring system to become incapable of reporting the very pollution it is supposed to measure! For ready reference, I am attaching comparison between NAAQS and @WHO norms on safe limits. 5️⃣ Lastly, no genuine scientist or engineer should countenance withholding pollution data from the public by switching off monitoring stations precisely when pollution peaks. The apparent shutdown of some monitoring stations during peak pollution periods, as highlighted here (teapawt.org/manoj_kumar_nr/status/…), calls for a transparent explanation. If the data are available, these must be disclosed; if the monitors are not functioning, the reasons and duration of their downtime must be made public. Scientific integrity demands that we measure, report and confront the problem as it actually exists, not devise convenient methodologies or justifications that make the numbers look less alarming. Public health cannot be protected by underplaying & hiding the data! @moefcc @byadavbjp @PMOIndia @HMOIndia @sardesairajdeep @Sonal_MK @svaradarajan @manoj_kumar_nr
The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) stated that the maximum AQI cap of 500 is a deliberate design feature aligned with global standards, as numbers beyond 500 do not alter the 'Severe' health advisory category. Official data relies on a scientifically validated 24-hour rolling average to measure sustained human exposure, while private apps often track instant hourly spikes using uncalibrated, low-cost sensors. Because private apps track instant readings, they spike faster during peak pollution but drop much lower than the official NAQI once air quality starts clearing up. (Source: CPCB)
14
163
14
347
20,471
We need a drastic change in how we govern, and that change needs to happen now.
Maharashtra faces the worst drought it has in over 50 years. At least 10 farmers have taken their lives in a week. On Oct 31, the Maha govt spent 20 crore for the inauguration of the Simhastha Kumbh Mela. It celebrated a Guinness Record that evening for most number of “dia rotations”. That same evening, farmer Tikaram Chavan took his own life in Yavatmal. A crushing drought, 19 tweets and 20 crore: I report for @thewire_in. thewire.in/politics/in-mahar…
7
207
The Central Pollution Control Board (CPCB) stated that the maximum AQI cap of 500 is a deliberate design feature aligned with global standards, as numbers beyond 500 do not alter the 'Severe' health advisory category. Official data relies on a scientifically validated 24-hour rolling average to measure sustained human exposure, while private apps often track instant hourly spikes using uncalibrated, low-cost sensors. Because private apps track instant readings, they spike faster during peak pollution but drop much lower than the official NAQI once air quality starts clearing up. (Source: CPCB)
4
127
This rare Greater Adjutant Stork (Hargila) died in Guwahati tonight, after being frightened by the deafening explosions of Diwali firecrackers. While we are celebrating Diwali with fireworks and crackers, this rare Greater Adjutant Stork (Hargila) flew around in panic, collided with an electric wire and died. Does this mean nothing to us? And if I raise this concern, will I be labelled anti-Hindu? Is celebrating a festival more important than protecting our precious wildlife? @StorkSister @Mrinal_MLA #Hargila #GreaterAdjutantStork #SaveWildlife #Assam #Guwahati #NortheastIndia #WildlifeConservation #India #EcoFriendlyDiwali #ProtectBiodiversity
92
540
62
1,853
124,487
Quite an interesting thread and rings true.
Cracker led pollution spike is a very good metaphor for India’s larger economic story 1/n
1
136
This is what I meant when I said that people are throwing rockets and other aerial firecrackers at each other like they're playing war with each other and the rockets are their missiles. Now tell me all those people who are irrationally pro firecrackers, don't you think we at least need some amount of regulation or control on this nonsense so people don't use fireworks like weapons?
𝐑𝐨𝐜𝐤𝐞𝐭𝐬 𝐃𝐞𝐥𝐢𝐛𝐞𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐞𝐥𝐲 𝐀𝐢𝐦𝐞𝐝 𝐚𝐭 𝐏𝐢𝐫𝐚𝐦𝐚𝐥 𝐌𝐚𝐡𝐚𝐥𝐚𝐱𝐦𝐢 𝐓𝐨𝐰𝐞𝐫, 𝐅𝐢𝐫𝐞 𝐁𝐫𝐞𝐚𝐤𝐬 𝐎𝐮𝐭 𝐨𝐧 𝐏-𝟗 | Piramal Realty has filed a police complaint alleging that residents of the neighbouring Aga Khan Building deliberately directed lighted rockets and aerial firecrackers towards the South Tower of Piramal Mahalaxmi (Saat Rasta, Agripada/Mahalaxmi) on the night of 8 November 2026. The incident set fire to furniture in the senior citizens’ amenities area on Level P-9. The building’s Emergency Response Team (ERT) quickly controlled the blaze; no injuries were reported. The company has sought intensified police patrolling in the area, citing a BMC order banning sky-bound rockets and firecrackers across Mumbai from 8–25 November
3
2
18
2,299
Rs 85,000. For a sticker that measures your face and calls it your brain. I am a Cardiothoracic Surgeon. Every day I hold a human heart in my hands and I fight to keep blood flowing to the brain. So when I see a device that claims to measure BrainFlow from your temple, I cannot stay silent. Because what Temple is measuring is not your brain. It is your scalp. And that difference is not small. That difference is everything. Let me make it simple for you. Put your finger on your temple. Feel that pulse. That is your superficial temporal artery. That artery is a branch of the EXTERNAL carotid artery. It sits OUTSIDE your skull. Its job is to supply blood to your scalp, your temple, your face, your ear. Your brain does NOT run on this artery. Your brain runs on the INTERNAL carotid arteries and the vertebral arteries. They go deep inside. They are protected by bone, by muscle, by dura. So when someone tells you a sticker on your temple is measuring your BrainFlow, I have to ask - how? Temple uses PPG. Photoplethysmography. The same light-based technology in your smartwatch. It shines light into the skin and sees how much blood is moving under it. At the wrist, it measures the wrist. At the temple, it measures the temple. It cannot magically see through skin, scalp, temporalis muscle, skull bone, meninges, and then tell you what is happening inside your cortex. Light does not work like that. If it did, we would not need MRI, CT angiography, transcranial Doppler, or invasive monitoring in cardiac and neurosurgery. In the OT, when I want to know cerebral perfusion, I do not put a sticker on the temple. I rely on validated monitors, on blood pressure, on cardiac output, on cerebral oximetry that has been tested in thousands of patients. Because brain blood flow is not the same as scalp blood flow. When you are embarrassed, your face flushes. Your temporal artery dilates. Does that mean your brain just got smarter? When you drink coffee, when you exercise, when you get angry, when you stand up from a chair - your scalp flow changes. Your brain flow, thankfully, stays remarkably stable because of autoregulation. That is how we survive. So if scalp flow and brain flow move together during exercise, that does not prove you are measuring the brain. That just proves both went up because your heart is pumping harder. This is what we call correlation without causation. And with only 23 healthy volunteers in an unpublished, company-funded preprint, that is not validation. That is a pilot study. In medicine, we do not sell a pilot study for Rs 85,000 ($904 USD). And then there is this new word - Entropy. A score from 1 to 250 to tell you the cost of being alive. I can tell you, there is no validated medical biomarker called Entropy that you can measure from your temple and use to predict ageing, longevity, or brain health. Metabolic carts, VO2 max testing, lab-based calorimetry - these took decades of validation. You cannot replace them with a proprietary algorithm and call it a discovery. Now, Mr. Goyal says - Temple is not a medical device, it is a wellness device. Then why call it BrainFlow? Why talk about brain ageing? Why talk about gravity ageing hypothesis? Why talk about cerebral blood flow? You cannot market like a medical breakthrough and then hide behind a wellness disclaimer when doctors ask for proof. And the argument - If it does not work, people will return it in 14 days, so it cannot be a scam. Sir, with respect, a patient cannot know in 14 days if his brain blood flow measurement is accurate. He has no gold standard at home to compare it with. He will see a number go up and down, he will feel reassured, he will think he is tracking his brain. That is exactly the danger. A 14-day return policy is not peer review. Spending 30 million dollars is not peer review. Having a good reputation in food delivery is not peer review. In medicine,we have a simple rule. First, do no harm. Second, prove it before you sell.
53
329
32
1,226
61,526
Chinmay Shaligram retweeted
Between 3pm on Sunday and 6am on Monday, the #Pune Municipal Corporation’s fire brigade attended 94 fire-related calls from various parts of the city. No casualties or injuries were reported in any of the incidents. This video is from Hadapsar, where a garbage pile caught fire.
1
7
1
20
1,261
Same, Ricky Gervais. Same.
If you’re letting off fireworks at the moment, I hope you die. Cunts.
2
215
Chinmay Shaligram retweeted
Khilarewadi, #Pune: 828 AQI (Hazardous) Perugate: 1248 #AQI Chattushringi: 635 AQI PM2.5: 490–701 µg/m³ Wind: just 4 km/hr Population ↑2x Firecrackers ↑10x Buildings ↑10x Wind ↓0.1x Dispersion ↓0.01x Pollution has nowhere to go. 🌫️ @Dev_Fadnavis @navalMH @mpcb_official @CPPuneCity @DGPMaharashtra
9
23
3
32
4,815