Pinned Tweet
All originators of rules of thumb give their name to their observaotins (Godwin, Moore), so I'm having this one.
Quilty's Law
=========
"As an online discussion grows longer, the probability that an antisemitic trope sharer will claim to be of Jewish descent approaches 1."
Interestingly both IHRA and the Jerusalem Declaration agree that non-Jews can be victims of antisemitism. It seems a little obtuse to think overwise
Except Ben Tait isn't Jewish, but many of his targets (among them 88yo Holocaust survivor Stephen Kapos) are.
It's almost as if the people constantly hallucinating Jews as being behind everything are the pro-Israel faction, not everyone else.
1
124
RT @LordIanAustin: What utter rubbish.
No one objects to someone simply “showing solidarity” with Palestinians.
I spent decades campaigning…
This quoted post is unavailable.
Clare Quilty retweeted
Ben Tait is one of the bravest men in Britain. In a country where the overwhelming majority of extremism researchers are doing nothing of any value, he has been doing the work of a whole team. Work, I might add, that should have been funded by the government and given official protection.
Instead, the government funded the crackpot conspiracy theorists who have just put his safety at risk.
✍️ Daniel Allington
Article | spectator.com/article/byline…
Clare Quilty retweeted
I am touched to see so much support for my work exposing the rampant bigotry that thrives in the UK. Thank you.
I do find it amusing that some of the most unpleasant people in the country are now squabbling over who made the simply amazing discovery that people who stand up against anti-Jewish racists talk to and help each other.
I will continue to break real stories.
The asymmetries are real and the framing fits core DARVO elements.
1. Byline's own ownership (Press Gazette, Sept 2025) shows >99% of £728k share cash and 63% of equity via anonymous Jersey trusts/opaque vehicles, yet it brands unpaid private X users as a "shadowy influence operation."
2. Targets are high-visibility figures with platforms, wealth and institutional roles (Lineker; Harriman, son of Nigerian billionaire industrialist). Mapped accounts are mostly private citizens.
3. The piece maps amplification of documented public statements without adjudicating their antisemitic character, treating the response itself as the offence.
This produces classic role-reversal: institutional opacity and power project "shadowiness" onto lower-resource critics while elevating the criticised as primary victims. Textbook institutional DARVO dynamics from a media-criticism lens.
Clare Quilty retweeted
The antizonist movement contains a clear and widening internal split. One faction insists its target is solely the political project of Zionism and the Israeli state, while the other increasingly treats Judaism itself as the deeper problem. Mainstream pro-Palestinian advocacy works hard to maintain the first framing, largely by elevating a small number of Jewish antizionists as proof that the movement is not anti-Jewish. That effort is under growing strain.
The first camp emphasizes Jewish participants: organizations such as Jewish Voice for Peace and IfNotNow, along with religious antizionists like Neturei Karta and progressive Jews. Their presence is presented as evidence that opposition to Israel is a political or humanitarian position rather than hostility to Jews or Judaism. These groups remain a minority within American Jewish life. Surveys over the past decade have consistently shown that most American Jews retain significant affinity to Israel even when they criticize specific governments or policies. These organizations, while loud, do not represent the broader community
The second camp rejects that distinction with claims that Judaism is “literally more racist and supremacist than Nazism,” that it has received a historical “pass,” and that practices such as matrilineal descent demonstrate inherent xenophobia and exceptionalism toward non-Jews. Similar arguments appear in online spaces that treat Jewish endogamy and concepts of peoplehood as forms of racial isolation rather than religious continuity. They argue that focusing only on Zionism is a distraction; the core issue is Judaism’s historic attitudes toward outsiders.
Historical precedents show that hostility to Zionism has repeatedly coexisted with or served as a vehicle for hostility to Jews as such. In Mein Kampf, Hitler dismissed Zionism as a deception. He wrote that while Zionists claimed to seek a state in Palestine, “the Jews again slyly dupe the dumb Goyim. It doesn’t even enter their heads to build up a Jewish state in Palestine for the purpose of living there; all they want is a central organization for their international world swindle, endowed with its own sovereign rights and removed from the intervention of other states: a haven for convicted scoundrels and a university for budding crooks.” The Nazi regime never supported a sovereign Jewish state and framed Zionism as part of a global Jewish conspiracy while seeking Arab alliances against it.
In the Soviet Union, the Yevsektsiya (Jewish sections of the Communist party) provides another case. They were charged with dismantling traditional Jewish life: closing synagogues and yeshivas, suppressing Hebrew and Zionism, and pushing assimilation into a Soviet identity. Their activities included raids on Jewish groups and campaigns against religious observance. Many of the section’s leaders were later purged. These are undeniable parallels between Soviet antisemitism and the use of Jewish antizionists today to legitimize broader campaigns against Jewish communal institutions or identity.
Media coverage, particularly in outlets such as The New York Times, has for decades highlighted American Jewish distancing from Israel while generally avoiding explicit attacks on Judaism. Pieces appearing periodically since the 1960s and 1970s (and accelerating in recent years) have documented generational differences, with younger Jews showing lower rates of emotional attachment and greater criticism of Israeli policies. This approach tokenizes a minority viewpoint, understates the continuity of Jewish attachment for most of the community, and creates a narrative in which opposition to Israel can be presented as an internal Jewish debate rather than an external pressure that oftentimes spills into antisemitism.
In historical and practical view, antizionism from either side functions as a vector of anti-Jewish violence we see today.
Clare Quilty retweeted
Tonight in Manchester, the “free Palestine” hate mob decided to descend on the Manchester Maccabi Jewish community centre and sports club
Make no mistake here, this is another direct antisemitic attack on the Manchester Jewish community, after Heaton Park Synagogue and at least 2 foiled terrorist attacks on the Manchester Jewish community enough is enough.
Clare Quilty retweeted
Antisemites ALWAYS portray themselves as ‘victims’ of Jews. It’s what they do. Today is no different.
Clare Quilty retweeted
Islamist bully Mothin Ali being slapped down.
Beautiful.
Replying to @cllr_dan_cohen
@cllr_dan_cohen "Zionism is a simple belief that the Jewish people have a right to self-determination in our ancestral homeland. According to the Green Party, I am a racist. Greens do not get to use a useful few to rewrite my identity. Or condenm us for their version of my faith"
Clare Quilty retweeted
Replying to @cllr_dan_cohen
@cllr_dan_cohen "Zionism is a simple belief that the Jewish people have a right to self-determination in our ancestral homeland. According to the Green Party, I am a racist. Greens do not get to use a useful few to rewrite my identity. Or condenm us for their version of my faith"
Clare Quilty retweeted
Today Leeds City Council passed a motion confirming that Zionism is NOT Racism.
Support for the Jewish community came from Independents and across the Chamber.
Motion passed 81 yes, 11 no, 2 abstentions.
There's 11 Green councillors
#Leeds
@LeedsCC_News
More to follow
Clare Quilty retweeted
I just got a note from a Jewish mother in Leeds who took her kids to the Vue cinema at The Light for a birthday on Remembrance Sunday.
The staff member checking tickets was wearing a Palestinian badge, and she told him she didn't think staff should wear political badges that can make customers feel uncomfortable.
She says two managers were called, her family was refused entry, and one manager told her she wouldn't get a refund if she kept complaining.
@vuecinemas, can you confirm your version? Are your staff allowed to wear political badges on shift, and what happens to a customer who comes in with her children and says a badge makes her feel intimidated?
Clare Quilty retweeted
No you are not. You are not even an ‘anti Zionist’. You are simply a fraud.
Only a few years ago when you were a Lib Dem you solemnly promised voters that a vote for you was “a support for Israel”.
You were a 34-year old man, not a child. You left the Lib Dems a year later purely and simply because they didn’t select you for a parliamentary seat.
If they had, you’d still be promising that a vote for you is a vote for Israel. You are a despicable, malignant fraud who would toss your own mum under a bus for a few extra moments of political relevance.
It's always the ones you least suspect
Russell Brand found guilty of one count of rape and three counts of sexual assault bbc.in/4ip1NNA
1
5
248
Clare Quilty retweeted
This apology from disability charity Scope, for cancelling my choir’s London Marathon performance because of my gender-critical views, is required to stay on its website for seven days.
Today is Day 6.
Women don’t always get the apologies they deserve. So I’d be grateful if you could help make sure this one is seen by sharing it over the next 24 hours (link below). 🙏
Thanks again to @SpeechUnion for supporting my legal case and helping secure this apology.
Clare Quilty retweeted
Israel is having its election today and every adult citizen - regardless of background or ethnicity - is able to vote.
In fact, out of 380 million Arab citizens in two dozen countries in the Middle East, the only ones who really get to choose their government in free and fair elections are the 2.1 million who live in the equal, diverse and multicultural democracy that is Israel.
The only Arab citizens who live in a democracy are the Israeli Arab citizens of the free and open country of Israel, the only liberal democracy in the whole of the Middle East.
Clare Quilty retweeted
The revealing admission in @mehdirhasan’s post - which he completely misses, accidentally or not - is that rising anti-Israel hatred fuels rising attacks on Jewish school kids, because they are Jewish.
Clare Quilty retweeted
Usha Sood (@UshaSood1497115), a human rights barrister and Head of Chambers at Trent Chambers in Nottingham, describes Jews as "inhuman, grasping and genocidal". Is she a fit and proper person to be practicing at the Bar? @barstandards


































