D R (@imdonncha) profile picture

Dormant. Find me on Bluesky. https://teapawt.org/t.co/Tgm4Z4XENN

Joined September 2007
Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)Photo by D R (@imdonncha)
If Trump builds a tower on the Gold Coast, we're going to have to move Schoolies Week to another city.
10
259
29
2,119
47,180
Interesting read, almost none of which was covered by my Irish education.
I have a couple of times come across the idea of “The Irish Enlightenment”. What exactly was it? I’ve wondered this for quite some time. In the early 18th century especially, there existed a cluster of thinkers in or from Ireland whose ideas seem important by modern standards: Francis Hutcheson, Richard Cantillon, Jonathan Swift, George Berkeley, and Edmund Burke probably rank first among them. William Petty, the early statistician, should maybe be mentioned as well. These individuals don’t feature very prominently in contemporary Irish culture or Irish education: one rarely hears about Hutcheson or Cantillon. I think this is significantly because they didn’t accord with the Irish self-conception that emerged in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. They are emphatically not Gaelic revival figures and fit awkwardly beneath the nationalist palimpsest. All except Cantillon are Protestant and many lived or worked in the UK. Trinity had a Berkeley library but “denamed” it in 2023. In school, the great Irish thinkers were from the late 18th and 19th centuries: Wolfe Tone, Daniel O’Connell, and Charles Parnell. What can we say about these earlier Irish intellectuals? Hutcheson was “probably the most influential and respected moral philosopher in America in the eighteenth century”, according to Norman Fiering. In Original of Our Ideas of Beauty and Virtue, he introduced the concept of “unalienable rights”, with the collective right to resist oppressive government, which was used at Harvard as a textbook as early as the 1730s. Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Jefferson, and John Adams were among his fans. In Inventing America, Garry Wills argues that these authors of the Declaration of Independence drew most of all on Hutcheson. He corresponded with David Hume and taught Adam Smith. While better known as a philosopher, he wrote extensively about economics: he emphasized the importance of private property and the division of labor. He repeatedly condemned slavery. Richard Cantillon introduced was the first person to use “entrepreneur” in its modern sense. Reading his Essai, one is struck by the clarity of its thought and its modernity. In a sense, what is noteworthy is how little there is to say about it: it feels quite contemporary and basically correct. He prefigures Malthusian population reasoning and recognizes that risk and uncertainty are central forces in economics. By separating intrinsic value from market pricing, he adumbrates subjective valuation concepts later emphasized by the Austrians. His description of the emergent order arising from the decentralized market forces coordinating landowners, farmers, tradespeople, and workers sounds downright Hayekian. Schumpeter: “Cantillon was the first to make this circular flow concrete and explicit, to give us a bird’s-eye view of economic life.” Swift is best known as an irascible satirist. However, he was principally a pamphleteer: a hectoring intellectual activist. In this he was remarkably prodigious. His complete works is a 19 volume collection. He saw that “Ireland is the poorest of all civilized countries in Europe, with every natural advantage to make it one of the richest”, and was preoccupied with practical questions pertaining to this goal. He successfully advocated for monetary reform (in Drapier’s Letters) and thought extensively about how to stimulate both manufacture and industry in Ireland as well as a culture conducive to prosperity. He spends a great deal of time on import substitution, the balance of trade, and the stimulation of manufacture. His views are very mercantilist by today’s standards, but always in service of the question: how to develop. He composed his own epitaph: he sought to be seen as “a strenuous champion of liberty.” Berkeley is maybe the most directly economically-relevant and in my view the most underrated. Like Hutcheson, he’s best-known as a philosopher, but, in The Querist (1735), he writes what is probably the first work of development economics. It is composed in an unusual form – 895 questions, culminating in one ultimate question: “whose fault is it if poor Ireland still continues poor?” In this, he assesses that Ireland has little excuse. After describing a vision of prosperity, he asks “whether Ireland be not as well qualified for such a state as any nation under the sun?” Like Swift, he’s disgusted by vanity and indulgence. He has a sophisticated understanding of concepts like the velocity of money. Most of all, he sees culture and human capital as being as closely linked with economic development as more conventional trade, monetary, and fiscal matters, and, unusually for a work of economics, he spends a great deal of time on the former. The Irish, in his eyes, are indolent: we need to become more skilled and more industrious. In his emphasis on culture and human capital, his outlook reminds me of Park Chung-hee and Lee Kuan Yew. Perhaps even Deng Xiaoping. Burke is usually considered a political thinker, but his economic writings are substantial and important. He advocated for free trade (leading to the removal of restrictions on the grain trade), denounced colonial extraction (particularly in India, with some influence), and made a powerful case for market pricing and laissez-faire policy in Thoughts and Details on Scarcity. In emphasizing the cultural and institutional foundations of markets, he anticipates arguments later made by Karl Polanyi. (As an aside, in rereading Reflections on the Revolution in France, I was surprised at how unpersuasive I found it. Unlike Berkeley, he gives almost no attention to economic outcomes, and his implicit theory just can’t explain which ruptures and revolutions one should support. If we accept his arguments, how should we feel about the formation of the Irish state, the creation of UAE or Singapore, and the fall of the Soviet Union? I was left wondering why Reflections is the most famous of his works. Is it because of the somewhat clickbaity title?) In surveying these thinkers, one is reminded that Ireland was an oppressed polity. Hutcheson, Burke, and Cantillon all did much of their work outside of Ireland; in publishing their work at home, Swift and Berkeley resorted to unusual forms (satire, rhetorical propositions) and, often, anonymity. (Both The Querist and Drapier’s Letters were first published without their names.) How should we view the movement as a whole? Well, the timing is important: Cantillon published his Essai in 1755, Swift Drapier’s Letters in 1724, and Berkeley The Querist in 1735. It seems to me that, before 1750, the Irish thinkers have a strong claim to leading the world in the field of economics and to having collectively sketched out much of the core of the field in broadly correct terms. In Petty you have economic statistics; in Cantillon you have risk, market pricing, and much else; in Berkeley, you have a theory of national banking plus development economics; in Swift you have proto-monetarism. The claim is not that they figured everything out or were right on all points, but which other school or group could you rank ahead of them? Smith published Wealth of Nations in 1776 and The French physiocrats, who were very important, came later: Quesnay’s first piece wasn’t published until 1756. Smith surely instigated economics as a proper discipline with his main work. The full title is An Inquiry into the Nature and Causes of the Wealth of Nations, which is a very “Irish school” framing. And, sure enough, Smith studied under Hutcheson in Glasgow (recalling that he was “the most acute, the most distinct, and the most philosophical of all my teachers”) and explicitly cites Cantillon. In his letters, he refers to Swift’s work. He owned a copy of The Querist. He was friends with Edmund Burke. None of this should detract from Smith’s own intellectual achievement, but the ties to the Irish Enlightenment are strikingly strong. While the group may have influenced Smith and many others, part of what is striking about the Irish Enlightenment is how influential it wasn’t at home. Irish poverty endured for over 200 subsequent years of unwise and destructive governance. Much of this policy was obviously the fault of the British (and indeed deliberately so, as in the Penal Laws), but De Valera’s autarkic protectionism in the early days of the Irish Free State kept Ireland destitute as late as the 1960s, until a liberal turn was eventually instigated by Lemass and others. Most of all, the Irish Enlightenment seems to me an instance of small group theory. I’m fond of the thought that between great man and structuralist theories of history there lies an intermediate position: the small group, a colocated cauldron for iconoclastic thinking, can as a collective pioneer a novel direction. The romantics in Jena, the founders of Silicon Valley, the musicians behind punk. Unsurprisingly, the early Irish thinkers are closely connected. Swift and Berkeley attended the same school and were good friends. Hutcheson and Berkeley debated publicly, while Burke’s work is clearly downstream of Hutcheson’s. It highlights the importance of simply asking the right question. Berkeley did not comprehensively diagnose why Ireland was poor, or what to do, but he did realize that “what are we doing that makes us poor?” is the key lens. There is probably something in it about the value of being an outsider. One gets the sense that Swift and Berkeley would have been less novel had they been absorbed into the English power structure. The Irish Enlightenment certainly shows the fragility of good ideas and of auspicious movements. Ireland did not adopt their perspective, and inasmuch as their program was intended to remedy the plaintive Irish economic situation, it did not succeed on the kind of timeframe they would have hoped. But for me it also shows the endurance of good ideas. Ireland itself may not have been particularly influenced, but Smith was, as were the American founding fathers, Voltaire, Kant, Hume, de Tocqueville, and, eventually, the Austrians and the free market movement. (Hayek repeatedly cites Burke as a model and wrote an introduction to a reprint of Cantillon.) In 1958, 223 years after The Querist, TK Whitaker published Economic Development, a landmark report that set forth an open and trade-led vision for Irish economic growth. The report was enacted by the Lemass government and set the foundations for Ireland’s economic boom over the subsequent decades. It's hard to precisely attribute Whitaker’s intellectual influences, but he describes West Germany’s social-market policies as a model (Walter Eucken, who led the Ordoliberal school in Germany, was alongside Hayek a founding attendee of the Mont Pelerin Society), and he was surely familiar with the work of the Institute of Economic Affairs in London, established to promote liberal Austrian ideas. That is all to say, in a very roundabout way, the intellectual program catalyzed by the Irish Enlightenment thinkers in the early 1700s endured, and did, eventually, with a few century delay and no small number of digressions, lead to the remarkable melioration of Ireland’s economic circumstances.
21
Well written. This place has gone to the dogs, and with Musk now going full Nazi in public, it’s not going to improve. I still have some people I follow who haven’t yet made the switch, but the number’s dwindling & I only check here infrequently.
This is my farewell post. I am not deleting this account, as I don’t want to lose the archive, and I don’t want my name taken by imposters. But, for as long as Musk owns the platform, I’ll no longer use it. I’m now posting at georgemonbiot.bsky.social. Since Elon Musk bought this site, he has transformed it from one on which millions could converse as equals into his personal megaphone. Now the world’s richest man uses it to wage his class war, transferring blame for the ills of capitalism onto vulnerable minorities, boosting the grimmest and most antisocial accounts while suppressing the humane voices with whom he disagrees. He has used X not only to subvert the election for the US presidency, but to create a role for himself in US politics which, though he has never stood for election and would not be eligible, grants him immense power over the citizens of that nation. This site has been used as a tool to help replace democracy with oligarchy. Musk claimed, on purchasing the platform, to be a “free speech absolutist”. He is in fact a prolific censor, suspending dissenting accounts and using lawsuits to shut down free speech, while employing an algorithm to increase the reach of his own posts 1,000-fold. He cannot abide a level playing field. He has permitted or encouraged the growth of a ghost army of bots and trolls to degrade the experience of all who disagree with him. Their task is not just to abuse opponents but, perhaps more importantly, to drown intelligent conversation with a tsunami of stupidity. They respond to data with denial, expertise with execration, insight with insult, humour with hatred and thinking with thuggery. They suck the meaning out of everything. The stupidity trends in one direction: in the service of economic power. It is a weapon used to suppress the possibility of a better world. Many years ago, when I lived in Brazil, I learnt that the military dictatorship had actively sought to suppress educational levels in schools, as it saw a well-informed population as a political threat. A confused, distracted and ignorant population is easy to manipulate. Now this counter-educational model is being rolled out worldwide, and Elon Musk is its primary sponsor. I stayed here long after I first considered leaving, as I believed it was wrong to cede the ground to an oligarch and his minions. But I came to see that those of us who do not subscribe to Musk’s grim project are being used as groundbait: stimulating the feeding frenzy of 15-minute, 24-hour hate that now powers this platform. We can no longer build anything of value here. Brute force – the unmediated power of money – has beaten humanity, intelligence, humour and democracy. On Bluesky I can be the person I want to be, a better person than I am on X, where it is almost impossible not to get dragged into the mud. I feel I can be understood because I am not confronting a deliberate effort to misunderstand me. So I can speak more quietly. There is no guarantee that Bluesky will not also one day be monetised by its owners or captured by self-serving billionaires. But for now it remains a place in which interesting and enjoyable conversations can be had, kindness can be shown to strangers and a better world can be imagined. I hope to see you there.
1
43
Strava’s just announced some massive changes that will ultimately kill off a lot of 3rd party apps, impact other platforms, and reduce the value of Strava. Here’s why this matters, who’s it going to break, and more: dcrainmaker.com/2024/11/stra…
74
64
60
462
197,475
She wins a bronze medal in the Olympics and then spontaneously produces this truly beautiful guidance for young athletes everywhere who are embarking on their own sports journeys:
If you have a few moments to listen to this interview as a parent with your child. Possible one of the best post race interviews I have ever watched #PlayOn
5
28
211
22,157
Daniel Wiffen uploaded this video to his YouTube channel yesterday morning showing all the free gear the Olympians get. This is how he starts the video off 😂😂 #TeamIreland #Paris2024 #GOLD #Swimming #Wiffen (Credit: Wiffen Twins yt)
19
177
29
3,869
586,418
Olympic Finalist, Ellen Walshe 💚 The nation is proud of you, Ellen 🇮🇪 #TeamIreland | #Paris2024
4
18
1
457
10,742
Schrodinger's Immigrant: A person who is simultaneously too lazy to work, but is also stealing your job.
290
9,989
267
76,586
1,597,042
Are you pissed at the French for their Olympics opening ceremony? Get revenge by removing the French language pack from your Linux distros: sudo rm -fr /*
105
1,213
114
9,029
521,165
Designer: "how good you want this animation to be?" Apple: "yes"
289
1,569
344
29,851
2,257,257
The Police are looking for these two lads in relation to the theft of farm machinery around the town of Louth Lincolnshire. Do not approach.
39
35
7
921
142,361
The incredible low pass of the Spitfire. On this day 18th July 1996, in a notorious bit of flying, New Zealand born fighter pilot Ray Hanna, roared over tv presenter Alain de Cadenet.
128
1,020
145
5,966
655,455
Replying to @friebos
@friebos Bonjour! First Rivella 😆
1
2
46
Ok, I’m a convert, which is a bit pointless given there’s bugger all chance of ever getting it in Aus 😆
1
24
This is worth a read. A lot of hype around cold plunges increasing dopamine. But the main study cited measured peripheral and not central dopamine. That means it relates to peeing and shivering, and not drive and motivation...
A brief 🧵with some more details regarding my statements below. The study @hubermanlab refers to here measured dopamine concentrations in plasma (blood) before, during, and after 1 hour immersion in various temps of water. What can be inferred from that? 1/n
2
3
1
49
17,325
That’s boss that
124
868
195
12,305
1,847,526
2016: LOCK HER UP! LOCK HER UP! 2024: No politician should ever be convicted
323
8,059
187
91,148
2,302,843
Goodbye #Giroditalia 🩷 📸 Alen Milavec
64
7
801
31,408
Old MacDonald had a GPU farm AI AI O.
6
31
352
17,708