Pinned Tweet
Looking at my account and my TL?? Don't forget to follow me....
Warning: I can be weird sometimes....
3
27
16,703
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
Hard Disagree bhaiya
On Su 30 MKI we can integrate any weapon we wish, we integrated Brahmos on it on our own, we developed and integrated Rudram, Astra on it and already plan to integrate SAAW TARA LRGB etc
Moreover we can upgrade Su 30 MKI on our own as well, the AAAU of 2400 TRM GaN radar has already been delivered, it will also get a new glass cockpit, new IRST, MAWS, RWR etc and all Indian
Can we integrate our weapon on Rafale on our own
Can we upgrade Rafale on our own
No
It's actually more complicated than just that. If you want to oppose, oppose any deals to Import weapons, because with Imports, you pay more and get less.
Whatever points Mr @Pawankhera raised here, apply equally to Su 30MKI Deal which was negotiated in the Congress era and the license production deal was signed during the Vajpayee government.
It’s just we have outsmarted the older Russian Technology and we are able to upgrade them locally which will be difficult with Rafale.
Also, we still don't have critical tech to make AL 31FP Engines completely on our own.
Want to talk about more blunder? We purchased MiG 23 and MiG 27 in significant numbers again during congress era, IAF was forced to retire them early due to their poor performance and maintenance.
So, its not like specifically Rafale deal is an issue, its as bad as any other deal we will do for Import. In fact, it’s less bad than any other platform which is out there to Import.
So, what we need is the serious push for local capability, for which doubts has been raised and timelines has been pushed.
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
Rafale VS Tejas Mk2.
29 squadrons against a sanctioned 42.5. Three MiG-29 and six Jaguar squadrons retire by this decade's end. The Air Chief says he needs 36 to 40 new fighters annually just to stop the slide.
Now look at what ₹3.25 lakh crore buys: 114 Rafale F4s, 18 flyaway from France and 96 built in India at roughly 12 a year. Production won't start before 2030, putting the last delivery near 2038.
One squadron a year at roughly ₹54,000 crore per squadron. The IAF needs four. Make in India branding doesn't change the reality of a French-dependent supply chain.
The Tejas Mk2 is the only option that scales
The Mk2's first flight is targeted for 2027, with induction around 2030–31. The same window as Indian-built Rafales. Only one leaves us owning the production ecosystem.
The GE F414 co-production programme promises substantial technology transfer and Indian manufacturing. Sign the 99-engine contract this financial year.
DRDO's Uttam Mk2 AESA radar, indigenous electronic warfare and Indian weapons like Astra, Rudram and SAAW give us control over upgrades without foreign vendors.
The Mk2 is also designed to integrate with India's network-centric warfare architecture and future manned-unmanned teaming programmes.
The ultimate goal: a fully indigenous Tejas Mk2A
The Mk2 should be the bridge, not the destination.
India's future 110–120 kN indigenous fighter engine should eventually power an upgraded Tejas Mk2A, subject to successful development and certification.
Imagine an aircraft with an Indian-designed airframe, indigenous engine, Uttam AESA radar, Indian EW suite, mission computer, flight-control software and weapons.
The GE F414 is a stepping stone. The long-term objective must be an Indian-developed engine, giving us control over manufacturing, upgrades and maintenance.
The endgame isn't just building Tejas in India. It's building a fighter India can design, manufacture, upgrade and sustain independently.
What that means in a war
Two things matter: how quickly we replace losses and introduce new capabilities.
Lose six Rafales and replacements depend on Dassault's production queue, foreign supply chains and export approvals. Lose six Mk2s and Indian production can potentially replenish the fleet.
Want to integrate a new missile in 2032? Indigenous development gives us greater control over timelines, software and upgrades.
Where the Rafale still earns a place
Two engines over Tibet, greater range and payload, and commonality with the Navy's 26 Rafale-M are genuine advantages.
Keep the Rafale for high-altitude twin-engine operations, deep strike and naval commonality. Buy 36–54 additional aircraft, not 114.
It should complement the IAF, not become the backbone of a 42-squadron force.
The same ₹3.25 lakh crore, spent here
200-plus Tejas Mk2s at an estimated $80–85 million each: 11–12 squadrons, replacing the MiG-29, Mirage 2000 and Jaguar fleets.
100-plus AMCA aircraft, alongside investment in the 110–120 kN engine programme.
$2–3 billion for CATS Warrior and Astra and Rudram missile stocks.
The result: 300-plus Indian aircraft, seventeen squadrons, and decades of investment circulating through HAL, BEL, BDL, Tata, L&T and Indian MSMEs.
Running costs strengthen the argument. Rafale is estimated at $20,000–25,000 per flight hour, against $8,000–12,000 for the Mk2. Across four decades, that difference matters.
What I'd do
Cap additional Rafales at 36–54. Sign the F414 co-production contract this year. Fund a second Mk2 production line targeting over 24 aircraft annually.
Invest in tankers and AEW&C too. We have six against a requirement of 18–20. Closing that gap multiplies every fighter's effectiveness.
We already have 36 Rafales. What we don't have is 42 squadrons or an engine we build ourselves.
One purchase order cannot fix a production problem.
The Tejas Mk2 is our opportunity to fix it permanently. The ultimate goal: a fully indigenous Indian fighter, powered by an Indian engine.
Uber fucking rare Opposition W
Apart from the loooong delay, here are the highlights of the Rafale deal. We are getting:
- Less Rafales.
- More expensive Rafales.
- Very limited transfer of manufacturing capabilities.
- No meaningful transfer of technology.
- No transfer of source code.
So, essentially, France gives us the jets, locks their systems and retains control over our ability to integrate, modify or upgrade them.
❌This means that if our Air Force wants to independently upgrade the Rafales to meet its evolving operational requirements, it will be unable to do so without the manufacturer's involvement.
❌Now, forget defence strategy for a moment and think like a computer gamer. Even a gamer will tell you that buying an expensive system without the freedom to modify or upgrade its "settings" is hardly a winning hand!
❌It amounts to sending our Air Force into battle with its hands tied, without giving it full control over the machines it will be operating. And this is a glaring demonstration of the government's ignorance of modern warfare.
❓Given the enormous bill the Indian taxpayer will be footing, the Defence Minister must explain exactly what is in it for India.
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
We have to differentiate between Sovereign AI and Frontier AI. Sarvam will build and deliver sovereign AI but won’t be a frontier lab. Both in terms of foundational models and the surrounding ecosystem like harnesses and API gateways etc to leverage other open weight models(which can be used for sovereign near applications when hosted locally) Sarvam will deliver.
But, there’s no realistic path for them to build and keep building frontier models with existing Indian initial conditions. A minimum of 500k GPUs, ability to bring atleast 100-200 really creme de la creme of global foundational AI/ML talent to India and pay them the comp. Which is tricky bcos Anthropic, OpenAI, DeepMind, Meta etc can load up in stocks that’ll make multi millionaires in US, whereas Sarvam can hardly provide such valuations if goal is just Indian frontier AI.
It’s like an Indian CRM upstart competing with Salesforce on market share and valuation without products and roadmap to gain Fortune 500 clients and keep at it perpetually. Unless Sarvam presents a vision to go global with Indian labs developed proprietary models and frontier marching efforts to capture Trillion $$ TAM, where it’ll have to compete with other frontier labs.
Without that, Sarvam’s TAM will be a fraction and ergo low ability to provide high equity upside and attract talent and also attract VC.
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
Amusing to see someone say that raising $234 million is “that much capital but failure to build frontier AI”. which world are you living in? A quarterly spend of one US frontier lab or Chinese lab would mog all of India’s annual AI development budget.
Sarvam got picked by the government in April 2025 to build India's own foundation model. They got a ₹98.68 crore GPU subsidy for 4,096 H100s and raised $234M at a $1.5B valuation in June.
Now they've opened Token Factory to everyone. 8 models on it. 1 is theirs. 6 are Chinese open weights (DeepSeek, Kimi, GLM) and 1 is Google's Gemma.
So India's sovereign AI lab is mostly serving Chinese models from Indian GPUs. That's a hosting business, and plenty of companies already run one.
I wanted Sarvam to be the lab that ships frontier research out of India. After that much capital and subsidized compute, this is not it.
Never in my life thought Reliance doing something not money, but for country...
..even if accidentally.
Like it or not, Reliance has spoiled Safran’s game.
I believe both should be allowed to take a shot at the AMCA engine programme. Let the company that delivers the right technology, within the stipulated timelines, emerge as the vendor whether it is Safran or Rolls-Royce.
With Rolls-Royce, India also avoids the Rafale jaziya, while opening up an opportunity for a serious private-sector-led effort.
41
824
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
Every single Indian bureaucrat deserves to be publicly humiliated, for not doing their jobs properly and making a ancient country into a shit hole.
Bittu Tabahi Says Repeated River Clean-Up Efforts Took A Toll On His Health, Shows Infected Hands
ndtv.com/india-news/bittu-ta…
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
🇨🇳💵🍜
🇮🇳💵🗣️
We (@Raphe_mPhibr) will give Indian 6th Gen Aircraft in India.
~ Chairman of Raphe
Na karay janaab, na karay. Hamare liye to yahi ship hotay hain janaab...khuda ka khauf karein janaab, 30kg kaafi hain
Combination of all below mentioned capabilities and Arrow-1 is a further redesign with Larger swept back Wings longer range.
It's a jack of all trades while also being a master of all.
Stealth
Ai Enabled Swarm attack
Can function as a decoy or jammer.
Can be used for Antiship
2
10
234
LeDarthPlanet retweeted
Group Captain Uttam Kumar Devnath Sir💀🗿
Destroyed Import Babus 🤣😂
Phoooo Phaaaaaa.........!!!!!
Full Podcast:- youtu.be/0tQ05kIRjmg
Seems like JR is throwing a hissy fit when it comes to ToT.
And our babus, keeping a spine, going for a worse, but sovereign option for the long term.
toyokeizai.net/articles/-/96… (2026/11/15アクセス)
この東洋経済オンラインの記事(大坂直樹氏)を読むと、「政府の新幹線輸出推進と分割民営化後のJR体制の相性の悪さ」と「政府とJR各社の新幹線輸出に対する温度差」の両方が浮かび上がってきます。
記事内でJR東日本の高岡常務は「あくまで日本政府の要請を受けて対応している」「日本政府とインドの間での議論を待つしかない」「やめてくださいと言える立場ではない」と明言しています。
国が政治的・外交的に案件を推進する一方で、実際の技術を担うJR側は受け身の姿勢に留まっている様子が読み取れます。
分割民営化は国内事業の自律性を前提とした制度でした。しかし輸出の場では「日本の新幹線」として一体的に売ろうとする政府の方針と、各社が自社の既存システムを基盤に動く構造がぶつかり、技術的な柔軟化や相手国の事情への適応を主導しにくい状態を生んでいます。
インド案件で信号システムや車両を巡って生じた齟齬も、この構造の延長線上にあるように見えます。「国が推進し、JRが要請に応じて対応する」という役割分担が、結果として相手国から見て「国内事情のコピペ」になりやすい一因になっているのではないでしょうか。
(Grokに作らせた文章を一部修正したものです)



































