@molemob (@molemob) header
@molemob (@molemob) profile picture

Everyone should read our 1996 Constitution. Tweets are on my individual capacity not endorsement & no vacarious liability enforceable thereof.

Johannesburg, South Africa
Joined January 2012
Photo by @molemob (@molemob)Photo by @molemob (@molemob)
Today I appeared before Lady Justice C Meoli on a simple straightforward application for review. She demanded that we file submissions. I insisted that she writes a ruling based upon the Affidavits as the issue necessitating review is not contested. She gives a ruling date on 17-6-2027. I notify her that rulings ought to be delivered within 30 days as required by the Civil Procedure Rules. She shouts back that I am not the only one being given that date. I tell her that others may be happy with far off dates outside the permissible time but I am not. The debate goes on until she looses her cool. An exchange ensures. She accuses me of bullying Judges, and tells me that I should change the Rules if I need preferential treatment in Court. Now, the law requires that rulings be delivered within 30 days. To what extent does she propose that I change the Rules to suit my preference. We have a problem with some of these Judges. We will continue complaining about them, before them and in public. It is the only avenue we have now that the C J and the JSC cannot reign-in on them to do their work efficiently and effectively. Call it bullying but if you accept an appointment as a Judge you must work.
68
231
15
773
63,219
@molemob retweeted
Legal practitioner Tumelo Fidel Bogosi explores an accused person's right to be brought to court within 48 hours of arrest, emphasising that 48 hours is a statutory maximum limit rather than a default detention period. derebus.org.za/the-accused-p…
3
5
371
Bafowethu I think this is of national important it should be televised 📹..
Advocate Johann Hershensohn SC for the Home Affairs dept in the asylum applications case being heard by the Johannesburg High Court on whether illegal foreigners applying for asylum should be detained or not. This will determine how these cases are dealt with. @MakiLeshoro
17
634
2
1,358
37,226
This hail storm was serious in Soweto mos🤔🤔 This is Jabulani Mall
133
464
39
1,675
164,115
The Coachella of constitutional lawyers 😌
It’s now two weeks until the #MadlangaConference at Stellenbosch University. The programme is out and it’s fire 🔥🔥 Looking forward to the opening discussion with Muzi Sikhakhane SC, Henk Botha, Mitch de Beer and Gideon Basson. Info: su.ac.za/en/faculties/law/ev…
8
37
1
269
14,966
WATCH | Behind every breakthrough in artificial intelligence are the people bold enough to build it. In partnership with the Mail & Guardian, the 2026 South African AI Awards spotlighted the change-makers and organisations transforming the country's AI landscape. @SAAIAWARDS #SAAIAWARDS #AI
2
2
3
2,423
CARRIM'S BAIL APPLICATION: THE CONSTITUTION AND SECTION 60(4) @AttorneysDonda The State opposes Suliman Carrim's bail, citing alleged vehicle theft, flight risk, financial disclosure and non-compliance with court orders. The defence disputes these allegations and argues that strict bail conditions can address the risks. THE CONSTITUTIONAL FRAMEWORK Section 35(1)(f) of the Constitution guarantees an arrested person the right to release if the interests of justice permit, subject to reasonable conditions. In S v Dlamini 1999 (2) SACR 51 (CC), the Constitutional Court emphasised the need to balance personal liberty against the interests of justice. APPLYING SECTION 60(4)(a)–(e) 1. Public safety – Section 60(4)(a) The State alleges Carrim was involved in a scheme involving two Absa-financed vehicles. He denies the allegations. The court must assess whether his release poses a danger to public safety or a risk of further Schedule 1 offences. 2. Flight risk – Section 60(4)(b) The State relies on his UAE residency and foreign assets. The defence points to his South African businesses, reportedly employing nearly 1,000 people, disclosed assets and willingness to surrender his passport and accept travel restrictions. 3. Interference with evidence – Section 60(4)(c) The State relies on WhatsApp messages obtained from his cellphone. Carrim challenges the legality of the download. The court must consider whether his release creates a likelihood of witness intimidation or interference with evidence. 4. Undermining the justice system – Section 60(4)(d) The State alleges Carrim breached his Pretoria bail conditions concerning his appearance before the Madlanga Commission. The defence argues that written correspondence sent within 48 hours substantially complied with the court order. It also maintains that the Pretoria and Musina proceedings are separate. 5. Public order – Section 60(4)(e) The State must establish exceptional circumstances showing that Carrim's release is likely to disturb public order or undermine public peace and security. Serious allegations alone are insufficient. THE CENTRAL QUESTION The court must determine whether the State has established grounds to refuse bail and whether reasonable conditions can manage the identified risks. Bail is not a determination of guilt. The constitutional question is whether continued detention is justified in the interests of justice.
1
3
476
Regter skuldig bevind nadat hy advokate gevra het hoekom hulle wit is. Dit volg op ’n klag deur die Solidariteit Regsnetwerk by die Regterlike Dienskommissie (RDK). Volgens die uitspraak moet regter Motha ’n waarskuwing ontvang om nie weer sulke uitlatings te maak nie. Hy moet ook binne 15 dae ná die uitspraak deur die Gautengse regter-president, Aubrey Ledwaba, berispe word. Regter Motha het aan vier advokate geskryf en ’n verduideliking geëis waarom nie een van hulle swart is nie. Die Solidariteit Regsnetwerk beskerm regslui en het ook onlangs ’n saak gewen oor sektorkodes wat ras in die regsberoep reguleer. Solidariteit doen ’n beroep op alle regslui om by die netwerk aan te sluit.
26
193
11
589
14,286
Greetings Colleagues, You opened a law firm. You have no clients, no inherited briefs and no lawyers in your family. Now what? In this edition of ADVOCATES VOICE, I share practical ways for young 1st generation advocates in Kenya to build a solo practice. A signboard is not a client acquisition strategy. Please read and share. Ekaterina Handa Partner Gitonga, Kinyanjui & Co. Advocates #AdvocatesVoice #YoungAdvocates
6
35
2
116
11,687
Two excellent judgments recently delivered by the Supreme Court on the principles governing compulsory retirement. The first, authored by Justice Dipankar Datta, was argued by Senior Advocate Sanjoy Ghosh @advsanjoy S. S. Das v. Union of India, C.A. No. 3215 of 2026. The second is the judgment authored by Justice Manmohan. The contours of compulsory retirement are well settled by the Supreme Court through a catena of judgments. “The ultimate assessment as to whether an officer has become ‘deadwood’ or whether his continued service would be detrimental to administrative efficiency falls within the domain of the executive.”
14
74
6,814
JUDGMENT OF THE DAY DAY 97 CAN CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS BE QUASHED WHEN OFFICIAL RECORDS SHOW THAT THE ACCUSED WAS NOT PRESENT AT THE PLACE OF OCCURRENCE? The Supreme Court examined whether criminal proceedings under Sections 498-A and 304-B IPC should continue against an accused when an unimpeachable BSF service record established his absence from the place of occurrence, and his co-accused parents had already been acquitted on the same evidence. THE SUPREME COURT HELD: 🔹 The High Court can consider official records of sterling and unimpeachable quality while exercising its inherent powers under Section 482 CrPC. 🔹 A plea of alibi ordinarily requires proof at trial. However, this is not an inflexible rule where undisputed official records conclusively establish the relevant circumstances. 🔹 The acquittal of co-accused does not automatically exonerate another accused. However, it becomes relevant when the prosecution relies on the identical evidence against both. 🔹 Applying the four-step test laid down in Rajiv Thapar v. Madan Lal Kapoor, the Court held that continuation of proceedings against the appellant would amount to an abuse of the process of law. 🔹 The Supreme Court quashed the FIR, chargesheet and all consequential proceedings against the appellant. LEGAL TAKEAWAY: Criminal proceedings can be quashed at the threshold when unimpeachable official records and other undisputed circumstances demonstrate that their continuation would amount to an abuse of the process of court. TODAY’S JUDGMENT: Rahul v. State of Uttar Pradesh and Another 2026 INSC 825 Criminal Appeal arising out of SLP (Crl.) No. 2939 of 2026
6
1
29
1,498
@molemob retweeted
This paper answers why confident idiots run the world. Cornell University published a psychological paper that explains every terrible boss, every loud influencer, and every broken corporate hierarchy. It’s called “Unskilled and Unaware of It.” they tested participants across logic, grammar, and humor to measure the gap between actual performance and self-perception. And the results are wild. participants scoring in the bottom 12th percentile consistently believed they were operating in the 62nd percentile. they were not lying. they were literally incapable of recognizing their own incompetence. the paper revealed a brutal paradox: the exact skills required to master a domain are the exact same skills required to accurately evaluate your own competence in that domain. if you lack the skill, you inherently lack the cognitive capacity to realize you are failing. this creates a dangerous systemic loop. the incompetent are blessed with absolute, blinding certainty. their brain protects them from their own ignorance, allowing them to speak first, demand authority, and never second-guess their decisions. meanwhile, the actual experts suffer the exact inverse. top performers in the study consistently underestimated their rank. because a task was easy for them, they falsely assumed it was easy for everyone else. they hesitate. they obsess over nuance. they assume they have nothing unique to add. we are biologically wired to confuse confidence with competence. the loudest person in the room gets promoted, gets funded, and gets the microphone, not because they know what they are doing, but because they are physically incapable of seeing what they don't. the only defense mechanism is building systems that stop rewarding absolute certainty and start demanding proof of work.
73
683
76
2,183
85,306
Ideas matter, but what do we do with them? Nelson Mandela Foundation Chief Executive Dr Mbongiseni Buthelezi reflects on why Madiba established the Nelson Mandela Annual Lecture in 2003. Ahead of Friday’s 24th Nelson Mandela Annual Lecture, delivered by former President of Colombia, and 2016 Nobel Peace Laureate, Juan Manuel Santos under the theme “When is silence complicity?” Watch the full interview here: bit.ly/4ecY7fl #NMAL2026 #MandelaLecture
9
17
3,477
@molemob retweeted
I feel this article is well worth reading. It helps dispel the myth that critical thinking can be applied to all situations. Many educational programs and business leaders have advocated for learning “higher-order thinking skills,” assuming these skills will then be++
92
2,138
118
12,642
1,203,446
SOUTH AFRICA’S GRADUATION OUT OF AGOA DOESN’T MEAN WE WON'T HAVE ACCESS TO THE U.S. MARKET. WE WILL HAVE ACCESS, BUT WITH SLIGHTLY HIGHER TARIFFS. While we are now in a different political climate, I think it’s important to remember that aside from the issues the U.S. raised about South Africa’s eligibility to be part of AGOA, there have been some conversations for some time. For example, back in 2014, the focus, amongst other things, was on the reality that South Africa is an upper-middle-income country and should have graduated from AGOA to a full bilateral trade agreement with the U.S. Of course, we had our own complications, both because of the Southern African Customs Union (SACU), which we can’t sign bilateral trade agreements without, and because we lobbied to keep benefiting from this unilateral approach (AGOA). Looking back, if we had found a way to graduate out of AGOA, as we were pressured to do then, and started conversations about a trade agreement, we would be in a different climate than what we are seeing now. Of course, this doesn’t mean countries with trade agreements are spared from drastic changes in U.S. trade policy; we see those changes affecting countries like Canada. Beyond South Africa graduating out of AGOA, I think there is also confusion about the implications. Others frame it as a complete ban from the U.S. market, which is not the case. Simply put, as South Africa transitions out of AGOA, the country would face an additional Most Favoured Nation tariff of around 3.4% on top of the existing tariffs the current U.S. Administration added to various countries. Currently, some South African products enter the U.S. market at 12.5% tariffs (Liberation Day tariff). Without AGOA, these tariffs would rise to 15.9%, slightly reducing the competitiveness of some South African products in the U.S. market. Still, one could argue that while this would be a challenging path, it would not necessarily be as catastrophic as we have faced in the past, when we faced much higher U.S. tariffs and still managed to compete. Consider South Africa’s agriculture: in 2025, the South African farming sector faced tariffs of around 30%. Still, agricultural exports to the U.S. were strong. South Africa’s agricultural exports to the U.S. in 2025 totalled US$504 million, down 3% from the previous year. During the higher “Liberation Day Tariffs”, some South African agricultural exporters took advantage of the 90-day pause in the second quarter of 2025 and exported more volume than usual. After this pause, exports cooled in the third and fourth quarters of 2025. Notably, South Africa’s agricultural exports to the U.S. fell 11% in the third quarter of 2025, compared with the same period in 2024, to US$144 million. In the last quarter, South Africa’s agricultural exports to the U.S. fell sharply by 39% to US$81 million. Still, the overall annual exports were encouraging. Even this year, South Africa’s agricultural exports to the U.S. were strong. For example, South Africa's agricultural exports to the U.S. increased by 56% from the first quarter of 2026 to the second quarter of 2026, to US$123 million. The decline in U.S. tariffs, from 30% to 12.5%, among other factors, has been the major contributor to the increase in South Africa’s agricultural exports to the U.S. The U.S. remains an important market for South African agriculture, accounting for about 4% of our agricultural exports. Main exports include citrus, berries, grapes, raisins, wine, fruit juices, apples, pears, apricots, and nuts. Again, South Africa's graduation from AGOA must be viewed in context and may not mean a catastrophe. This is not to understate the impact some industries may feel as the increase in tariffs slightly reduces their competitiveness. Still, we must manage the sentiment and narrative around this issue well. Above all, this yet again reminds us of the need to work hard to diversify South Africa’s export markets to growing regions such as Asia and the Middle East. But export diversification must be framed correctly; it is not a replacement for the U.S., EU, UK, Africa, and other markets. These remain key, and we must work to retain our access to them. --Wandile
104
741
67
1,301
123,799
As confirmed in September 2026 by Land Reform and Rural Development Minister Mzwanele Nyhontso, the South African government does not have recently updated, comprehensive statistics for racial land ownership, meaning the 2017 State Land Audit remains the most recent official benchmark. The statistics from the official 2017 Land Audit Report issued by the Department of Rural Development and Land Reform break down ownership based on categories of title deeds as follows: 1. Farms and Agricultural Holdings (Rural Individually Deeded Land) When isolating individual title deeds for farms and agricultural holdings (which accounts for roughly 37 million hectares), the official racial distribution is: Coloured people: 15% (5,371,383 hectares) African people: 4% (1,314,873 hectares) Combined African & Coloured individual ownership: 19% (For context, White individuals hold 72% and Indian individuals hold 5% of this specific land category). 2. Urban Land (Individual Residential and Erven Title Deeds) For individuals holding title deeds in urban areas (totaling roughly 722,667 hectares), the distribution shifts significantly: African people: 30% (219,033 hectares) Coloured people: 8% (54,522 hectares) Combined African & Coloured individual ownership: 38% (White individuals hold 49% and Indian individuals hold 8% of urban individual deeded land). Crucial Caveats regarding South African Land Statistics The data above does not equate to a percentage of all land in South Africa due to the following data limitations acknowledged by both government and researchers: Juristic Hidden Data: The state land audit could only assign a race to land held by private individuals. Roughly 46% of private land is registered under Companies, Trusts, and Communal Property Associations (CPAs), which cannot be racially profiled by the Deeds Office. State and Communal Land Exclusions: The figures exclude the 23% of South African land owned directly by the State, as well as approximately 15% to 18 million hectares of communal land (such as the Ingonyama Trust). This communal land is occupied almost exclusively by millions of Black Africans, but mostly lacks individual title deeds. AI Mode response is ready Ask about
3
5
612
@molemob retweeted
In 1998 former President Thabo Mbeki said “A major component part of the issue of reconciliation and nation building is defined by and derives from the material conditions in our society which have divided our country into two nations, the one black and the other white South Africa is a country of two nations. One of these nations is white, relatively prosperous, regardless of gender or geographic dispersal. It has ready access to a developed economic, physical, educational, communication and other infrastructure. This enables it to argue that, except for the persistence of gender discrimination against women, all members of this nation have the possibility to exercise their right to equal opportunity, the development opportunities to which the Constitution of '93 committed our country. The second and larger nation of South Africa is black and poor, with the worst affected being women in the rural areas, the black rural population in general and the disabled. This nation lives under conditions of a grossly underdeveloped economic, physical, educational, communication and other infrastructure. It has virtually no possibility to exercise what in reality amounts to a theoretical right to equal opportunity, with that right being equal within this black nation only to the extent that it is equally incapable of realisation. This reality of two nations, underwritten by the perpetuation of the racial, gender and spatial disparities born of a very long period of colonial and apartheid white minority domination, constitutes the material base which reinforces the notion that, indeed, we are not one nation, but two nations. And neither are we becoming one nation. Consequently, also, the objective of national reconciliation is not being realised. Today in 2026, South Africa is still a country of two nations
11
1
23
2,256
According to former Deputy Chief Justice Dikgang Moseneke and prominent legal scholar Tembeka Ngcukaitobi, the Constitution of South Africa and its existing legal frameworks have never been the barrier to land reform; instead, the failure lies entirely with the government's lack of political will, corruption, and administrative incompetence. Both legal minds have argued extensively that Section 25 of the Constitution (the property clause) provides all the necessary power to achieve radical land redistribution, but those powers were simply never utilized effectively by the state. Key Arguments by Dikgang Moseneke and Tembeka Ngcukaitobi 1. The Constitution is an Enabler, Not a Barrier Expropriation without compensation was always possible: Both scholars have pointed out that Section 25 never strictly demanded "market-value" compensation. The Constitution requires compensation to be "just and equitable," which allows for zero compensation in specific, justifiable circumstances. The legal tools existed: The state always had the constitutional mandate to expropriate land for public interest and land reform, but it chose a slow, market-dependent "willing buyer, willing seller" policy instead. 2. Government Dereliction of Duty Failure to pass enabling legislation: For over two decades, the ANC-led government failed to pass a clear Expropriation Act that defined exactly how and when land could be taken for redistribution. Budgetary starvation: Land reform was never given top financial priority. The budget allocated to land reform and restitution has historically been less than 1% of the national budget. 3. Corruption and Elite Capture Farms given to the politically connected: Instead of redistributing land to the poor, farm workers, or labor tenants, many state-acquired farms were allocated to wealthy politicians, state officials, and politically connected elites. The "bureaucratic mess": The Department of Rural Development and Land Reform has been plagued by corruption, missing records, and syndicates that inflated land prices to enrich government officials and corrupt sellers. 4. The Failure of Land Restitution Unresolved claims: Decades after the 1998 deadline for lodging land claims, hundreds of thousands of claims remain unresolved due to state inefficiency. Collapsing projects: In cases where land was restored to communities, the state failed to provide post-settlement agricultural support, capital, or training, causing many commercial farms to collapse financially. Summary of the Debate When the government initiated debates to amend the Constitution to allow for "expropriation without compensation," Moseneke, Ngcukaitobi, and other legal analysts argued that amending the text was a political scapegoat. They maintained that changing the wording of the Constitution would not magically fix a broken, corrupt, and incompetent state bureaucracy. youtu.be/C_bYmbQazuo?si=XNBC…
19
121
8
225
43,397
🚨Kylian Mbappé on Harry Kane winning the Ballon d’Or ahead of him and Lamine Yamal: 🗣️ Kylian Mbappé: “To be honest, I sat there throughout the ceremony and listened to everything. I barely moved from my seat because, at some point, I genuinely wanted to see whether they were going to invite us onto the stage or simply hand every award to the Spanish players! “Every time they announced a winner, it felt like another Spanish player was going to collect a trophy. And I’m sitting there thinking, ‘Okay, let’s see how this ends.’ “At one point, Michael Olise turned to me and said, ‘Kylian, when did the Ballon d’Or become a country achievement?’ “I laughed and told him, ‘Just sit down and watch. We haven’t seen the final award yet.’ “Then Lamine won the Young Player of the Year award. Congratulations to him, because he is an incredible talent. But we were still waiting for the biggest prize of the night. “Finally, they announced the men’s Ballon d’Or winner, and it was Harry Kane. “Honestly, if I had to choose between Harry Kane and Lamine Yamal winning it ahead of me, I would rather see Harry win it. “Not because I have anything against Lamine. He is a fantastic player, and I respect what he has achieved. But Harry represents something I deeply respect about football. He has worked for years, carried enormous expectations and continued to deliver at the highest level. “Seeing him lift that trophy made me happy. I was proud of him, genuinely. But let me be clear: I didn’t travel to that ceremony to support Harry Kane. I went there because I wanted to win the Ballon d’Or myself. “And I think people sometimes forget that. You can respect another player, congratulate him and appreciate his achievement while still being disappointed that you didn’t win. “I sat there watching him celebrate, and part of me was happy for him. Another part of me was asking what I needed to do differently to make sure I would be the one standing on that stage next time. “People might look at my reaction and say, ‘Mbappé should be grateful to be nominated.’ Of course I’m grateful. But I didn’t reach this level by being satisfied with nominations. “I want to win. I want to be the best. And when I lose, I don’t suddenly pretend that winning was never important to me. “I would rather lose the Ballon d’Or to a player I respect than win the sympathy of people who tell me I deserved it after the ceremony.” “Harry had his night, and I respect that. But my story isn’t finished. If working harder, scoring more goals, improving my game and taking greater responsibility are what it takes, then that is exactly what I will do. “I won’t ask anyone to feel sorry for me. I won’t complain about the result. I will go back to work. “Because the next time I walk into that ceremony, I don’t want to sit there wondering whose name they are going to announce. “I want to hear my own name and I want nobody to have an argument about whether I deserve it.”
Readers added context they thought people might want to know
The detailed quote attributed to Kylian Mbappé here is fabricated; he made no such statements. Harry Kane won the 2026 Ballon d'Or ahead of Mbappé (2nd) and Lamine Yamal (3rd), with reports noting only Mbappé's visible disappointment at the event. bbc.com/sport/football… infobae.com/deportes/2026/… uefa.com/uefachampionsl…
449
1,126
133
23,749
4,412,661
Dear South Africa 🇿🇦 I have been given a slot to participate in another world record high altitude marathon in 2027. This could see me collect my 2nd World Record again after this year's Guinness World Record. I need Sponsorship partner. Cost is R200 000-00 Ngicela Mzansi 🙏🙏 – at Nelspruit, South Africa
4
26
1
65
2,040