Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall) header
Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall) profile picture

Occasional Conservative. Father of daughters. Chef wannabe.

London, England
Joined October 2013
Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)Photo by Will Marshall (@mrwillmarshall)
1/בעיניי, הטור ביום שישי הוא מהחשובים שכתבתי. לפחות מבחינת הדחיפות העצומה ומצב החירום הנוכחי, שהוא לדעת מקורותיי חמור מתרחיש בו איראן השיגה נשק גרעיני. הנה הקטע הרלבנטי. ישראל במצב חירום אסטרטגי עמוק ומחריף. הניצחון הענק של הדמוקרטים בבחירות האמצע, יחד עם תפנית בדעת הקהל כלפי ישראל, יביאו עמם מהלכי חקיקה בקונגרס. זה יכול להתחיל בסנקציות בעקבות טרור יהודי בשטחים, להמשיך בניסיון לחסל את העמימות הגרעינית הישראלית ולהגיע לשיא בהגבלות על מכירת נשק – כזה שיוגדר "התקפי". בהמשך נשק בכלל. את המהלכים האלה אפשר לעכב או לדלל, אך לא למנוע לגמרי. קחו לדוגמה את הסנאטור החדש מטקסס, המטאור ג'יימס טלריקו. כאשר הוא החל את הקמפיין שלו, הוא אימץ גישה מרכזית מאוד ביחס לשאר המפלגה הדמוקרטית באשר לישראל. בכל זאת, הוא התמודד במדינה אדומה, רפובליקנית, שמרנית. ככל שהקמפיין התקדם, טלריקו הפך להיות יותר חד בביקורת על ישראל. מה הוא גילה? שלא רק שדמוקרטים סולדים מישראל ומדיניותה, אלא שהוא יכול למשוך קולות של רפובליקנים רבים באמצעות עמדה ביקורתית יותר כלפי נתניהו וממשלתו. ההתפתחויות הללו לא יסכנו רק את היתרון האיכותי של ישראל- אלא את היכולת של חיל האוויר להיות בכשירות מבצעית. חיל האוויר וצה"ל כולו נסמכים לתפקודם השוטף על אספקה שוטפת של ציוד, כלים ותחמושת אמריקנית. לא משנה כמה חלקי חילוף מחזיקה ישראל במחסניה, אם האמריקנים יפסיקו לספק אותם לחיל האוויר, בסוף – הוא יתקשה לתפקד. לכל מי שמפטפט על "לייצר בארץ" או "לקנות מהודו" – מומלץ לדבר עם ראשי להק ציוד בעבר בחיל האוויר, או מנכ"לים לשעבר של משרד הביטחון. הסכנה לביטחון הישראלי היא אמיתית, מוחשית וקרובה בהרבה מפצצה גרעינית באיראן. וזה רחב בהרבה מאספקת ציוד ונשק. מהשלום עם מצרים ועד להסכמי אברהם, מרכיב משמעותי שהביאה ישראל ליחסיה עם העולם הערבי היה הנגישות והקרבה לוושינגטון. אם ישראל הופכת ליותר ויותר מצורעת, לידידיה יש פחות תמריץ; לאויביה יש סיבה לתקווה. לישראל יש שני נכסי ביטחון אסטרטגי מהותיים: צה"ל ומערכת הביטחון, והברית עם ארה"ב. ללא הברית עם אמריקה, צה"ל ומערכת הביטחון ייחלשו משמעותית. פיזית, מילולית. ** המצב הזה דורש שינוי דחוף בהתנהלות ישראל; מהלכי חירום נרחבים. מבוססי מדיניות. ב"מדיניות" הכוונה היא שהממשלה החדשה תצטרך ליזום שורה של צעדים אמיתיים, עם משמעות אזורית. עצירה כוחנית ומהירה של הטרור היהודי בשטחים, וריסוק התשתיות שלו. זה יצטרך להיות מהיר ואגרסיבי. הצדק הזה לא רק צריך להיעשות, אלא גם להיראות – לאור הנזק העצום שנגרם לישראל. וזו רק ההתחלה, הסיפתח. יהיה צורך במהלך מדיני נרחב כלפי הפלסטינים, וב"מדיני" הכוונה היא לתהליך שלום. ישראל תצטרך להציג גישה חדשה לגמרי לרצועת עזה, בנייתה ושיקומה. החזקת השטחים בסוריה ובלבנון תצטרך להישקל היטב מול תועלות ביטחוניות ומחירים מדיניים. מדיניות הפעלת הכוח של צה"ל הייתה תחת הגדרת "מלחמה" מאז ה-7 באוקטובר. זה לא יכול להימשך כך; המחירים המדיניים עצומים. הפוליטיקאים והמטה הכללי נכנסו לפרדיגמה מראשית המלחמה, של לקיחת "אפס סיכון" מהרמה הטקטית (דמות חשודה שמתקדמת על ציר בעזה), ועד הרמה האסטרטגית (התרעות למכביר על מתקפות פתע). התוצאה: אינפלציה בפעילות התקפית. כאילו אין לזה מחיר. מי שמחפש מחיר למה שהתרחש בעזה מאז הפסקת האש – כדאי שיביט במתרחש בוושינגטון ובעולם.
128
288
67
1,846
308,753
Will Marshall retweeted
It's very hard to explain in a compelling way how bad Trump's Iran policy has been without explaining how we were set on this course of action 10+ years ago by JCPOA opponents. slowboring.com/p/21-thoughts…
15
28
2
408
42,393
Will Marshall retweeted
I’ve done my own investigation into Byline Times and the suspicious nature of those instantly boosting the article. If you’d like to support my journalism please treat yourself to something at GAIL’s bakery. Thank you.
🔴 NEW ‘Habibi’: The Anatomy of an Influence Operation on X By Dan Evans and Byline Times Team An exclusive six-month investigation by Byline Times has mapped the workings of pile-ons and cancellations of public figures on social media Subscribe to support fearless independent journalism. bylinetimes.com/2026/11/12/h…
44
173
12
737
25,479
Will Marshall retweeted
I’m not even a Schumer guy (feel free to do a search on my past tweets about him lol) so I can’t believe I’m the one laying this all out, but everyone seems to have memory holed this period, so here goes nothing. From 2021-2022, when Democrats held 50 seats in the Senate (with VP Harris as a tiebreaker) — so they had zero votes to spare — Schumer got 97 federal judges confirmed to the bench (including Ketanji Brown Jackson to the Supreme Court) and shepherded the following bills through to passage on their way to becoming law. You can argue that these didn’t go far enough, he had the wrong priorities, that Build Back Better was a flop, etc. But it is objectively damn impressive that he was able to get all of these through with literally no room for error: American Rescue Plan ($1.9T) Huge economic stimulus package in the midst of the pandemic — provided $1,400 stimulus checks to eligible Americans; expanded unemployment & child tax benefits; funded schools, hospitals, small businesses, local governments, and COVID-19 vaccinations and testing.
 Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act ($1.2T) Repaired roads and bridges, invested in public transportation and passenger rail, expanded broadband internet access, funded improvements to airports and ports, invested in electrical vehicle charging stations & upgraded drinking water systems. CHIPS and Science Act Provided over $50B in incentives to build more computer chip factories in the U.S. and research funding for semiconductor manufacturing to reduce our dependence on Chinese chips. Inflation Reduction Act Allowed Medicare to negotiate prices for certain prescription drugs, capped Medicare beneficiaries' insulin costs at $35 per month, extended Affordable Care Act health insurance subsidies, offered tax incentives for electric vehiclesand clean energy, created a 15% minimum tax on certain large corporations, increased IRS funding to improve tax enforcementand collections.
 PACT Act Expanded healthcare coverage for veterans exposed to burn pits and toxic chemicals, made it easier for veterans to qualify for disability benefits, and added more VA healthcare facilities and resources.
 Bipartisan Safer Communities Act Expanded background checks for gun buyers under 21, provided federal funding for state crisis intervention programs, invested in school security and mental health services.
 Respect for Marriage Act Protected federal recognition of same-sex and interracial marriages and required states to recognize valid marriages performed in other states.
Replying to @admcrlsn
In what sense was he a "fantastic" majority leader with 50 seats?
203
690
88
3,253
324,955
CNN: Raphael Warnock wasn’t trying to make the crowd laugh. “There’s one race I think we’re sleeping on, and that’s Mississippi,” the Georgia senator said as he talked up Democrats’ big plans for the year at a Washington, DC, fundraiser in April. But the attendees did laugh, according to a recording obtained by CNN, and quite hard, until Warnock cut them off. “Mississippi — yes,” he said, before launching into a little of Scott Colom’s biography Link to article: cnn.com/2026/11/11/politics/…
1
46
5
668
25,878
Will Marshall retweeted
Did the Democrats who won campaign with Elizabeth Warren? Was she an in-demand surrogate? Should we maybe let the winners speak for themselves in terms of what kind of policy approach worked?
“The Democrats who won were straightforward about the fact that the economy is rigged against working people. They didn’t pussyfoot around about it; they made it clear: the economy is rigged.” @ewarren
178
70
35
972
152,483
Will Marshall retweeted
Important point. The societal norms that allow some men to get away with offending (alleged offending in the case of Walliams) don't automatically self-combust when something is blown into the open. Harvey Weinstein's conviction didn't achieve it, neither will Russell Brand's.
I am glad to see accountability for Brand and Walliams, but I worry that the festival of hindsight misses the fact that these men only faced consequences when their professional value had collapsed, and right now a successful man is probably getting with similar.
12
36
1
216
11,712
Will Marshall retweeted
This is astonishing
On Thursday I wrote about the 2014 injunction Russell Brand obtained against a woman who accused him of assault. I've now obtained the final order. It's breathtaking. She had no lawyer. No trial. Yet she was silenced for life - even barred from speaking to the police. 🧵:
5
16
164
18,279
Will Marshall retweeted
The worst-performing Democrats in competitive Senate races were the candidates Bernie endorsed. (link in next tweet, no paywall)
240
949
186
5,479
493,354
Will Marshall retweeted
Talarico, a dude who flipped a red state in a landslide, being lectured by a dude who needs like $50 million from Uncle Chuck to win purple Michigan.
Hasan was not happy with James Talarico seeking bipartisanship and says he's compromised when it comes to Israel "Omg Talarico stfu..who is this for man?..just give us 12 hours of excitement..before we get the f'in annoying a*s like centrist pivot..no we're not coalescing around Republicans, we're not collaborating..see look at the way he's (Abdul El-Sayed) communicating on this..he says I defeated Mike Rogers bc my constituents did not want a rubber stamp on Trump or Trumpism" "His Israel position is actually really annoying..he is absolutely f'n compromised..you've already made the case that Israel sucks, that it's doing unbelievable amounts of war crimes, why are you not saying it's a gen*cide..bc you are compromised..it just shows you who he is serving..simply telling you what he knows the party bosses want to hear"
51
351
6
5,231
521,413
Will Marshall retweeted
Here for the replies.
Drunk air passenger who pulled down her underwear and exposed herself in front of holidaymakers on packed jet warned she faces jail Sarah Parker ignored the pilot’s instructions and got up out of her seat to go to the toilet during take off from Birmingham Airport on the Tui flight to Melbourne Florida on July 24 2025 She then pulled down her shorts and underwear in the aisle in full view of other passengers, a court heard. 'The defendant was intoxicated on the flight from Birmingham in the UK to Florida in the US,' prosecutor Edward Downes told magistrates in Manchester on Tuesday. 'Her behaviour was distressing to passengers, causing danger. She was exposing her genitals in view of the passengers. The charge read that she behaved in an indecent manner 'by pulling down her shorts and underwear, squatting and exposing her vagina in full view of other passengers'. Parker also previously pleaded guilty to being drunk on a plane and failing to comply with the pilot's instructions. Prosecutor Edward Downes told magistrates in Manchester the flight had to be diverted to Manchester Airport with the financial loss amounting to £20,000 pounds.
11
16
1
296
172,826
Will Marshall retweeted
This guy is a standing rebuke to people who claim to have committed crimes against humanity because they were just following orders.
3
24
181
7,364
Will Marshall retweeted
Life comes at you fast
6
10
3
101
6,066
Reposting this for no particular reason Liz Cheney: “I say this to my Republican colleagues who are defending the indefensible. There will come a day when Donald Trump is gone, but your dishonor will remain.”
567
14,025
456
63,838
729,624
Will Marshall retweeted
4
209
6
2,684
36,314
And just like that, the snake shed yet another skin
One of the things the data analysts on our side obsessed over was "composition"—whether the electorate looked close enough to 2024 for Republicans to win. And despite polls that showed a Democrat blowout, the data kept on telling us the same story: in some states turnout was merely OK, in other states it was downright amazing, and in no state was it catastrophic. There was a genuine sense of optimism on our team: our people were showing up. So, I asked the smartest data guy I know, does that mean we're going to shock the world? "No," he told me. "We might do better than the polls suggest. But the data is telling us that a lot of Trump/Vance 2024 voters are pissed and planning to vote for the other guys. Our voters are turning out, but they may not vote for us." Well, that looks prophetic now. Our voters did show up. In Florida, for example, the electorate was 9 points more Republican than Democrat, just a couple points worse than 2024. Undoubtedly there were places we could have done better on turnout. But the main problem is not turnout. The main problem is that many people who voted for Trump/Vance in 2024 voted for Democrats in 2026. There will be a lot of infighting and arguing over what happened and why that is. One of the pollsters I really respect told me that our economic messaging wasn’t sharp enough down the stretch. I’m sure that’s true. But the real reason we lost is obvious to almost everyone. Another pollster—one of the smartest people I know in politics, told me yesterday we’d lose the generic ballot by 13 points. I felt negative going into Tuesday, but even I was shocked by this. In his polling, he saw that a lot of Trump 2024 voters were angry and planning to vote for Democrats. He asked those voters who had abandoned us what would cause them to come back on our team. The top four answers, accounting for nearly all of the responses were: 1) End the war 2) Focus on cost of living/inflation 3) Put America First 4) Change our relationship to Israel Our voters showed up. And the above four reasons are why many of them voted for Democrats. This is according to a pollster who nailed the results. While many spent Monday attacking Rachel Campos Duffy for calling for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict, it turns out her political advice was sound. (She’s also a great person.) In the next few months, there's going to be a lot of gaslighting. Expect to hear any number of establishment politicians say the solution to our woes is amnesty. I'm open to the idea that we should change enforcement—by focusing more on businesses that hire illegal labor, for instance. But anyone pushing amnesty is lying to you. The reason we lost is the war. The president himself said so last night. If you'd like to argue it was worth it, that losing the Senate for the next 6 years was worth it, then do so. Argue it was a worthwhile cost to pay. Agree or disagree, that's at least honest. But everyone knows why we lost. And any honest conversation about where we go from here must start there. I remain hopeful about our country. To the people who are pissed off and want to say, “I told you so”: you’re right, you did tell us so. Take that energy into electing Republicans who share your worldview. To the people who are just pissed at the results, you should be. Let’s take that anger and get back to the work of saving our country.
56
Will Marshall retweeted
Dear Democrats, You do NOT have a mandate to go woke and give your extreme base whatever they want. You are RENTING this coalition. You do not yet own this coalition. Don't make the same mistakes Trump made after winning in 2024. Govern accordingly washingtonsun.com/perspectiv…
81
158
21
972
90,866
turns out it's much easier to win when you're not wasting time putting up blockers
VoteHub: Jonathan Kreiss-Tomkins wins Alaska’s gubernatorial race 🟦Democratic flip
86
Will Marshall retweeted
So proud of Gina, so proud of James, so proud of Texas!
2,804
17,059
1,356
177,596
2,463,983
Will Marshall retweeted
El Sayed (+6.5) Talarico (+23.7) One of these is not like the other.
Projected swing towards the Democrats relative to 2024 presidential results: Texas +23.7 North Carolina +23.2 Rhode Island +23.2 South Carolina +22.4 Mississippi +22.1 New Jersey +21.2 Kansas +21.0 West Virginia +20.8 Georgia +20.2 Louisiana +20.2 Alabama +19.5 New Mexico +19.0 Arkansas +18.6 Kentucky +18.5 Tennessee +17.6 Virginia +17.2 Iowa +17.0 Ohio +16.3 Oklahoma +16.3 Colorado +15.0 Delaware +12.3 Wyoming +11.8 New Hampshire +11.2 Illinois +11.1 South Dakota +10.2 Florida +10.1 Nebraska +9.5 Michigan +6.5 Massachusetts +5.8 Minnesota +4.5 Maine -3.3
260
211
49
3,793
302,765