the asian diaspora has indeed debased itself. no longer can we allow ourselves to play such roles. in fact we need some kind of self-strengthening movement
A few days ago I wrote about how the Asian diaspora in the west have a tradition of debasing themselves.
I even considered writing about how we perpetuate the “Asians are good at math” stereotype ourselves but thought that was too on the nose.
86
zohran the king of spin! psychopathic liar
Replying to @taliaotg
I don’t fully understand mentioning ban on teargas (NYPD has never used teargas, on protestors or otherwise) and long guns and limits on LRAD. NYPD has *been* prohibited from using the LRAD’s sound cannon feature (Edrei v City of New York). It’s been banned since 2021
10
511
if you tried this and found that there were no active struggles and the bourgeoisie, the bureaucratic elite, the landowners, the ""subaltern groups"", and everyone else were apathetically sitting around in their own shit then i would concede the passive rev thesis is good enough
21
it would then follow from this that the coalitional forces represented by the post-47 state were engaged in active struggles to maintain the stability of capital accumulation. then you would have to work out how these struggles shaped the development of the state and the economy
1
20
my own inclination is to say that the indian state is more like other 'normal' capitalist states than it is not. theories of states should prob not be derived from their histories but rather from (1) the logic of capital and (2) the spatial economic structure of the world economy
2
41
is the logic of the indian state derived from this historical narrative? what is it about the indian state that means it can't be recaptured by a diff coalition or by a single class? is this the same in other countries?
1
40
Replying to @ShinMarginalScr @ClimateGaliev
i understand that this is the historical narrative. i think it is pretty plausible as a broad strokes narrative of south asian history as a whole. what i am dissatisfied is the end point, whether its 1952 or 64 or 75 or w/e. what is the logic of the indian state?
1
42
throwback to when i had 饢 in xi'an it blew my mind. david ludden global asia the silk road is real, its out there
1
7
327
and they've uncritically laundered a hazy reflection of the maoist theory of new democracy (which, lets be real, is not a very good theory by academic standards and really only worked that one time in extremely improbable circumstances) into a theory of bad colonial hangover
2
40
Replying to @ShinMarginalScr @ClimateGaliev
ok setting aside the first two, break down the third for me, if you feel like it. i think it sounds right but i want to know what the justification is
1
1
78
Replying to @ShinMarginalScr @ClimateGaliev
yeah but thats not really satisfying imo, even if on its face it seems like an accurate description. like what are status groups? why do they exist? why are they kept in a permanent stalemate? i'm blackpilled too but i don't think being blackpilled can be the whole theory
1
1
108
to dipesh or whoever downstream, they have forgotten that the implicit comparison is not europe
1
2
47
to some extent. but i think a lot of the rest of this stuff is sort of unconscious. passive revolution as a theory is that there was a failure to do a national revolution and have either a proper proletariat/bourgeois coalition. which is what china did. but by the time you get
1
2
42
Replying to @ClimateGaliev @left_plain
i would guess that cpi and cpm are probably in the same boat now. maybe they weren't back then, though i confess idk if i've ever read a CPI theorist on like any question. but i mean the subaltern studies guys. i think guha knows what he's doing and partha i assume must also
1
2
25
Replying to @left_plain @ClimateGaliev
yeah i need to read more theory on the class formation side
1
25










