Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter) header
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter) profile picture

"Female is real and it is sex, and femininity is unreal and it is gender." Germaine Greer (Channel 4 2018) We are sexed bodies. All the rest is personality.

Through the looking glass
Joined March 2015
Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)Photo by Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ (@socksknitter)
A truly magnificent speech by Councillor Sarah Field at the Declaration of Sex Based Rights at Leeds Civic Hall. "If your feminism prioritises the internal identifications of men over the material conditions of women then you are not a feminist." mumsnet.com/Talk/womens_righ…
5
20
1
87
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Woman of the Day — although it was a near thing — is Suffolk-born suffragette Ada Flatman (1876-1952) whose dry wit had me in stitches. A woman of independent means, she joined the Women’s Social and Political Union in 1907 and took the motto ‘Deeds, Not Words” to heart. “I am a very proud old suffragette. How did I become one? It was after attending a meeting in the Royal Horticultural Hall, Westminster. Christabel Pankhurst was the speaker. I saw a young girl in her early 20s giving out handbills at the door and [Christabel] came in and made a fighting speech telling how us how constitutional change had failed to catch up.” On 13 October 1908, the WSPU organised a ‘rush’ on the House of Commons. Ada volunteered without hesitation even though “For this, a warrant was issued for the arrest of Mrs Emmeline Pankhurst, Miss Christabel Pankhurst and Mrs Flora Drummond, the organiser. In the meantime, our treasurer Mrs Pethick-Lawrence took charge of things.” “We were immediately surrounded by a wall of the biggest policemen in the police force. I was told by a policeman to go back. I said no, it is my duty as an Englishwoman to see the prime minister. He said you cannot do that, put his hand on my shoulder and marched me off to Cannon Road Police Station. All of the other suffragettes were brought in. We were put in one small cell together, and…sat on the cold stone floor until midnight waiting for Mr Lawrence to come and bail us out. He had a hectic time going around all of the police stations bailing all of us out.” Ada described how Christabel Pankhurst decided to defend herself and, with her usual flair for publicity, called David Lloyd George, Chancellor of the Exchequer, and William Gladstone, the Foreign Secretary, as witnesses. They didn’t appear. Can’t think why. “The trial lasted a week. Each day we, turned up with suitcases expecting to be sent to prison. At last, the rank-and-file were put in the dock and it was my turn to speak. The magistrate said, ‘Ada Flatman, you are charged with obstructing the police. Have you anything to say?’ I said, ‘Yes, I did not obstruct the police. The police obstructed ME’. The magistrate said ‘You are fined 20 shillings or a month in prison’. I said ‘Prison!’ We all went down to the cells and were taken to Holloway in a black Maria [a police van for transporting prisoners].” She served a month and described the insouciance of the suffragettes when they saw the very basic conditions at Holloway. “The wardresses took our possessions from us and we had to take a bath in a very dirty old-fashioned bath. I only dipped in my toes…Emerging into a hall, there was a huge hamper filled with boots of all sizes. None of them fitted us at all. They were all heavy and thick. We looked so quaint with our caps and grey dresses with black arrows pointing upwards that we all shook with silent laughter.” In May 1909, the West Country suffragettes were planning to protest during a meeting between a Cabinet minister and the Chamber of Commerce in Bristol — barricades had been erected to keep these dangerous women out — but Ada had her own ideas. “Part of our policy was heckling cabinet ministers…I went to the first barricade and the speeches had just begun, so I [went upstairs] and pretended that I wanted to listen.” The detectives guarding the barricade were distracted by a pageboy bringing them mugs of beer. When he spilled some, this was exactly the kind of open goal Ada was looking for. “In a split second, I went to the barricade and shouted Votes for Women Taxpayers, scattering green, white and purple handbills over the diners below. They clapped and applauded me and cheered me. A hand was put over my mouth by a detective and I was dragged away to the lounge…Detectives rushed from every part of the building to the scene where I stood, then…[a man] shaking his head scolded all the detectives saying ‘Why did you let her do it?’ He was Chief of the Bristol detective police force and he said to me, ‘Ma’am, because of you I had to upbraid 300 of my men!’” In April 1911, Ada opened the very successful WSPU shop in Liverpool, selling literature, china and other merchandise such as handkerchiefs, badges and motoring scarves in the WSPU colours. The way she saw it, the shop’s windows served as very useful advertising space for the cause and in the first year, it raised £592 (nearly £60k in today’s money). On 20 July 1912, Ada resigned from the WSPU. Not just a woman of independent means but she had independent views too and by then, the WSPU had become increasingly authoritarian. She relocated to the United States in 1915 to become the advertising and business manager of The Suffragist, a paper produced by the Congressional Union for Woman Suffrage. Ada died in 1952, aged 75, after decades of dedication to the cause of women’s rights and having exercised fully her hard-won right to vote. “I knew I must be one of that valiant band.”
12
109
3
329
4,539
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Massive irony here from the UN. Apparently women & girls need safe toilets in order to participate fully in society. Yet @UN_Women insists crossdressing fetishist men should use women's toilets. So which is it? #WorldToiletDay2026 un.org/en/observances/toilet…
"World Toilet Day 2026 is about sanitation and gender equality. The campaign – ‘Safe toilets. Equal futures.’ – shows how safe sanitation protects women and girls’ health, safety, dignity and opportunity – enabling them to go to school, work and fully take part in society."
7
144
605
3,715
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
“According to the Cabinet Office, the Stonewall survey is the best available data. The reality is instead that the Stonewall survey provides the best available data on how likely people are to fabricate claims of conversion practices if it suits their goals.”
6
79
1
277
9,408
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
It's a significant flaw in the pro Conversion argument that they can't cite a single case, study or opinion from the police or CPS regarding a case where they were stuck for something to charge. The fact we are using Stonewall (lol) "evidence" is just ridiculous for legislation.
“According to the Cabinet Office, the Stonewall survey is the best available data. The reality is instead that the Stonewall survey provides the best available data on how likely people are to fabricate claims of conversion practices if it suits their goals.”
3
148
3
616
9,020
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Calling UK lawyers! Membership now open for the Sex & Gender Law Association For practising, academic & retired lawyers, judges, pupils & trainees SaGLA is non-partisan. You don't have to hold any particular view to join No joining fee (for now) 🔗 sagla.substack.com/p/join-th…
5
98
1
231
6,256
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Woman of the Day Karen Harrison, born OTD in 1960 in Glasgow, the UK’s first female train driver and the first woman to preside over an ASLEF conference. She endured ten years of sustained verbal and physical harassment from management and staff but refused to give up. In 1977, 17 year old Karen applied to British Rail to become a Secondman, the first step on the way to becoming a train driver. In those days, a Secondman assisted the driver of the train by operating the heating systems, shunting the train when required and generally assisting the driver. It was a sort of apprenticeship. They could learn by observation before sitting the drivers’ tests and exam. She proceeded to the interview stage but only because she’d applied as K. Harrison and British Rail thought she was a lad. When it realised its mistake, it tried to shunt her into the typing pool but she stood her ground. No, she said: train driver. The law was on her side. After all, this was 1977; the Sex Discrimination Act 1975 removed the barriers to women’s employment if they were otherwise suitable for the job. Then again, the law is also on the side of women and men who hold gender critical beliefs. It doesn’t stop them from being harassed, investigated for spurious reasons (“malicious communications”, anybody?) and even hounded out of their jobs, does it? The process is the punishment. But I digress… Karen started work at Old Oak Common, a traction maintenance depot west of Paddington, formerly used for storing and servicing locomotives. The unrelenting wave of misogyny started immediately. "Ten years of hell, ten years of heaven. It's a bit tough when you're only a teenager and you're hit by this gigantic tidal wave of hate. To a lot of the men, I was the proverbial turd in the swimming pool. Every day I walked into the mess room I'd be s***ting myself, but strutting about pretending not to be. I couldn't let them create no-go areas for me; that would've established a precedent and we couldn't have that, could we? It would've been the beginning of the end." There was next-to-no support from colleagues or management. Almost to a man, they didn’t want her there and they used every opportunity to ensure she knew it. “It was open warfare. People wouldn’t work with me, people put notes up about me, my locker was defaced. Graphic pornography went up in the mess rooms.” By people, Karen meant men of course. All of her harassers were big brave men, including some who probably prided themselves as respectable family men with wives and daughters. When I say “almost to a man”, there was an honourable exception however: the old-style Communists at the depot. “It was like being raised by wolves. They did a grand job, bless them." Ultimately, don’t mess with a Glaswegian. Karen overcame every single manmade obstacle thrown in her path and qualified as a train driver in 1979. She credited her resilience to her Scottish genes, “rich in stubbornness”. After her ten years of hell, Karen transferred to Marylebone and it must have been like emerging from the deep, dark forest into the light. A member of ASLEF, she earned a solid reputation with her fellow trade unionists, campaigned for improved conditions for women in the rail industry, and in 1995 was elected as lay member to preside over an ASLEF conference. A bout of meningitis put paid to Karen’s career as a train driver but she secured employment as a full-time officer for UNISON and represented members at employment tribunals (that was in the good old days of course when unions actually knew was a woman was). She never lost a case and her experience prompted her to study law at Oxford as a mature student. “It was hard, f****** hard, but it's easier than driving a trains for a living. It's hard to get too stressed about exams when you've experienced things like brake failure approaching a red signal, especially when you can see another train crossing the junction in front of you. I still miss the camaraderie of my mates in ASLEF. I miss them terribly. The folk at my college are the closest I've got to that old espirit de corps and they put up with an old bag like me with great stoicism." Karen was due to graduate in May 2011 — her plan was to work as a barrister specialising in labour law and human rights — but she died a matter of weeks before her 50th birthday. Today, just 6.5% of train drivers are women but there is a touching tribute to Karen at Euston Station: a giant mural encouraging more women to apply. Meanwhile, her old union UNISON, whose membership is 70% female, continues to insist that blokes in dresses are women too, and its leadership has described gender critical views as misinformation, aligned with far-right tactics to restrict single-sex spaces to just women. I think I can guess what Karen Harrison would have to say about that, but those women (and men) who are trying to restore sanity to their union from within might be heartened by her words. “I never wanted to be pushed out. I knew if I’d left the railway, I’d have let these people win and what was happening was wrong and it wasn’t fair.”
18
131
2
396
5,027
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
The Women of the Day are Sophia Jex-Blake, Mary Pechey, Isabel Thorne, Matilda Chaplin, Helen Evans, Mary Anderson and Emily Bovell, known as the Edinburgh Seven, who had to face down a mob of rioting male students at the University of Edinburgh OTD in 1870 trying to prevent them from sitting their anatomy exams. The University’s special treatment of women began the previous year when Sophia Jex-Blake applied to study medicine. It was an all-male preserve and tried to stop her, claiming it couldn’t possibly be expected to make arrangements for “just one lady” so she advertised in newspapers for other women to join her. Mary Pechey responded straightaway, followed by the other five. “Do you think anything more is requisite to ensure success than moderate abilities and a good share of perseverance? I believe I may lay claim to these, together with a real love of the subjects of study…” The University had no choice but to admit them so it thought of another cunning wheeze. It announced it would charge them more than men for attending the same classes. The Seven paid. Sophia actually tutored the other six in mathematics. The real trouble started when the women came top of the class, making four of them eligible for a prestigious scholarship on the basis of their stellar results. The University promptly awarded the scholarships to four men with lower marks. Under the influence of some of the professors, faculty staff who had initially supported the women began to back off. Male students began treating them with open contempt, slamming doors in their faces, crowding into seats that they usually sat in, bursting into "horse laughs and howls" whenever the women approached. Sophia said: “What means were used in the interim I cannot say, or what influence was brought to bear: but I do know that from that day the conduct of the students was utterly changed, that those who had hitherto been quiet and courteous became impertinent and offensive…It was as if a conspiracy had been formed to make our position as uncomfortable as might be". Her doorbell was wrenched off, her nameplate damaged five times, fireworks were attached to her door. The rest of the Seven had smoke blown in their faces and filthy letters sent to them. They were waylaid in quiet streets. Obscenities and insults like “whore” were shouted at them in public. (Does that sound familiar at all?) The women started taking precautions, walking around campus together as a group for safety, but events came to a head exactly 156 years ago today in what became known as the Surgeons’ Hall Riot. Sophia said, “On the afternoon of Friday 18th November 1870, we walked to the Surgeons’ Hall, where the anatomy examination was to be held. As soon as we reached the Surgeons’ Hall we saw a dense mob filling up the road…The crowd was sufficient to stop all the traffic for an hour. We walked up to the gates, which remained open until we came within a yard of them, when they were slammed in our faces by several young men…who stood within, smoking and passing about bottles of whisky while they abused us in the foulest possible language.” The women had managed to pick their way through the threatening crowd while several hundred men blocked their way, pelted mud and rubbish at them and shouted insults and threats only to find themselves trapped when the gates were slammed in their faces. They had to endure the hostility until a sympathetic student opened the gates for them. The women sat their exams and despite their ordeal, all of them passed, four with honours. Edith Pechey won first place over all of the candidates. None of that made the slightest bit of difference to the University. It denied all seven women their hard-won degrees. Some male students were shocked by the way they had been treated and escorted them back to their digs safely. For weeks after, those students acted as bodyguards, escorting them to and from classes. Despite the vocal support of Charles Darwin and 300 others, the Court of Sessions delivered the final blow and supported the University's right to refuse the women degrees. They also ruled, by a majority, that the women should never have been admitted in the first place. Five of the Seven had to go to Paris or Bern to qualify as doctors. Sophia Jex-Blake returned to Edinburgh in 1878 to set up practice as the city’s first woman doctor but that she considered that the case brought such unwelcome publicity for the University, it helped to pave the way for more to follow. “I believe that it was the seed sown in tears in Edinburgh that was reaped in joy elsewhere.”
39
280
26
713
11,947
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Even though I have tried to get used to Stonewall's betrayal of us homosexuals and bisexuals and especially lesbians it still pains me. How anyone who is gay or lesbian or just plain human can laugh at a joke about a reduced lesbian dating pool as a result of girls taking puberty blockers, testosterone and having double mastectomies makes me sick to the pit of my stomach. Depravity unleashed.
29
130
10
675
9,638
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
To our non-Jewish allies: If despite the trouble it causes you you’re standing up for Jews because you don’t like seeing Britain’s tiniest minority being bullied by a bunch of herd followers, thank you. The most interesting people refuse to follow the herd.
63
56
10
691
6,418
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Women managed it in the 1970s with no money and laws that were stacked against their financial & sexual agency. There are plenty of wealthy, powerful men who transition. Why not ask them for help? Stop expecting the rest of the world to nanny you.
Telling Trans people to just “make their own spaces” … the most marginalized underprivileged and underfunded group with lack of resources. Yall are way too comfortable with entitlement privilege and discrimination.
15
157
3
1,250
13,798
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Cass explains that the Bill treats something treating something - gender identity - as a stable belief, when it is actually something that, for many, is changeable. She points out that it is also something intrinsically very sidfficult and distsressing to discuss for young people and parents alike. It is not the same as sexual orientation.
4
93
3
581
30,761
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
In case there is any doubt, Labour MP Naz Shah asks, "do you support this Bill as drafted?" Cass says, "No"
1
86
4
626
12,117
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Asked whether the Bill could have a "chilling effect on whistleblowing" which was relied upon in the case of the Tavistock Gender identity Development Service (GIDS), Cass replies, "Yes".
1
42
1
375
6,105
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Next, Cass talks about how difficult the situation is now - before any legislation - for clinicians practising in an exploratory way. She mentions Dr Anna Hutchinson, who gave evidence to the committee last week. She has had to have security with her before when she’s given talks - "and that’s not normal in any area of medicine.”
1
48
1
387
7,255
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Cass gives another example she heard during her review of a mother who had been in an abusive relationship with husband. Daughter was going through anorexia and also had some medically unexplained symptoms. The father left the family home and the daughter began identifying as trans male. Mother tried to be supportive, but not using preferred pronouns. Father, who was very angry, reported her to social services for not supporting the gender transition. At time she spoke to Cass, it was 11 months into investigation by social services. "I think that was father being vexatious." But with the Bill he could just as easily report her to the police “people who are angry have the potential to do the wrong thing”. The qiestion is how we guard against that.
3
92
4
571
17,901
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Olivia Bailey, who originally introduced the Bill, asks whether clarity on certain points would help and allow Cass to continue to support a ban. Cass responds that "the devil is int he detail" and that she would need to see the text.
3
18
3
278
10,561
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
"I am still concerned because unfortunately, the polarisation is worse now than when we came out with report." Cass says it is “very clear that there are malign actors who feel that my report and the exploratory approach that I describe is conversion therapy – that’s what they label it as and I think there is definitely a wish to push back on the changes that have come about because of my review and this is potentially one way to undermine it.”
1
50
1
375
9,943
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Cass tells the committee that staff in four new NHS youth gender hubs are worried about real risk of vexatious compaints. "The issue is not so much you are found guilty, but the whole process of the inquiry”, she explains. "The hcillign effect isn’t theortetcial and it’s here today.”
4
56
508
10,801
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Cass says her second concern is for parents. While it is not the intent for them to be caught up by the Bill, “that is unavoidably the risk of the way the Bill is framed." She gives examples of parents not agreeing to change pronouns for child, or restricting money to deny them chance to buy a breast binder or hormones as being in reach of this Bill.
3
67
1
520
13,078
Kat 🟩⬜️🟪 Women Matter ♀️ retweeted
Baroness Hilary Cass tells committee considering draft Conversion practices Bill that she cannot support it as stands. She saw the Bill 15 mins before Gov wanted press statement signed off. "Having obviously spent a long time now thinking about it, I unfortunately I don't think it is anywhere near tight enough to avoid serious unintended consequences."
36
518
47
1,824
136,491