🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader) header
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader) profile picture

Reader. Multilingual. Culture Rich. Trivia. Geopolitics. Rashtra. Consulting. Gold. Music. Rare books collector 🎶 'स्मृतिभ्रंशाद् बुद्धिनाशो'|भगवद्गीता २.६३

Joined June 2009
Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)Photo by 🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 (@southvader)
I say 2026 - 2027. Modi will step aside mid term....Modi will be instrumental in setting up a monk as PM and go onto fulfil his own calling of being a monk. He took a political detour of 50+ yrs.
Yogi’s swearing-in has the look of a future #coronation. Modi chief guest, Shah & BJP state CMs in attendance. So too the heads of Birla, Ambani, Mahindra & Tata groups. #2029?
1
8
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Indians’ tendency to place themselves above the larger public good is reflected in the way exporters, importers & traders have for years pushed INR down by hedging. After RBI introduced a 20% deposit for derivatives currency hedgers under Foreign Exchange Risk Reserve (FERR) on October 10, INR has gained 4% against USD. Oil prices helped but it was the #FERR slap on rupee bears that did the job. Some Indians put personal profit above public good.
14
95
1
315
16,565
பூர்வ ஜென்ம வாசனை!🫡🫡 பேஷ், பேஷ் 😃😃
I definitely have some Karmic connection with Tamil Nadu, apart from the more obvious marital one. I get a lot of online hate from the Dravidian hatemongers, but in Tamil Nadu, I have received nothing but love and respect, even in the smallest of towns. They laugh at my attempts to speak Tamil, but always always go out of their way to help.
9
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Not arguing about Sikhi merits whether it is Hindu or not. Irrelevant to need to dialog and then dialog takes it wherever ppl want. Bad idea to impose preconditions. What is need is closing ranks in the face of common threats.
2
1
8
499
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Hello @HarmeetKDhillon, I am sorry to hear of the racism & bigotry you faced in MAGA. I have a few questions: 1. Could you please clarify your position on Khalistan? Since some ppl insinuate you on this, it’s better to ask you directly rather than speculate. 2. Has your position changed after MAGA targeted Sikhs? 3. Do you think it’s better for Sikhs to stop supporting Khalistan and join hands with Hindus in addressing common threats? As a prominent Sikh leader, your voice matters; hence I would appreciate your clarity on this. Thanks and wishing you the very best. Background: I was a member of the late Pujya Swami Dayananda Saraswati’s initiatives for dialogues with other religious leaders. We held numerous summits with leaders of Jews, Orthodox Christians, and Buddhists. I wonder why there has been no sincere effort at a Hindu-Sikh Summit.
58
198
16
845
44,826
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Yesterday, my group of 22 ladies bought 56 handloom sarees from ThiCo, the Thirubhuvanam Weavers Co-op. That’s a billing of 9 lakh plus, in one evening. The staff and the weavers were ecstatic. This is how local economy thrives! @tntourismoffcl #TamizhTrails @TVKVijayHQ
51
371
4
2,597
42,482
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Replying to @nickcollins1953
Nick, your sea route makes beautiful sense, and the tradition offers a hint of its own. Valmiki taught the Ramayana to Lava and Kusha, who sang it as they wandered, and so the tradition says their names became the word for travelling bards, kushilava. The Ramayana was born to travel. Bards went wherever the ships and caravans went, and the katha is still sung at the dhuni today. Reading your books has been a joy.
2
8
82
3,480
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
I firmly disagree with your AIT premise as well as the premise that Greek epics influenced Indian. The facts are opposite. The evidence is overwhelming in support of Indian origin. I, too, am against those who valorize the past on the basis that: older is superior. That downplays the role of advancement and freezes a civilization in a museum. It undermines the role of smritis as vehicles for fresh development. However, that is a separate debate for a separate thread and should not hijack this one. The purpose of this thread is to show how I am using the Ramayana film as a door opener here in USA. Have held meaningful discussions in school/college settings in classics studies, to open and expand them with Indian classics. Getting a seat at the table is happening in the few cases where I pushed this strategy. It’s NOT about who is superior, but about giving young minds diverse ideas to consider. So far, Ram beats Odysseus in these small casual settings - as king, human role model. One topic that emerged spontaneously from the students: What if the US were run on similar principles? This makes the Ramayana a relevant socio political contribution to American society. But I don’t want to push the politics prematurely, until the topic of Ramayana is in the door, and then all sides should participate as equals. Mutual respect has brought my fragile efforts some humble success. The biggest threat is not the white folks, but those stupidly closed minded Hindus who can’t think strategically. Jai Shri Ram!
This is an important essay from @RajivMessage that is well-worth reading. As an academic, though, I raise the question: assuming that the two epics shared a common origin, was its original "Aryan" morality more Greek or more Hindu? I suspect that the underlying oral tradition was closer to the Greek, and that the Ramayana's Dharmic elements came primarily from the civilizing influence of the native Bharatiyas who first wrote it down. And yes, with apologies to my Twitter audience and politically-correct modern-day scholars, I do accept that the "Aryan invasion theory" is fundamentally correct.
31
156
4
653
86,172
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Ramayana is a wonderful movie. Enjoyed it thoroughly. Meant for mainstream audiences, making a good impact. Sets a new standard for Hindu films. I can find issues with it, as with anything else, but this is a solid professional job on a complex topic. This will become a classic that people will watch during Diwali season for many years to come.
32
353
137
2,486
150,714
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
At the fag end of the film when Jatayu is dying, Rama asks "Yeh Lanka kis aur hai?". That hits you like a million bolts of lightning! Unlike Lord Krishna's consciousness which is fully aware since the very birth, Prabhu Ram is an unaware Avatar of Vishnu and this matters so much for the universe of Ramayan. Just the sheer scale of absurdity in that contrast between Dharma and Adharma is so heart wrenching. Rama is not even a powerful prince now, he and his wife are living in a small hut in Vanavasa when a sophisticated flying Pushpaka comes to the forest and Kidnaps Sita. What can you even do as a husband? He doesn't even know who has done it and where has she disappeared to. All his life he has been questioning what his Bhagya is and every element of Dharma is leading him on. You feel so sad for him - the human avatar of him - for he has been chosen to fight in a battle between Devatas and Asuras without even being told so explicitly. This is where the complication really exists, for Ram cannot be consciously aware of him being a form of Vishnu because then it would bar him from killing the immortal Ravana; he has to exist as a simple human and accomplish the task. For most Indians, experiencing Ramayana has always been through the prism of annual Ram Leela which is played across literally millions of villages, galis and streets of this nation since time immemorial. Frankly, and I am aware that this might not be a very popular opinion (especially among the nationalists), Ranbeer Kapoor's essay of Rama is among the top 1 percentile of all enactments of Ramayana everywhere. Yash as Ravana might be colourful, menacing and even a powerful presence on the screen with complexity in character formation, but Ranbeer's fight with destiny to evolve into a man who is united with the cosmos when he declares "I will fight the most powerful man in the 3 Lokas if that is what I have to do" is the perfect high on which it ends. Adharma can have all the gadgetory of a Pushpaka, but Dharma now has the faith of Rama and that is enough to change the equation forever.
54
246
30
1,208
100,586
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Replying to @BabonesBhai
The wrong question. Call it whatever, focus on its meaning(s). Note the plural meaningS. By focusing on naming, many people divert away from the profundity. What are the first principles that are common to all views? Where do views differ and on what axiomatic basis? What are the methodologies for self discovery of the first principles? You will discover that mere text crunching is insufficient; the journey requires dedicated practice. I suggest you get initiated in a serious meditation practice (not self taught or picked up from some influencer). Good luck.
11
12
168
5,326
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Something I told a friend: Indians (and especially Hindu Indians) are the targets of a highly literate Western class that despises them. I came to India with no preconceived notions; only an open mind and curiosity. Few other Western intellectuals seem to take the same approach.
130
377
14
2,292
74,738
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Twelve months without a single CRPF operational fatality, the first such stretch in 47 years. This deserves far more attention, including from economists. I consider it as worthy of attention as major poverty-reduction milestones. I hope our armed forces achieve the same. India attracts investment and sustains international trade despite substantial gaps in infrastructure and human capital. We severely underestimate the economic value of the internal and external security India provides. Our security forces do more than protect lives. They safeguard the stability that supports investment, trade and the productive use of remittances. In an increasingly conflict-ridden world, I am confident that credible deterrence and strategic autonomy will help India stand out and reap substantial economic benefits. The North versus South debate often misses this shared asset. Every state benefits from belonging to a country capable of defending itself, rather than depending on a foreign “big brother” for protection. That benefit does not appear in state-wise tax-and-transfer calculations, but ignoring it makes the accounting incomplete. National security is not separate from economic development. It is one of its foundations. We count the cost of defence far more readily than the prosperity it protects.
3
44
7
151
5,361
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Now that the poverty numbers have been accepted globally, here’s another common question from critics: If poverty has fallen so dramatically, why do 80 crore Indians receive food subsidies? Because social protection is not the same as poverty alleviation! Public social spending (% of GDP): 🇫🇮 Finland: 31.4% 🇩🇰 Denmark: 26.4% 🇸🇪 Sweden: 26.1% 🇳🇴 Norway: 24.1% 🇬🇧 UK: 23% India spends just 0.6% on food subsidies. A welfare state is not merely a poverty-relief programme. #ViksitBharat🇮🇳
157
983
48
3,522
95,696
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Replying to @LSinghShekhawat
लोकेन्द्र सिंह, समोसे का पासपोर्ट और जलेबी का वीज़ा ढूँढते-ढूँढते तुम्हारा इतिहास का ज्ञान कहाँ मर गया? भारत ने दुनिया को क्या दिया? चलो, तुम्हारी अधूरी शिक्षा पूरी करते हैं। 1. काली मिर्च - केरल के पश्चिमी घाट की देन। सदियों से अंतरराष्ट्रीय मसाला व्यापार का प्रमुख आधार। 2. छोटी इलायची - दक्षिण भारत के पश्चिमी घाट की मूल उपज, आज दुनिया भर की मिठाइयों और पेय पदार्थों में इस्तेमाल। 3. हल्दी - भारत में कम-से-कम 2,500 वर्षों से इस्तेमाल, बाद में दुनिया के अनेक क्षेत्रों तक पहुँची। 4. क्रिस्टलीय चीनी - गन्ना भारत में पैदा नहीं हुआ था, लेकिन उसके रस से चीनी के क्रिस्टल बनाने की तकनीक प्राचीन भारत में विकसित हुई। दुनिया के चीनी उद्योग के इतिहास का बड़ा अध्याय! 5. कटहल - वनस्पति विज्ञान के अनुसार दक्षिण-पश्चिम भारत की मूल उपज। 6. आम - इसका मूल क्षेत्र असम, पूर्वी हिमालय और आसपास का दक्षिण-एशियाई इलाका है। 7. सहजन (Moringa) - उत्तर-पश्चिम भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप की मूल वनस्पति, आज दुनिया के कई उष्णकटिबंधीय देशों में उगाई जाती है। 8. कोकम - पश्चिमी और दक्षिण-पश्चिमी भारत की मूल उपज। 9. उड़द - भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप में विकसित प्राचीन दलहनी फसल। 10. मूंग - भारतीय उपमहाद्वीप से म्यांमार तक के क्षेत्र की प्राचीन फसल। 11. खिचड़ी - चावल-दाल की भारतीय परंपरा का उल्लेख प्राचीन ऐतिहासिक विवरणों में मिलता है। इब्न बतूता ने भी इसका वर्णन किया। 12. डोसा - भारतीय पाक परंपरा में इसका लिखित उल्लेख कम-से-कम 12वीं शताब्दी से मिलता है। अब तुम्हारी पोस्ट की मूर्खता भी सुनो। राजमा पुर्तगालियों की खोज नहीं है। उसकी मूल फसल अमेरिका की है। पुर्तगाली उसके भारत पहुँचने के माध्यमों में से एक थे। फसल की उत्पत्ति और उसे लाने वाले में फर्क होता है गोभी को फारस, यूक्रेन और पश्चिम एशिया से एक साथ आयात कर दिया! फूलगोभी के विकास का इतिहास मुख्यतः पूर्वी भूमध्यसागरीय क्षेत्र से जुड़ा है। कोई भी देश जोड़कर इतिहास नहीं लिखा जाता। और मान लिया कि समोसे, जलेबी या नान के पीछे विदेशी प्रभाव हैं। तो क्या हुआ? हर महान खाद्य संस्कृति व्यापार, प्रवास और स्थानीय प्रयोग से विकसित हुई है। तुम्हारी अक्ल के हिसाब से इटली का टमाटर भी विदेशी है, तो पिज़्ज़ा इतालवी नहीं रहा! टमाटर मूलतः अमेरिका से आया था। सात विदेशी संबंध गिनाकर हजारों वर्षों की भारतीय खाद्य संस्कृति को उधार का साबित करने निकले थे। उल्टा अपनी ऐतिहासिक निरक्षरता का सार्वजनिक प्रदर्शन कर बैठे। समस्या यह नहीं कि भारत ने दुनिया को क्या दिया। समस्या यह है कि दुनिया ने तुम्हें जानकारी हासिल करने के इतने साधन दिए, फिर भी तुमने अज्ञानता को चुना। अगली बार भारत का इतिहास लिखने से पहले किताब खोल लेना। हर चीज़ पर राय देना जरूरी नहीं, खासकर जब जानकारी समोसे की बाहरी परत जितनी पतली हो। सात व्यंजनों का इतिहास पढ़कर सात हजार वर्षों की सभ्यता का मूल्यांकन करने चले हो। इतना आत्मविश्वास अगर ज्ञान के साथ होता, तो पोस्ट मजाक नहीं बनती।
6
3
53
7,595
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Qualifications of @nsitharaman: BA (Economics) MA (Economics) MPhil (Economics) Assistant to Economist, AEA, UK Senior Manager, BBC Senior Manager, Price Waterhouse Commerce Minister, India Defence Minister, India Finance Minister, India Qualifications of @RahulGandhi: Dynast
2,123
8,972
357
36,953
942,928
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
According to the World Bank, close to 50 crore Indians moved above its lower-middle-income poverty line between 2011–12 and 2023–24. China’s achievement of lifting approximately 80 crore people out of extreme poverty became central to the global scholarly understanding of its rise. India’s achievement, comparable in its enormous human scale, risks becoming a headline that disappears after a few days. The contrast is surprising, particularly because the way India achieved this deserves sustained examination. I have heard scholars invoke China’s poverty reduction as an indirect excuse for its one-party dictatorship. Those scholars should pay particular attention to India’s progress while retaining a vibrant democracy, competitive elections and political opposition. Indian voters demand both liberty and prosperity. Economic performance does not give governments an unrestricted licence to curtail freedoms. The Emergency illustrates this: despite growth of approximately 9% in 1975–76 and stronger industrial production during the Emergency years, voters removed the government in 1977. Economic gains could not secure acceptance of authoritarian rule. Political arrogance is costly in a system where citizens retain the power to dismiss their rulers. Equally, democratic credentials do not excuse economic mismanagement. Governments face electoral punishment for inflation, declining purchasing power and failure to create economic opportunities. Liberty and prosperity are therefore not freely exchangeable in India. Voters impose minimum expectations on both. Success in one does not automatically compensate for failure in the other. These constraints can make policy change slower and political negotiation more demanding. But they also create mechanisms for correction before failure threatens the legitimacy of the entire political system. Citizens can replace the government while preserving the system through which they hold it accountable. That makes development more durable. India’s poverty reduction deserves to become a serious subject of global scholarship, not a passing news item. The achievement matters. The democratic conditions under which it occurred matter just as much.
9
44
2
141
7,615
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
(1) To be rich is glorious. (2) It is my deep desire to see India rich. (3) It is my dispassionate deduction that India will be rich. Subconsciously (2) [activism] can impact (3) [analysis], but I wrote a book to make sure it doesn’t. [Of course those who disagree with (1) are not an insignificant section. Mostly they tend to be a segment of the old elite in one way or the other.] Writing close to 6-digit relatively deeply researched words takes away a lot of, what the kids call, hopium and copium. But you be the judge of that. Soon. #LongIndia
10
54
1
321
8,850
Applying this list could fill a life with meaning, purpose and then some. Let's get India back to where it belongs. Koti, koti naman!
🇮🇳 What can India learn from its diverse cultures? Learn civic sense from the Northeast. Business from Gujaratis & Marwaris. Research and innovation from South Indians. Sports and physical endurance from North Indians. Hard work, resilience & survival from UP and Bihar. Every region has something to teach us. If I missed your culture, please mention it in the comments! 🇮🇳💬
23
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
Went to the salon after ages. Every other client there was decking up for #KarwaChauth2026. Youngest was in her late twenties maybe, oldest was 70 plus. Full mehendi and all. When I complimented them, they all blushed like new brides. It was beautiful to see. Let the haters hate. P.S - I don’t celebrate Karwa Chauth because it is not a tradition where I come from. As simple as that.
35
256
4
2,655
59,541
🇮🇳 R. Vinayakan Aiyër 🇮🇳 retweeted
I feel honored to have met Mr. Mohammed Rehmat Pasha, a true Indian Hyderabadi hero who saved more than a dozen lives last year on Bondi Beach. While others fled danger, he pushed forward to help. A man of dignified quiet greatness.
29
100
2
764
9,367