Abdi Zihaul (@zhlbd) header
Abdi Zihaul (@zhlbd) profile picture

Research Fellow at @HarvardGrwthLab | economic growth, trade, innovation, industrial development | MPA/ID @harvard & econ @univ_indonesia.

Indonesia
Joined August 2012
Good morning with good news: Renewables' share of global electricity surges to 50% in 2035 from 33% in 2025 reports IEA in World Energy Outlook 2026! RE plus nuclear generate 60% by 2035. Solar generates 20% & wind 15% by 2035. Solar jumps 3.5 times! iea.org/reports/world-energy…
5
23
108
2,163
Abdi Zihaul retweeted
Real pictures of Harvard
26
101
19
1,589
106,875
Abdi Zihaul retweeted
Put the same PhD student in a small lab and in a powerhouse lab at Stanford, MIT or the Broad Institute, and you are basically running two different careers. In a top lab, money is rarely the first constraint. You have better equipment, better datasets, stronger collaborators, experienced postdocs, grant support, and people around you who already know exactly what a Nature, Science, Cell, NeurIPS or CVPR paper is supposed to look like. Look at the Broad Institute. It has entire genomics, proteomics, imaging and genetic-perturbation platforms built to support projects that a normal university lab could never run alone. Feng Zhang isn’t just “a very smart professor” — he sits at the intersection of MIT, Broad, McGovern and HHMI. That ecosystem matters. Same in AI. Fei-Fei Li didn’t build ImageNet in isolation in somebody’s basement. She was operating inside the Stanford AI ecosystem, surrounded by elite students, collaborators and an institution built to turn ambitious ideas into major projects. MIT CSAIL is another absurd example: around 1,800 researchers and a research budget of roughly $65 million a year. A PhD student entering that environment is not starting from the same line as someone in a five-person lab fighting for GPU hours and begging for travel money. Of course talent still matters. Hard work still matters. But academia loves pretending everyone is competing on the same track. They’re not. Some students spend three years figuring out how the game works. Others enter a lab where the game manual, the coaches, the equipment and half the winning team are already sitting in the room. If you seriously want an academic career, choosing the lab may be one of the highest-leverage decisions you ever make.
33
173
16
1,668
140,863
Meeting @ricardo_hausman in his office. Discussed about Indonesia’s strategy in nickel, comparisons with policymaking in the past, and Indonesia’s new sovereign wealth funds and their role for industrial policy. Thank you for connecting us! @zhlbd 😁
2
29
1,231
Genuine question: kalau putusan MA soal suket implikasinya Gibran tidak memenuhi syarat menjabat wapres, bukankah artinya paslon 02 sebenarnya tidak pernah memenuhi syarat sebagai peserta pilpres, dan penyelenggaraan pilpres cacat hukum dan perlu diulang? belum nemu yg jelasin.
54
1,492
41
5,217
96,642
ok lgsg nemu tp gak ada norma tuh maksudnya apa
dalam pengetahuan saya yang terbatas, sayangnya, secara normatif, jawabannya ngga. 1. Memang, Pasal 169 UU No. 7 Tahun 2017 mengatur syarat calon Presiden/Wapres. Selama masih pada fase pencalonan, ketidakpenuhan syarat dapat berujung pada gugurnya status "paket" calon. 2. Setelah pelantikan, statusnya sebagai Presiden atau Wakil Presiden berada dalam rezim konstitusional berdasarkan UUD NRI 1945. 3. Hanya saja, di dalam konstitusi kita, tidak ada norma yang menyatakan bahwa jika setelah menjabat diketahui syaratnya tidak terpenuhi, maka Presiden dan Wakil Presiden otomatis kehilangan jabatan atau wajib mundur berdua. 4. Yang ada, jika terbukti terjadi pelanggaran hukum sebagaimana dimaksud Pasal 7A UUD NRI 1945, fakta tersebut dapat menjadi dasar untuk proses pemberhentian melalui mekanisme DPR, MK, dan MPR sebagaimana Pasal 7B UUD NRI 1945.
1
1
42
12,356
Update Super El Nino: semakin meningkat hampir sentuh level 3°C, super El Nino bahkan diprediksi dapat melampaui 4°C. Hal ini cukup rasional, karena pemanasan tertinggi masih terkonsentrasi di timur Pasifik dengan suhu melampaui 5°C. Ini menandakan panas belum sepenuhnya terdistribysi dan ditransfer ke barat. Fix, tahun depan peluangnya tinggi kita akan mengalami musim kemarau dalam kondisi masih El Nino kuat. Inilah lagi-lagi, pertama kalinya dalam sejarah super El Nino, intensitas akan melampaui 4°C. Tetaplah waspada denga. Potensi Karhutla di Kalimantan dan Papua, karena dua daerah ini adalah hotspot terkuat selama El Nino.
The latest ECMWF update has interestingly shifted its forecast El Niño peak (+4.1°C) one month later to January. This likely owes to relentless westerly wind forcing that continues to shift warm water eastward across the Pacific. El Niño's impacts will extend well into 2027.
33
654
58
1,365
44,188
Nike's 6-page ad in today's NYT's 24-page special section for the New York City Marathon 26 (that has a list of names of all participants). The first-person narrative makes it both intimate and engaging to read!
3
43
13
858
117,900
Abdi Zihaul retweeted
This is one of the most important pieces of social science on human and AI interaction that I’ve seen in some time. Experts follow agentic advice the vast majority of the time (causally), but only a tiny fraction credit the agent—majority think they came to decision on their own volition. Reminds me of the classic Nisbett and Wilson study on people following outside influence without realizing it “ But as more work is handed to AI—including AI safety research—these judgment calls are the main levers for people's own values to influence outcomes. If people defer to AI without noticing, then "human in the loop" might provide less assurance than people expect.”
New Anthropic research: How AI agents shape experts' judgment calls When experts delegate work to an agent, do they still make the key decisions? We tested this in a randomized trial with 50 professional data analysts.
67
309
31
1,939
158,582
Abdi Zihaul retweeted
I found footage of 20yo Dario Amodei speaking against the Iraq War in 2003. 18 years before Anthropic even existed
271
623
235
8,977
1,660,150
The post goes through how each box in the flowchart matters, how TAI changes it, and what firms and countries stuck there can do. The flowchart is inspired by the growth diagnostics work of @ricardo_hausman, @rodrikdani, and @AndresVelasco. First we look into the revenue part:
1
1
1
73
Ini definisi “lu gak diajak” - konsekuensi doubling down on resource-based industrialization? Indonesia padahal punya capabilities di Electronics/Electrical Equipment yg adjacent dgn AI infrastructure & hardware. Sekarang giliran ada historical boom, kita cuma nonton.
Indonesia doesn't seem riding the AI wave: Indonesia's exports of AI-enabling goods to the world is negligible, compared to Vietnam, Malaysia, or Thailand. Read more: worldbank.org/en/publication…
1
3
2
406
Kamboja aja masih ikut kebagian kue. Bulan Agustus lalu mengunjungi perusahaan Hong Kong di Kamboja yg kebanjiran pesanan kabel optik dari US buat data centers: asia.nikkei.com/business/tec…
1
166
Indonesia doesn't seem riding the AI wave: Indonesia's exports of AI-enabling goods to the world is negligible, compared to Vietnam, Malaysia, or Thailand. Read more: worldbank.org/en/publication…
2
11
1
33
1,794
We’re Hiring Industrial Policy Lab Indonesia (IPL Indonesia) is looking for researchers to join our three research groups: Macroeconomics, Trade, and Structural Transformation (MTS) • Lead Researcher (Economist) • Research Analyst Industry, Technology, and Productive Capabilities (ITP) • Lead Researcher (Industry Specialist) • Research Analyst Energy Transition and Green Industrialization (E&G) • Lead Researcher (Energy Specialist) • Research Analyst If you’re interested in contributing to rigorous, policy-relevant research on Indonesia’s reindustrialization agenda, we’d love to hear from you. Jakarta, Indonesia Application deadline: 9 October 2026 For full responsibilities, qualifications, preferred experience, and application details, scan the QR code or visit the link provided in the post
4
52
8
329
21,372
Abdi Zihaul retweeted
New essay on @alexolegimas's blog: Will AI Soon Deliver Double-Digit Growth? Probably not. Here is why. aleximas.substack.com/p/will… 1. We outline the economics behind oft-discussed predictions that AI will soon deliver double-digit GDP growth in advanced economies. We list the assumptions that need to all hold in order for double-digit growth to happen and explain why we think they won’t. 2. To be clear: we are extremely bullish on AI and think the capabilities explosion predicted by technologists is already happening (e.g. yesterday's Navier-Stokes news!). But predictions of GDP growth in the 2030s of 15%, 30% or even 100% per year are off the mark. What we take issue with is the timeline. To paraphrase Milton Friedman's dictum on monetary policy, AI will affect GDP growth with "long and variable lags." 3. Start with some growth rate arithmetic. It is often much more useful to first think in levels rather than growth rates. Ask yourself: how much richer will we be in, say, 15 years? If you think twice as rich, that implies 4.7% annual growth, which would already be massive. Ten times as rich requires 16.6% per year; it would also imply that we are 100 times as rich 30 years from now! Asked in levels, we bet that most people would come up with much lower growth rates. 4. It's important to be clear: there is absolutely nothing in standard growth theory that constrains growth rates to be in the single digits. In fact, it's pretty easy to write down theoretical models that deliver explosive double-digit growth. We show this by writing down a standard textbook growth model of the type we routinely teach our undergrads (a souped-up Solow model), plug in some seemingly innocuous parameter values, and get AI-driven double-digit growth by the mid-2030s benjaminmoll.com/task_based_…. The basic logic is that, by replacing labor with capital, automation alleviates / eliminates diminishing returns and removes labor as a bottleneck on growth. Fancier models, in which AI also automates R&D, deliver even wilder numbers. 5. But just because something is possible in theory doesn't mean it will happen in practice. The explosion rests on five assumptions, and each is unlikely to hold within the next 10-15 years. These assumptions are: Assumption 1: Fast, economy-wide automation, with machines doing two thirds of all tasks by 2035. Historically, automation has proceeded at about 2% of tasks per year. Most work is physical, not cognitive. And politics will slow things down. Assumption 2: People keep spending on whatever gets automated. They don't. As things get cheap, their share of spending falls, as it did for agriculture and manufacturing. Messy jobs, relational goods and scarce physical inputs like energy, chips and land become the new bottlenecks. Assumption 3: Someone buys the new output and firms invest to produce it. Automation shifts income from workers to capital owners, who spend a smaller share so demand may not keep up with supply. Assumption 4: No AI-driven cyber incidents destroying economic value. AI can also destroy output, and every incident slows deployment and investment. Assumption 5: Explosive technology growth because AI automates R&D. The wildest scenarios in which the economy doubles each year all rest on this feedback loop. There is no evidence for it so far. Why do many people who are closest to the technology (and who have been consistently right about the capabilities explosion) consistently predict double-digit growth? Our best guess: they extrapolate from their own sector to the rest of the economy. This reminds me of the 2022 German gas debate: industry insiders were right about their own firms and very wrong about the economy as a whole. Our bottom line: a much more likely outcome is a large increase in the level of GDP spread over a decade or two, which is what 4-5% growth is. If you remain unconvinced and still believe in double-digit growth, we are still looking for counterparties for our bet benjaminmoll.com/growth_bet/ 😃
16
104
23
343
140,133
This is totally *new* to me. Remaja di Indonesia tenyata terjebak aspiration trap akut.
Anak-anak Indonesia kompetensi dasarnya masih jelek dan cenderung nggak percaya Sains. Bisa goal-setting dan mau help-seeking, tapi gak merasa dapet support orang tua. Curious tapi growth mindsetnya rendah gapercaya bisa jadi lebih baik. Pun bisa jadi lebih baik, mereka gak percaya bisa mobilize socially.
4
115
1
1,307
53,561
my #1 favorite experiment:
1
1
1
68
4,224
Abdi Zihaul retweeted
Southeast Asia is now a $4.5 trillion economy and one of the world’s fastest-growing regions. Yet only about 22 percent of its exports stay within the bloc. Discover more in F&D magazine’s Picture This. imf.org/en/publications/fand…
22
352
29
979
106,441