
Passionate Teessider. Co-founder of @WholeNationCons. @Conservatives campaigner. YIMBY. Keen amateur equestrian. Views my own.
North East, England
Joined September 2012
- Tweets11.2K
- Following1.7K
- Followers876
- Likes50.1K
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
"When the SPS reset is announced tomorrow, we will be told, and expected to believe, that abandoning the right to make our own laws on food and agriculture constitutes some sort of benefit for this country. That puzzles me, and I admit that I am a bit confused by the Government’s negotiating strategy in this reset more generally. In my experience, most negotiations involve giving something that benefits the other side in return for something that benefits you. This negotiation has involved asking for things that benefit the EU in return for conceding things that benefit the EU. It is a novel approach to negotiations.
One must spare a thought for Maroš Šefčovič, my old sparring partner, who must have been a bit flummoxed by this. He has, after all, spent a career negotiating with people who actually wanted to get something from him. He was not in his current job between 2016 and 2018, so he will not have been familiar with British negotiators with this unique negotiating style. But he has adjusted, and was no doubt delighted to discover that the EU single market for food and agriculture could be enlarged without going through any of the inconvenience of giving Britain any say in it.
Mr Šefčovič certainly seemed pretty delighted on Monday, when he spoke at the UK-EU Parliamentary Partnership Assembly of his “intense” “dating schedule” with our negotiator, the Minister, Mr Falconer, who, for his part, said that his role had “felt like a honeymoon”, and that although they were not married,
“the relationship is indeed very close”.
If I may bring a colloquial term into your Lordships’ House, this kind of thing slightly gives me the ick.
Our relationship with the EU is not a marriage. We just went through a long and unnecessarily painful divorce, but the remainer/rejoin establishment, so well represented on the Benches opposite, are still turning up at the ex’s house and desperately trying to bestow gifts in the hope that there will one day be another chance. That is the context in which we must see this SPS deal.
Let us be clear about the problem the Government tried to solve here. British traders face costs at the border, as they do at all kinds of borders and always have. Some of those costs are imposed unnecessarily by our own Government and the others are real, but even Mr Falconer himself claims these are only some tens of millions of pounds per year. If the aim was to reduce that number, why not just reduce or subsidise those costs? Instead, Labour’s way of cutting the paperwork at the border has been to agree that Brussels should write all the paperwork everywhere else and that we should pay it to do so. Dynamic alignment sounds so much better than doing what you are told.
We already have to accept EU food rules in order to sell food in Europe. This agreement is not about that; it is about accepting the rules and transactions which have nothing to do with the European Union. Food and animal exports to the EU are under 1% of this economy. Most British food production never goes anywhere near the EU and only 6% of it goes abroad at all. For most British producers, the effect of the SPS deal will be to remove a barrier between them and a European customer they do not have anyway and to put a new cost between them and a British customer they do have. It has achieved something remarkable and truly innovative: imposing the expense and inconvenience of the EU single market without even having to sell into it.
In all this, we get no say. Of course, British diplomats can turn up and say what they think, but they are then kicked out of the room and the EU gets on with it, and, whatever is agreed, we have to put up with it. In Andy Burnham’s British Food restaurant, there is no menu; the waiter just tells you that you have to have whatever the chef decides. And if you want to leave, apparently you have to pay for that, too.
The Government tell us it is all worth it to get some growth—0.14%, to be precise—in 2040. The DBT methodology note of 22 May last year admits:
“This analysis is not a full cost-benefit analysis of an SPS agreement”.
Too right it is not, for it covers only the benefits and not the costs: the inability to import cheaper food from outside the EU and the inability to reform our own rules and promote innovation. This week, the more serious estimate we had from the Growth Commission says that, over 10 years, there will be about 1% of benefits and 3% of costs—a loss of 2% of GDP and, in 10 years’ time, some £2,400 per household. The savings from less red tape for exporters are going to be dwarfed by higher prices for everyone else.
In 2018, some of the EU’s negotiators were filmed joking that Britain had become the EU’s first colony. Unfortunately, eight years on, it seems that we have a British Government who do not think that that was a joke. The old Colonial Office used to send young men abroad to govern people who had not asked for it. The Government have reversed the arrangements—they send young negotiators abroad to ask Brussels to govern us.
Think about it for a moment. This agreement gives Emmanuel Macron and Friedrich Merz more say over British food and agriculture than the British Prime Minister. How can that be right? Under no pressure at all, the Government have needlessly, gratuitously, unnecessarily chosen to give away this Parliament’s rights to an institution in which we are not represented. They should be ashamed of themselves."
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
This comes just weeks after BOTH the Scotland Secretary and then the First Minister were on apparent trade missions to… India.
Surely then this could have been avoided?
The tariff is now *higher* than before the UK-India trade deal.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
Comparing Britain's growth with the G7 is like a contest to see who can be the fastest snail.
We should be competing at the top of the G20. Instead, countries like Mexico and India are overtaking us!
This can't be the height of our ambition.
A bit of rain isn't stopping @SouthTeesTories getting out on the doorsteps of Hutton ward, Guisborough. Lots more good conversations this afternoon and plenty of support for our fantastic candidate Nick Fardon 💪
11
302
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
I’ll admit, these days I don’t have the time to play video games…
But we should all celebrate the remarkable success of GTA.
You might think it’s yet another US import. You’d be wrong. Grand Theft Auto started in Edinburgh and is still led by Rockstar North in the City - a great example of British innovation and enterprise competing and winning on the world stage.
The last version sold more than 200 million copies worldwide. GTA 6 – released today – has a reported budget of more than £1.2 billion. The biggest budget for a video game in history!
I’ll never shy away from calling out Britain’s problems. But I’ll always celebrate our successes too. Britain’s video games industry supports tens of thousands of skilled jobs, contributes billions to our economy and exports our creativity around the world.
Before entering politics, I was a Finance Director, helping to grow Sky into one of Britain’s biggest businesses. I know what businesses need to flourish. Whether it’s producing TV or video games, we need lower taxes, less red tape and to make it as easy as possible to recruit and develop the next generation of British talent.
I might not be first in the queue for the latest release of GTA, but I’m proud of the role Britain has played in creating it. We need much more of it.
If we want more Rockstars, more Revoluts, more Gymsharks, and more Shazams, we need to give the next generation of innovators and entrepreneurs the tools they need to build their British success story.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
What if I told you that a fifth of people coming here on “Global Talent Visas” aren’t paying a penny of income tax?
Not because they’re getting a tax cut, but because despite being considered exceptional “global talent” they earn less than £12,570!
The Global Talent visa is supposed to bring in only the very best and brightest people. The next Elon Musk. The next Einstein. Not the next welfare recipient.
It sounds mad, but that’s what the Government’s Migration Advisory Committee admitted this week. And the visa is becoming more popular no wonder!
Last year alone, 16,700 of these visas were granted – a new record.
I know previous governments got a lot wrong on immigration; there’s no shying away from that. But let’s be clear now: anyone who comes here should earn enough to support themselves and be a tax net contributor.
The numbers should always be low, that’s why we would set a cap on immigration.
Over the past 4 years, 55,200 people have come here on global talent visas — and as many as 21% in some years earned less than £12,571. That’s ridiculous.
And the median income for main applicants is just £42,800. Barely above the average full-time salary in Britain. And that ignores their often-non-contributing dependents.
That raises a lot of questions.
Why are the salaries so low? Why are large numbers of supposed global talents earning less than half the minimum wage? How are they supporting themselves? Why are they here? And who is making these assessments and getting it so wrong, so often!
We saw how in the past how easily a visa route intended for “skilled” migrants ends up being abused to give visas to curry houses and kebab shops.
The committee estimates that the bottom 20% receiving a global talent visa could actually cost the taxpayer money over their lifetime.
The government should act now to prevent this.
It makes sense to have visas for the very small number of people who are genuinely incredible global talents. People who found businesses worth billions and employing thousands. Creatives like Steven Spielberg, or a scientist who will invent the next cure for cancer.
But immigration has been too high for too long, and it’s the British taxpayer being forced to pay the bill and see their communities change. The rules need to be tough and they need to applied rigorously and with accountability for those making decisions.
As Shadow Chancellor I am working closely with the Shadow Home Secretary to ensure we control and reduce immigration.
The government has shamefully bottled their reforms to ILR, they should act now before things get worse.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
Labour’s manifesto promise was to bring down household energy bills by £300.
How’s that going?
Energy bills forecast to go up by £443 a year from January as UK inflation rises again bbc.in/4C68Kel
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
Britain has sleepwalked into the most extreme abortion laws in the western world.
The government just pardoned a woman who murdered her baby at full term - simply to cover up an affair.
Not a few cells, not a blastocyst, not an unviable foetus, but a full-term healthy baby ready to be born.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
Extraordinary.
If there's suddenly money to cut tuition fees for EU students, why not scrap real interest rates on Plan 2 student loans?
Burnham is putting foreign students ahead of our own young people.
EXCLUSIVE: Andy Burnham has committed to 'significantly reduce' tuition fees for EU students in Britain under his Brexit reset deal.
@JamesCrisp6 and I report that a draft statement drawn up by British officials shows the Prime Minister pushing the compromise ahead of Friday’s EU-UK summit in Brussels.
An EU demand to cut fees has been one of the main sticking points. The UK’s counter-offer would reduce the current international rate of at least £38,000.
Mr Burnham is also keeping the door open to 'equal treatment', which would bring fees down to the £9,970 domestic rate.
Talks are going down to the wire.
Read at the fully story at @Telegraph
telegraph.co.uk/politics/202…
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
'This is, again, Andy vibe coding his way through foreign policy.'
Tom Tugendhat is 'absolutely certain' Britain won’t rejoin the EU in his lifetime.
Watch in full | youtu.be/6DfwI_HyA1g
@TomTugendhat @ShippersUnbound
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
The Prisons Minister blocked my visit to HMP Erlestoke. HMPPS had agreed and arranged it.
Then the Minister’s office blocked it, with no explanation or alternative date - despite two weeks notice.
The Opposition must be able to visit prisons to scrutinise the Government and develop policy.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
So Labour’s position:
4p off gherkins = big benefit for the cost of living
£100 extra for a family holiday = most people won’t even notice a tiny little bit extra
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
Lord Cameron says that one of the benefits of Brexit was the setting up of the MHRA which allows us to be a global leader in medicines, life sciences and developments in treatments and cures.
Our work in genomics, health mapping and rare diseases is world beating.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
For anyone unfamiliar with how long pregnancies are, 39 weeks is full-term. Her baby was just that, a baby. This act is distinguished from infanticide only by the umbilical cord - which it could live without if delivered - and, more importantly, the fact you can't see the baby.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
The UK's fresh productivity data (released yesterday by the ONS) does present a rather awkward data backdrop to the UK-EU summit.
It now reveals that since the Brexit vote in 2016 the UK's productivity performance has accelerated away from comparable EU economies - having largely tracked them (2016-2025) in the previous iteration of this data.
It must call into question the validity of the (widely cited) NBER estimate that Brexit triggered a 3%-4% reduction in UK productivity. We have consistently believed the -ve Brexit impact to be closer to half this level.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
The government are trying to pull a fast one - payments for the EU deal won't be in the text but "negotiated separately" according to Euronews
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
'The more secure you make employment, the more likely it is that someone will stay in employment.' No, Andy. The more secure you make employment, the less likely is that employers will take a chance on hiring someone they can't get rid of.
Miranda Jupp 🧢🌳🏡 retweeted
Excellent thread. Tugendhat is a serious figure































