Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi) header
Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi) profile picture

Lecturer | Financial Economist | Researcher Following, T and RT ≠ endorsement. Views are my own {?}

Joined June 2013
Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)Photo by Daniele Tori (@DrDaToRi)
Happy to share a new publication: “Financial demand as a driver of U.S. housing macro-dynamics: a structural VAR approach, 1996-2019”. #HousingMarket #Macroeconomics #PoliticalEconomy #Finance #SVAR #Housing #Research #Economics #Financialization
1
128
Daniele Tori retweeted
1/ I agree the axiom is innocuous. Completeness and transitivity on their own say very little. That is the point: the ideology isn’t in the axiom. It’s in what the axiom is then asked to carry. Three moves usually follow it, and none of them is innocuous. 🧵
Replying to @tonyannett
The assumption is that people have a preference ordering. They can rank different consumption bundles. A is preferred to B, or B is preferred to A, for example. People are assumed to choose their most preferred feasible consumption bundle. This sounds pretty innocuous to me.
7
21
4
74
9,589
Una storia molto interessante, da non dimenticare. Paper pubblicato su American Economic Review (il top dei top) su cui si basa policy di tetto al #debito sul PIL, smontato da uno (ai tempi) studente. La risposta non è stata pubblicata su AER. #merito #economia #ideologia
A 28-year-old UMass graduate student got a homework assignment to reproduce a famous economics paper, couldn't make the numbers match, and found a spreadsheet mistake in a study that politicians had used to argue for budget cuts. His name is Thomas Herndon. In 2010, two Harvard economists, Carmen Reinhart and Kenneth Rogoff, published a short paper called Growth in a Time of Debt. Its headline finding: once a country's public debt goes above 90% of its economy, growth falls off a cliff. In their numbers, average growth for that group was minus 0.1%. It came out right after the 2008 financial crisis, and it spread fast. In the US, the Paul Ryan budget cited it as its only evidence on what high debt does to growth. In Europe, an EU commissioner pointed to the research in a speech. In Britain, George Osborne cited the authors by name. Herndon was a PhD student at the University of Massachusetts Amherst, taking a class called Econ 753: Applied Econometrics. The big assignment was to pick a well-known paper and replicate it. He picked this one. He couldn't get the same results. He asked the authors for their spreadsheet, and they sent it. When he spotted the problem, he called his girlfriend over to make sure he wasn't seeing things. He wasn't. > One formula stopped five rows short > That quietly left out five countries: Australia, Austria, Belgium, Canada and Denmark > Some available years of data for other countries weren't included > The way the averages were weighted let a single bad year in one country count as much as decades in another Herndon and his professors, Michael Ash and Robert Pollin, published the critique in April 2013. Fixing the problems, average growth for the high-debt countries came out to 2.2%, not minus 0.1%. Reinhart and Rogoff publicly admitted the spreadsheet error. They disputed the other criticisms and defended their broader view. Economists still argue about debt and growth today. But the formula was wrong, and for about three years nobody had publicly caught it. A student doing homework did. Most people assume famous research has been checked many times. Often the first person to really check it is someone with nothing to lose and an assignment due. Have you ever found a mistake in your boss's spreadsheet and kept quiet?
1
65
Daniele Tori retweeted
Nearly a third of statistically significant findings in development economics may be false discoveries In a new NBER working paper, Qingyuan Chai, Kevin Lang, and Liang Zhong question the statistical credibility of randomized controlled trials (RCTs), which have become one of the main tools of modern empirical economics. The authors analyzed 745 tests of primary hypotheses from 190 papers published in leading economics journals and arrived at some rather troubling findings. nber.org/papers/w35999
5
127
11
379
31,808
Daniele Tori retweeted
Replying to @ar888 @ale_caiani
C'è differenza tra "fondi a pioggia" e "premio mediocrità" e confronto tra un sistema che accentra risorse (come se ce ne fosse bisogno) e alternativa che cerca di stimolare un ecosistema più ampio. Bastava soglia minima progetti a 1/2m e avremmo avuto 10 "eccellenze" in più...
1
4
71
Daniele Tori retweeted
"Does High Public Debt Consistently Stifle Economic Growth? A Critique of Reinhart and Rogoff", by Herndon, Ash, and Pollin
1
14
1,789
Daniele Tori retweeted
This is the same argument raised by Colander, Holt and Rosser, that there is no mainstream and that the cutting edge of the profession is moving away from any established consensus. It is problematic for many reasons /1
The fatal challenge to heterodox economics is that there isn't actually orthodox economics. Just take a few recent Nobels: behavioral, information failure, institutions, bubbles, financial fragility, labor monopsony (sort of), Schumpeterian creative destruction, etc. Not to mention RCTs which are emblematic of how much economic research is empirical and only lightly if at all structural. The real difference is methods. Heterodox economics is an avowedly political project not a social scientific effort to better understand the world. And I have nothing against political projects just shouldn't confuse the two.
2
19
76
5,380
Daniele Tori retweeted
Levy Research Associate, Riccardo Bellofiore journeys through Minsky’s work while asking not only how to stabilize an unstable economy, but what kind of economy we aim to stabilize. Read more: tinyurl.com/minskytour #Minsky #economichistory #hetrodoxeconomics @ptcherneva
15
1
38
4,265
I disagree. The NK model will in hindsight be seen as a massive misstep in the history of science. The most successful implementations of the model, an early example is by Smets and Wouters, aeaweb.org/articles?id=10.12… are engineered to fit the data by adding as many ‘shocks’ as observables. The model is identified by imposing untestable restrictions ( see my piece with Andreas Beyer on that point static1.squarespace.com/stat…) and, like the Keynesian models that preceeded it, the model falls apart when estimated on more recent data that was not used to generate the initial parameter estimates. Why does the profession not recognize this? One reason is that there is a large group of macroeconomists of a certain age who have invested their careers in the agenda and have not received their reward in the form of a Nobel Prize. Paraphrasing Max Planck, “science progresses one funeral at a time”. @R2Rsquared @ojblanchard1
And yet, a few of the researchers whose work developed this model have still not been picked for the Nobel prize. Together with IO demand-estimation-merger-analysis, going by influence in debates and policy, it is the most glaring omission in the current prize list.
11
44
15
217
87,341
Gli stessi che vorrebbero mandare i giovani a fare la guerra, poi si scandalizzano per qualche vetrina in frantumi.
157
497
19
2,822
30,801
Daniele Tori retweeted
Pleased to share our new article on the underrepresentation of women in heterodox journals (rosa.uniroma1.it/rosa04/psl_…) just published by PSL Quarterly Review. Our analysis of 14 journals over a 7-year period (376 journal issues, nearly 3,700 articles written by over 5,650 authors, and some 420 editorial positions) found strong evidence of a persistent gender gap which cannot be attributed to numerically fewer heterodox women than heterodox men economists. We contend this under-representation is caused by a dynamic complexity of institutional barriers and social structures causing epistemic injustices that delimit knowledge creation by excluding and marginalising the scholarship and participation of women heterodox scholars and have cascading effects for academic careers.Moreover, the published content – the topics of research fields and ideational development – of heterodox journals become default benchmarks for what ‘counts’ as being heterodox economics. Enduring actions to break women’s underrepresentation are needed although there are several immediate steps that all heterodox economics journals should take. @heterodoxnews @PSLqr
2
1
83
Daniele Tori retweeted
Very preliminary thoughts on the Nobel prize. A prize that celebrates the return of pre-Keynesian, Neo-Wicksellian macroeconomics
1
17
1
93
4,260
[1/4] Hall and Woodford are being awarded the Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel "for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation", that is, for having laid the foundations of the New Keynesian macroeconomic model. However important this may be, ...
1
8
2
47
19,830
1/3 La scelta del premio Nobel per l'economia è criticabile se si considerare la motivazione è quasi comica. Woodford è il padre dei modelli DSGE che NON sono riusciti a spiegare (non a prevedere!) la crisi del 2008, la maggiore dal 1929, e non hanno fornito nessuna policy utile.
BREAKING NEWS The Royal Swedish Academy of Sciences has decided to award the 2026 Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel to Robert E. Hall and Michael Woodford “for microeconomic foundations of macroeconomic stabilisation.” #NobelPrize
12
89
24
377
186,616
Daniele Tori retweeted
No Country Makes Its Own Inflation dlvr.it/TVcM6r
1
3
600