Rethink retweeted
At some point, you have to explain why every country and major institution is supposedly in on it lol
Rethink retweeted
I’m starting to think you could have a conversation with a keto person about absolutely anything to do with carbs and eventually they’ll tell you that your body can make all the glucose it needs. You could be talking about insulin, thyroid function, stress hormones, glycogen, exercise, digestion, protein metabolism, practically anything, and somehow they’ll find a way to tell you that carbs aren’t essential. And if you point out that the brain uses glucose, they’ll tell you it can use ketones. If you explain that it still needs glucose, they’ll tell you the liver makes it. If you ask why making glucose is necessarily better than eating it, they’ll tell you carbs aren’t essential. If you explain that something not being essential for survival doesn’t mean it can’t be beneficial, they’ll tell you the brain can use ketones. And if you explain that nobody was actually arguing about whether you can survive without carbs in the first place, they’ll tell you the liver makes glucose. And round and round we go. Apparently being able to survive without eating carbs settles every possible question about whether eating them might actually be beneficial. You can survive without exercise, sex, sunlight or ever leaving your house too, but I wouldn’t recommend making an entire philosophy out of it. It’s like trying to have a conversation about the benefits of owning a car with someone who keeps interrupting to tell you that humans can walk. Yes, congratulations, we can walk. Nobody was arguing that we couldn’t walk. We’re talking about cars. And the funniest part is that they’ll accuse you of not understanding metabolism while repeating the same three facts over and over again, none of which actually answers anything you’ve said. I’m beginning to think ketosis isn’t just a metabolic state anymore…it’s a conversation you can never escape.
Rethink retweeted
Ken, semaglutide is not a “keto-mimicking drug.” That is low-carb theology trying to annex pharmacology.
GLP-1 drugs reduce appetite and food intake, yes. But they also increase glucose-dependent insulin secretion, suppress glucagon when glucose is elevated, slow gastric emptying, and act through GLP-1 receptors in multiple tissues. Ketosis is not their defining mechanism.
And the study you are dismissing actually looked inside the kidney. In a 52-week randomized placebo-controlled trial, semaglutide reduced renal vascular resistance, slowed fibrosis progression, lowered albuminuria, and produced changes in glomerular endothelial cells consistent with improved vascular health and less inflammatory signaling. (nature.com)
Could weight loss and improved glycemia contribute? Of course. But declaring beforehand that every benefit must simply be “pharmaceutically induced fasting” is not an explanation. It is a belief system.
And there is another inconvenient fact: keto trials do not produce anything close to the weight loss seen with modern GLP-1 and GLP-1/GIP drugs. If these were simply keto-mimicking drugs, the outcomes should look like keto. They do not. Semaglutide and especially tirzepatide produce far greater average weight loss than ketogenic diet trials have shown.
The “sugar-laden toxic shit-storm” line is rhetoric, not physiology. Semaglutide can actually increase insulin secretion in response to glucose.
GLP-1s are not injectable keto diets. Sometimes a receptor agonist actually has receptor-mediated effects.
You have to read the paper before explaining why the paper cannot possibly mean what it found.
Ozempic and other GLP-1s are Keto-mimicking drugs; they don't repair/restore anything.
They provide pharmaceutically-induced fasting, thus decreasing the amount of carbs/sugar/junk that people eat, and prolong fasting time each day.
This increases ketosis levels and allows blood vessels time to heal by removing the sugar-laden, chemical-toxic shit-storm that is the standard diet.
Rethink retweeted
Here's my prediction. Ten years from now, even with these guidelines in place, if every American hit 1.2 to 1.6 (and plenty already do), nobody would be much healthier. Protein is great. It is not a magic nutrient. theconversation.com/2025-was…
Rethink retweeted
Professor Noakes, your personal remission is excellent news. Your attempt to turn it into a universal law of medicine is rather less impressive.
Diabetes remission is not a cure. The disease can recur. And carbohydrate elimination is not a prerequisite for remission.
DiRECT demonstrated remission through substantial weight loss without requiring lifelong carbohydrate elimination. Look AHEAD, which you cite, wasn’t a trial of eliminating carbohydrates at all. It showed improvements in glycemic control and weight, but no significant reduction in cardiovascular events.
And your extraordinary claim that every newly diagnosed person with type 2 diabetes will die of arterial complications unless they eliminate carbohydrates is simply false.
I’ve spent a career treating complications of diabetes, including its vascular consequences. I don’t need a lecture about how devastating the disease can be.
What patients need is evidence-based treatment, not the suggestion that eating carbohydrates sentences them to an early grave.
Your experience is an anecdote. Your certainty is not evidence. And your dietary preference is not a prescription for humanity.
I don't think you understand that diabetes is a completely curable and preventable condition. I have type 2 diabetes, in remission on a carbohydrate elimination diet.
My disease was caused by my genes and by following your idea that carbs are fine, provided you eat unrefined "healthy" carbs.
Monthly in this country, there are 10 000 new cases of Type 2 diabetes. All will die from the arterial complications of diabetes. It is a gruesome death (you may not have witnessed it).
And all will die because they are told by my profession that they don't need to eliminate carbohydrate, that simply by avoiding dietary fats and reducing refined carbs will be enough to manage their disease. That is utterly false and has been repeatedly proven to be wrong - ie misinformation. (See the Look AHEAD Trial)
Please, you obviously do not have the disease and you do not follow those who do.
What you write is criminally-ignorant misinformation, because it will mislead and misinform anyone with diabetes who reads it and condemn them to a progressively worsening quality of life and early death. @LoreofRunning1
Rethink retweeted
What must be understood about High-Intensity Training (aka "Sharpening") - The benefits don't last! 👇
So, the argument goes...
"I only have 3 hours a week to train and I want to maximize my VO2max, what do I do?"
There's a missing dimension in this question - time, i.e.
*When* do you want to maximize your VO2max?
Because the answer to that question will determine the right prescription.
See, the thing is, these papers that show an impressive increase in VO2max with high-intensity training don't continue. They're short. The real question for most of us who care about long-term health and fitness is what happens after the paper is done?
Sure you might see an increase in VO2max from your really bad 35 ml/kg/min VO2max to your still pretty horrible 40 ml/kg/min in 20 weeks, but what happens at 40 weeks? Do I get another 5ml/kg/min? And then another if I just keep up my 3 "bleed from the eyeballs" sessions every week? The papers don't tell you that, but I will, 'cause I've lived it!...
First of all, you stop improving and that sucks!
You're still showing up, hammering yourself 3x a week every week finishing every session completely wasted and you're not getting any better. The stimulus just stops working. You're literally going as hard as you can so you can't just increase the stimulus, you've just got all you can out of it. No matter. You're tough. You'll persist. It'll turn around eventually, right?
Second of all, you start getting worse, and that really sucks!
You're tired. Like really tired. And you've got no base, so the hard sessions are really starting to wear on you. You're just too tired to hit the same power numbers that you were hitting a few months ago. The whole curve takes a nosedive. No matter. You're tough. You'll persist. It'll turn around eventually, right?
Third of all, you get sick or injured & you can't do these sessions anymore and that sucks the most!
When you're trying to do really hard training when you're already really tired, it's a matter of time before stuff breaks. Injuries start to show up, you start to pick up colds and viruses that you'd normally be able to fight off if you weren't so run-down. Your body forces you to take a break.
No matter. No pain, no gain, right? Once you're over this, you'll be back at it. But you're not consistent, so you don't get any better. You just keep banging your head against the wall until you knock yourself out only to wake up and start doing it all over again.
#####
There's a slower, but better way that leads to lasting improvement.
It's called building an aerobic base.
Try it.
Rethink retweeted
Russell Brand - now a convicted rapist - had recently become a darling of the anti vaccine movement, despite having zero medical knowledge or understanding of the issues
He even chaired a session at the MAHA Summit event to support RFK Jr's anti vaccine agenda
What a poor choice of an ally
Russell Brand is convicted of rape and sexual assault charges on allegations dating back more than 20 years. The judge said Brand would receive a prison sentence. apnews.com/article/russell-b…
Rethink retweeted
TURBO CANCER SHOCKER
It doesn't exist.
The NHS just published new cancer registrations for 2024.
1/3
Rethink retweeted
Hallelujah! Donald lame-Duck.
But let’s hope the Looney-Tunes left wing of the Democrat party can be reined in.
At the same time let’s hope Congress will find a way to bring Trump to justice, for his corrupt use of the presidency to enrich himself, for his criminal attempted coup when he lost the 2020 election, and for besmirching the dignity of the presidency.
Rethink retweeted
A doctor is a doctor. Except when he's a crossdresser bringing his fetish to work. Then he's a safeguarding nightmare.
No surprises that Sall is once again being “disingenuous at best”. NSW Health policy (and common sense) is that you cannot request a doctor of your preferred sex in a clinical priority area like an Emergency Department. You can ask for a female chaperone or family member to be present if you must be seen by a male doctor, but a doctor is a doctor.
#theshitsallsays
Rethink retweeted
Another blow for anti-vaxxers as mRNA vaccine helps reduce death rate or return of skin cancer by 42%.
It also reduced the spread of melanoma by 38%
Replying to @Drlipid @nationallipid @foundationofnla @society_eas @ASPCardio @escardio @atherosociety @TheEndoSociety @FamilyHeartFdn
Grifter exposed
Rethink retweeted
FINALLY - THE CASE IS CLOSED - embarrassment that this faulty study was ever published but now is buried where it belongs, in the dust bin of medical nonsense @nationallipid @foundationofnla @society_eas @ASPCardio @escardio @atherosociety @TheEndoSociety @FamilyHeartFdn @fhpatienteurope #cholesterol
Rethink retweeted
How many elite fat-adapted, keto athletes podium’d at Kona this year?
Rethink retweeted
One of my latest PRO
TOC
OLS is to eat like a normal human.
No keto.
No carni.
No LA-phobia.
No fructo-phobia.
No LDL-c denisalism.
No insulin dynamics BS.
NO mentions of bomb calorimetry.
Rethink retweeted
To the anger of trans activists and leftists, the National Health Service England has issued formal new guidance that wards, toilets and changing rooms should be segregated by biological sex, not gender identity. This is 18 months after the UK Supreme Court ruled that under the Equality Act, sex is defined as biological.
Important to remember that the Minnesota Starvation Experiment involved men with an average starting BMI of 21.7, who lost 25% body weight and ended with an average BMI of 16.4. These results can't be extrapolate to people with excess fat mass dieting for weight loss.



































