Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson) header
Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson) profile picture

the government doesn't borrow our savings in order to run a deficit, it runs a deficit so that we can have savings

Surrey, UK
Joined August 2013
Photo by Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson)Photo by Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson)Photo by Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson)Photo by Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson)Photo by Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson)Photo by Robert Pearson (@robert19pearson)
Robert Pearson retweeted
1. Private bank money carries the ultimate promise to settle payments with state money. This makes private bank money a derivative of state money. The fact that a bank can fulfill a depositor's payment instructions by transferring a deposit liability to another bank via netting or settlement in assets other than state money does not negate the underlying promise to settle at par in state money. 2. I would actually say the deposit system is a derivative bolted to THE BOTTOM of state money. There would be no private deposit system denominated in the state’s unit of account without the state establishing that unit of account first. We could all theoretically bank, receive, and pay our state tax credits directly to the state without a private deposit system. We could not, however, get and pay our state tax credits without a state. The dependency is one-way. That is why the deposit system is the derivative layer. The fact that banks can expand their balance sheets horizontally before seeking reserves vertically does not flip the ontological hierarchy. 3. Deposits are only “every bit as good” as central bank money if they're insured by the state. You might be fine with uninsured deposits, most are not. The fact that the insurance payout does not pay in state money but in another deposit with the same promise is not evidence that deposits are every bit as good as state money. The existence of the insurance, however, is evidence that private bank money is not “every bit as good as” state money. 4. This is NOT to say that private bank deposits are claims on the state. They are, however, “claims on state money” in the same sense that my ticket, bought from a third-party vendor, gives me a claim to a seat in the football stadium. If I told you that I have a seat for a Sunday night game you would correct me and say: “No, all you have is a promise by the third party vendor to a seat at the game. The stadium has no obligation to you.” You would be technically correct, but few would want to be your friend. 🙂 Then you would go on to say: “But, your third party ticket is every bit as good as a ticket directly bought from the stadium”. You’d be incorrect and have even fewer friends, because now you're inconsistent too.
6
7
14
242
Robert Pearson retweeted
U2 release their cover of Old Ned (theme from Steptoe & Son)
138
431
58
2,056
244,852
Robert Pearson retweeted
If we define central bank money as balances on banks’ settlement accounts at the CB and private bank money as balances on accounts held with private banks, then both types of money are created when the government makes payment to the non-bank private sector and destroyed when a payment is made in the opposite direction. It's a fairly reasonable definition too. It would make little sense to count the tax credits returned to the issuer, that the issuer can issue at no cost, as something the issuer now “has”. A simple DEB example illustrates this. Starting at zero. The government makes a transfer to the PS of its tax credits. It now has two balancing entries on its BS. When the tax credits return, the cancelling entries are made. Total four entries. End balance zero. Some would consider that “ceasing to exist”.
3
5
1
14
375
Robert Pearson retweeted
For those wondering what was the cause of the global Microsoft Outlook problem this simple, easy to understand video has been produced to explain the issue in plain language.
37
73
7
272
13,128
I know some will skip this sort of thing and I do not blame you. Economics can be a boring, technocratic basket of bullshit. But accounting is science. The rules of accounting are very important. As an MMTer,I dont play games like the government borrows from the central bank whatever… I follow the accounting. If you do that, you will understand the world around you so much better than the narratives surrounding macroeconomics. Really the lies told by the media, politicians and even the framing errors of our friends. This paper is one of the best at explaining federal finance, how banks function under state charters and how article 1 section 8 of the USC show the power of the purse is in the hands of congress. They authorize the spending of NEW money into existence. They also authorize the taxation that serves to delete money from the economy by purging reserves in the inner banking system. Eric Tymoigne and Scott Fullwiler… Randall Wray… definitely names to follow to understand the banking system. Not necessarily asking for their insights on voting, but they are the masters of understanding fiat systems and the legal frameworks that make money move. As a ML, banking is probably the last thing most think of in this space, even though Lenin said without seizing the state's banks, and thus money creation, socialism would not be possible. There are some who conflate the Fed as private. Bad move. It also gives the false impression that the power of capital doesn't control both the “private” and the “public”. Its a silly distinction that nets out some really silly narratives that often bring me to cross purposes with friends and allies. If you ever just want to understand… here is a link vital to understanding the system vs the Coolio theories that pass for knowledge around the water cooler. Money & Banking | New Economic Perspectives share.google/iOYCRHTcA7AJzKJ…
4
55
1
123
2,799
"Government debt" is a column in an account. Flip to the other side, and it's private wealth: superannuation holdings, bank assets, savings. Every dollar of the debt is someone's asset. You can't pay it all down without taking that wealth off someone. #MMT
10
23
2
55
1,881
Robert Pearson retweeted
Higher rates mean higher cost of doing business, but higher rates also mean a massive fiscal add to support the higher cost. We are now in the early innings of a rate induced inflationary cycle. At this point, hikes are acting pro-cyclically, not counter.
"Sticky" inflation continues as Core CPI rose +0.3% in October vs +0.2% expected. Treasury has paid $583.9 billion of interest on securities YTD, up from $506.9 billion during the same period last year (+15.2%). Rate hikes won't fix inflation.
9
20
4
72
3,941
So why tax at all? Four reasons, none of them funding. #MMT It creates demand for the currency. It withdraws spending power when the economy is running hot. It reshapes distribution. And it discourages things we want less of. Those are real jobs. "Raising revenue" isn't one.
8
58
1
142
3,805
Robert Pearson retweeted
16
87
4
575
10,618
Robert Pearson retweeted
Just remember: 1. Spending creates income. 2. Loans create deposits. 3. Taxes do not fund spending. 4. Government deficits create non-government financial surpluses. 5. Real resources, not money, constrain sovereign government spending.
85
202
29
610
105,692
Robert Pearson retweeted
If you add a 0 to the end of everyones money (cash/debts), then prices will increase roughly 10x. If you double everyones money (cash/debt), prices will increase roughly 2x if you increase everyones cash/debt by 4%, prices will.... Interest rates just change the scale.
7
5
14
546
Robert Pearson retweeted
Replying to @PatriciaNPino
It will add a small amount to UK deficit spending/aggregate demand/etc. and push up forward prices a bit as well.
5
20
487
Robert Pearson retweeted
Loved this joke: Just imagine, Soros, with his relatively modest fortune, somehow controls the entire world, orchestrates revolutions, and is behind every single political event. Meanwhile, Musk, with his trillion-dollar fortune, couldn’t even get a Republican elected in Texas. HOW DOES THAT WORK?
7
12
1
39
1,561
Robert Pearson retweeted
My presentation "Chartalism and Money Theory: State and Beyond." Main point: Charta means token not state + old historical roots + has methodological and practical implications for the analysis and set up of monetary systems. youtube.com/watch?v=9y8r5CIb…
19
54
2,153
Robert Pearson retweeted
On TARGET2 The fan club of the ever-hysterical Robin Brooks is coming after me. So let’s use a simple example to explain what TARGET2 actually is and how its balances arise. Suppose an Italian buyer pays €100 to a German seller. The payment goes through, but the Bank of Italy ends up with a €100 liability to the ECB. Sounds paradoxical, doesn’t it? But these are two entirely different kinds of obligations. Let's break it down. 1. An Italian transfers €100 to a German. €100 is debited from the Italian buyer's bank account. €100 is credited to the German seller's bank account. The payment is complete. The Italian buyer owes the German seller nothing. Before going further, we need to understand something about modern monetary systems. There are two types of money relevant to this example: Commercial bank deposits: the money households and businesses use to pay for goods and services. Central bank reserves: the money commercial banks hold at their central banks and use to settle payments between themselves. 2. What happens at the central bank level? The Italian commercial bank holds reserves at the Bank of Italy, while the German commercial bank holds reserves at the Bundesbank. When €100 moves from Italy to Germany, the balance sheets of the two central banks change. Here's what happens: BANK OF ITALY 🇮🇹 Reserve liabilities to commercial banks: −€100 TARGET liability to the ECB: +€100 BUNDESBANK 🇩🇪 Reserve liabilities to commercial banks: +€100 TARGET claim on the ECB: +€100 Notice something important. The Bank of Italy has not increased its total liabilities by €100. It has simply replaced one liability with another. Before the payment, it owed €100 in reserves to the Italian commercial bank. After the payment, it owes €100 to the ECB through TARGET. Meanwhile, the Bundesbank has acquired a new €100 liability to the German commercial bank. To balance its books, it simultaneously acquires a €100 financial asset: a claim on the ECB. This is precisely how the ECB and the Bundesbank explain the accounting. 3. Why can't we just transfer the money and forget about it? Because the euro is a single currency, but national central banks maintain separate balance sheets. If Italy and Germany operated under a single central bank with one consolidated balance sheet, this would simply be a transfer of reserves between two commercial banks. But since the Bank of Italy and the Bundesbank have separate balance sheets, an additional accounting entry is needed to record the movement of reserves between them. That's what TARGET does. 4. What if someone in Germany transfers €100 back to Italy tomorrow? Everything happens in reverse. The Bank of Italy's TARGET liability decreases by €100, while the Bundesbank's TARGET claim falls by €100. Assuming no other transactions, both TARGET balances return to their original positions. Here's the key takeaway: TARGET records net settlement flows between national central banks within the Eurosystem. It does not represent unpaid debts of Italian buyers to German sellers, nor does it mean the Italian government has borrowed money from Germany. And this brings us to a much more interesting question: If the Bank of Italy can maintain a negative TARGET balance indefinitely while remaining in the Eurosystem, why would it need to repay it at all? And here's the most fascinating part: Much of the enormous TARGET imbalances accumulated since 2015 were actually driven by the Eurosystem's own asset purchases under the ECB's quantitative easing programs!
Every time I read Brooks’s tweets, I can’t help but facepalm. In a debate about Germany potentially leaving the eurozone, TARGET2 liabilities have somehow magically turned into Italian and Spanish government debt owed to Berlin. But TARGET2 balances are intra-Eurosystem positions between central banks, not loans between governments. Germany leaving the euro would not, in itself, oblige the Italian and Spanish governments to issue sovereign debt to settle those balances.
18
74
10
233
28,612
Robert Pearson retweeted
Indeed.
4
8
139
Robert Pearson retweeted
To be clear, MV=PY is an accounting identity when velocity is defined as nominal GDP divided by the money stock. It tells us that MV=PY because V=PY/M. Without additional behavioral assumptions about velocity, real output, and monetary dynamics, the equation has no independent explanatory power regarding the causes of inflation.
2
12
39
2,091
Unfortunately Craig confuses bank capital with assets. Bank capital is not an amount of money banks must have in order to lend, as Craig seems to think. It is the equity cushion a bank must have to protect depositors from losses in the event of insolvency. Banks do not lend out money they already have. They create the money they lend. This increases their leverage, since the money they create is a liability to them, and reduces the equity cushion as a percentage of assets. Bank capital requirements dampen lending by preventing banks running down their equity cushions. Banks obtain funding to settle deposit withdrawals, including loan drawdowns. I too spent many years building banking and financial systems. That's how I know banks don't lend out depositors' money or check reserve levels before lending. And why I know the difference between bank capital with assets.
I spent 35 years building banking systems for banks worldwide, including central banks. I know how banks decide where their money goes. When you build systems, you have to make them work, so you have to know how they work. The Basel Committee de-industrialised the countries that adopted its rules. It's that simple: I explain the whole complicated mechanism in my essay. They simply regulated it away because that was the most profitable thing to do. It was implemented in such a systemic global way, and nobody seemed to notice Capital is what a bank must hold before it can lend, the way a manufacturer or miner must hold supplies before it can sell. No miner doubles their costs to serve one group of customers. But that's what the banking system does to miners and manufacturers. Since 1988, the Basel rules have required banks to hold twice the capital against a factory loan as against a home loan, and under Basel III the gap reaches five times. So banks lend less to industry and more against houses. It should be stopped tomorrow. Manufacturing's share of GDP fell in ten of the eleven countries I examined. In Australia it fell from 13.7% to 5.4%. Every other country that followed fell as well. The only truly crafty ones were the Koreans, who did a good job of offsetting it. Regulators were warned in writing that the rule would steer credit, and they adopted it anyway. No parliament voted for it, and it's simply too dumb to keep doing, but we do . Not today; there is no justification. Yet from India, across Europe, across the US, including Australia, sanctions against industrial capacity. Financialization has gone too far it needs to be reviewed . The charge is manslaughter by gross negligence. The mechanism is proven. Same Rules, Different Ruins:ctindale.substack.com/p/same…
6
15
88
5,733
Robert Pearson retweeted
Replying to @DHughesy
The “national debt” does not have to be paid back. How much is issued as spending and recovered as revenue is entirely up to the govt. Bond holders aren’t creditors. When their bonds mature their treasury debt is just converted into central bank debt.
6
7
3
16
2,191
Robert Pearson retweeted
Replying to @ShangguanJiewen
Though NO citizen of a sovereign country 'owes' ANY 'govt debt' of course. It's just a record of what govt spent into the economy, not a 'debt' that has to be paid back to anyone.
6
7
651